Does Karan deserve it?

trina_saras thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Does Karan deserve to be punished for seeing Kangana and not telling anyone? On the one hand, noone forced her into this relationship. But on the other, Karan knows how dangerous his friend is and always has been. How long can he go on with this charade?

I mean, just getting a few phone calls from her in Shourya's room was enough to make him sweat bullets. 😆

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

2.6k

Users

8

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

Preternatural thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I know right? The guy who gets scared with just few phone calls how will he continue the relationship hiding it from Kangana's family.
Dolly-heart thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Karan was one of the four Rapist. So yes he does deserve punishment.

Karan knows how dangerous Shaurya really is and his stupidity show that by keeping it hidden from Shaurya and the Goenka's is going to get him into trouble.

My question is does Kangana know that Karan was one of the Rapist and now a co- conspirator in an attempt to murder Dev.

I think Durga should target Karan after she has dealt with Shehkar.

Karan has to pay for these crimes and deserves punishment.
Dolly-heart thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
@ Abray. I am not sure if he was the one that helped Payal escape.

He was there and by association he is guilty.

I am sure Kangana knows that there was a case against her brother and that he was cleared.

Is she smart enough to know that there is smoke only if there is a fire ?? I don't know.

Was Kangana curious enough to ask Karan about the whole debacle as he is such a close friend of her brother?

And yes, Akash has to alert Durga as to Shaurya always hanging out with Karan and maybe keep an eye on Karan and his activities.

There are too many questions and the answers are slow to come forward.

A frustrating but interesting serial.😕
cherrypansy thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Karan scared of Goenka's and hiding his affair with Kangana is an example of double standards...for goenka's their daughter is daughter who should be protected, respected and given a respectable life whereas other girls do not deserve this...they very well know Shaurya but still are huntimg a well educated, beautiful girl from a respectable family...
bangles thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Karan has a big part to play in Shaurya's crimes.
He has always stayed in the background but has been the one to push, instigate and 'challenge' (make bets) Shaurya into his misdeeds.
I find Karan to be cowardly character- always hiding behind Shaurya. Recently , despite having misgivings, he has decided to support Shauarya in causing Dev's accident.

He was one of the rapists and he is an accessory to attempt to murder .

Why should he escape punishment?
Preternatural thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Dolly-heart

@ Abray. I am not sure if he was the one that helped Payal escape.


He was there and by association he is guilty.

I am sure Kangana knows that there was a case against her brother and that he was cleared.

Is she smart enough to know that there is smoke only if there is a fire ?? I don't know.

Was Kangana curious enough to ask Karan about the whole debacle as he is such a close friend of her brother?

And yes, Akash has to alert Durga as to Shaurya always hanging out with Karan and maybe keep an eye on Karan and his activities.

There are too many questions and the answers are slow to come forward.

A frustrating but interesting serial.😕


I agree So many questions had arisen after knowing that Karan-Kangana affair🥱
trina_saras thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Dolly-heart

Karan was one of the four Rapist. So yes he does deserve punishment.


Karan knows how dangerous Shaurya really is and his stupidity show that by keeping it hidden from Shaurya and the Goenka's is going to get him into trouble.

My question is does Kangana know that Karan was one of the Rapist and now a co- conspirator in an attempt to murder Dev.

I think Durga should target Karan after she has dealt with Shehkar.

Karan has to pay for these crimes and deserves punishment.



I think Kangana knows about the case and therefore that Karan was involved. It was all over the news. She most likely doesn't know about the coverup just like Suchitra and Dev, she believes her brother is innocent like a lot of gullible people. Because if she knew about her brother's guilty past, why would she want to get involved with a friend of his? Why would anyone? I dont think she knows about any of Karan's truths if she doesn't know about Shourya's. She seems fairly young, and since this case was two years ago am assuming she was in high school at the time.


Yeah, Karan knows how dangerous Shourya really is, but that didn't stop him from setting him up when Rajnath asked him to and keeping it a secret. He could have warned him about that but he didnt.


I agree, she needs to target Karan after Shekhar and then see how it affects Shourya.


I think I have been misleading with my title. I didnt mean does Karan deserve to be punished for the rape, that is an absolute yes. What I meant was does he deserve to be punished for hiding the affair from the Goenka family when his girlfriend is equally involved. Whatever Shourya has done with girls in the past is am sure a well-kept secret. Because of his power and influence.
Dolly-heart thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9


I think Kangana knows about the case and therefore that Karan was involved. It was all over the news. She most likely doesn't know about the coverup just like Suchitra and Dev, she believes her brother is innocent like a lot of gullible people. Because if she knew about her brother's guilty past, why would she want to get involved with a friend of his? Why would anyone? I dont think she knows about any of Karan's truths if she doesn't know about Shourya's. She seems fairly young, and since this case was two years ago am assuming she was in high school at the time.


Yeah, Karan knows how dangerous Shourya really is, but that didn't stop him from setting him up when Rajnath asked him to and keeping it a secret. He could have warned him about that but he didnt.


