fair in war

Whether Shamit voted out kirti or arijit voted out shamit or rex voted out arijit...........either All the decisions are correct or all are wrong.

But according to me "everything is fair in war". After all it is a question of earning 1 crore, a car as well as lot of fame.

So I think everything is fair. Who in their normal mindset will allow somebody else to win. when i play a game i want to win. So do fame gurukul students.

they want to win by hook or crook.

all i ahv 2 say iz...this show is totally gettin on my nerves 😡

Originally posted by: anna_ps

they want to win by hook or crook.

I don't think it is as plain as that. First of all, the students wre simply handed the voting right -they were never asked to confine themselves to the criterion of talent; that's why it was very, very upsetting for me to watch Shankar's anger-filled comments to the students when Kirti was voted out-he didn't even let the students clarify their stand(remember his dry statement? "did you think Gurpreet sang better than Kirti? Yes or no? That's all"-I think that was very unfair.

And then, Ila strengthens the students' stand by saying that they may use any criterion for voting-including the desire to carve out their own path. And then finally JA repeats that. But we, the forum participants , create a huge furor when the students take a decision which seems wrong to us- the faculty and the judges have the obligation to maintain the fairness of the race;but, not the students; it is time we accept this fact.

I think the show should now be called 'Shame Gurukul'. 😛
I had a lot of expectations from this show after 'Indian Idol'. But the show has now been degraded into a cheap fiasco - no singing talent in sight - only dirty politics and mud slinging. It amazes me that people like Javed Akhtar openly engage in slanging contests.
What really concerns me is that someone like Qazi who is at best a bathroom singer is going to be a FJ- thanks to the great Indian junta.This show is getting on my nerves now and it is time people chose to spend their time doing something worthwhile instead of watching this utterly ridiculous show.