I agree, she needs to target Karan after Shekhar and then see how it affects Shourya.


I think I have been misleading with my title. I didnt mean does Karan deserve to be punished for the rape, that is an absolute yes. What I meant was does he deserve to be punished for hiding the affair from the Goenka family when his girlfriend is equally involved. Whatever Shourya has done with girls in the past is am sure a well-kept secret. Because of his power and influence.


Since there was not much info on Kangana we are guessing most of it.

I would be curious if such an allegation was put on my brother and then knowing that her now boy friend Karan is such a good friend , I would ask questions.

Karan is a slime ball of a friend no doubt. But when Rajnath asked him to take him out for the night he did not know that Rajnath was going to set up his friend, he thought Shaurya was his old self going after any girl he fancies.

And Karan will get into trouble with the Goenka's for secretly dating Kangana because Shaurya and the the Goenka's knows that Karan was involved in the rape case.

And they will want to protect her because she of course is one of their own.

And Karan is really playing with fire dating a Psycho's sister knowing Shaurya is capable of murder.

I personally would love to see Shaurya find out and see what he will do to Karan.

Does Shaurya even love his sister or will he not care just like he does not care about his father. Because he blackmailed him without any thought of what his father has done for him.

I guess we wait and see what the writers have in store for us.

trina_saras thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Dolly-heart



I think Kangana knows about the case and therefore that Karan was involved. It was all over the news. She most likely doesn't know about the coverup just like Suchitra and Dev, she believes her brother is innocent like a lot of gullible people. Because if she knew about her brother's guilty past, why would she want to get involved with a friend of his? Why would anyone? I dont think she knows about any of Karan's truths if she doesn't know about Shourya's. She seems fairly young, and since this case was two years ago am assuming she was in high school at the time.


Yeah, Karan knows how dangerous Shourya really is, but that didn't stop him from setting him up when Rajnath asked him to and keeping it a secret. He could have warned him about that but he didnt.


I agree, she needs to target Karan after Shekhar and then see how it affects Shourya.


I think I have been misleading with my title. I didnt mean does Karan deserve to be punished for the rape, that is an absolute yes. What I meant was does he deserve to be punished for hiding the affair from the Goenka family when his girlfriend is equally involved. Whatever Shourya has done with girls in the past is am sure a well-kept secret. Because of his power and influence.


Since there was not much info on Kangana we are guessing most of it.

I would be curious if such an allegation was put on my brother and then knowing that her now boy friend Karan is such a good friend , I would ask questions.

Karan is a slime ball of a friend no doubt. But when Rajnath asked him to take him out for the night he did not know that Rajnath was going to set up his friend, he thought Shaurya was his old self going after any girl he fancies.

And Karan will get into trouble with the Goenka's for secretly dating Kangana because Shaurya and the the Goenka's knows that Karan was involved in the rape case.

And they will want to protect her because she of course is one of their own.

And Karan is really playing with fire dating a Psycho's sister knowing Shaurya is capable of murder.

I personally would love to see Shaurya find out and see what he will do to Karan.

Does Shaurya even love his sister or will he not care just like he does not care about his father. Because he blackmailed him without any thought of what his father has done for him.

I guess we wait and see what the writers have in store for us.



It's true that when Rajnath asked Karan to take his friend out he didn't know the reason behind it, but at the same time he asked him to not reveal that he spoke with him so that in itself is fishy. I mean, so what if he spoke to his friend's dad and then took him out? The fact that Rajnath asked him to take Shourya to a club and not just any club but a specific one is already a red flag, and then keep the entire details of their conversation to himself? Karan isn't as stupid as he looks. He didn't need to have known about Urvashi, all he knew is that Rajnath had reasons for needing his son to go out that night. He is smart enough to know not to ask Rajnath anything at this point.


Karan is playing with fire, agreed. But they all are. Raj and Raima are playing with it by hiding their affair from Sakshi. Durga is playing with it by setting up Dev and Shourya against each other as well as by plotting against Shourya's parents. Gautam and Sonali are doing it by helping Dev. Kangana is doing it by going with a hard core criminal that she thinks is her brother's close friend and hiding it from her parents. Shourya, by going after Durga not knowing her real identity and then making mistakes like showing his true feelings in front of her. Shekhar, by helping Sakshi dig into Durga's past. And finally Raima, by using both Raj and Sakshi to her benefit and getting involved in Sakshi's little schemes.


I am not sure Shourya will care for the right reasons. I mean, he won't not care because it's his sister. But I think the part that will make him angry isn't that his sister is being played with by this guy, but the fact that it was hidden from him and it will hurt his ego.


Shourya was always kind of psychotic, like when he was at the gym and he was being baited by one of the guys for not winning the bet against Durga he lost his temper very quickly. The only time he was ever not himself was when he tried to act all "professional" during his presentation like his dad told him to and then Durga was suspicious at this sudden change of heart. But his true character comes out and he is never able to keep a smooth exterior like his parents.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".