Was Sumo really wrong? - An aftermath of watching re-runs

_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Hello people...Hope you all are having a great sunday. Well I dont know what prompted me to make this post but just a few days back while watching the re-runs I was thinking that how the forum made a hue and cry when during the wedding track Sumo disapproved of Aditya's closeness. Many said that Sumo is misleading Aditya and sadly even I felt that she was doing wrong with Aditya. I feel so sorry at my own self for thinking that. Really was Sumo so wrong when she told Aditya that she wasnt comfortable in getting intimate with him before marriage? Or she was uncomfortable in saying I love you? Or even if she had hidden feelings for someone else or she had an ex (not exactly) she wanted to move on from? Did all this make her any wrong for Aditya? And now I can strongly say NO! It never did. How in the world Aditya's stupid expectations made her at fault?

In our country we have been born and brought up in an arranged marriage setup. Even Aditya and Suman were having an arranged marriage where there was attraction just from one side. And most of the girls are not comfortable with getting intimate in an arranged marriage setup before taking the plunge for not just emotional reasons but safety reasons too. And here I am talking about modern girls like us. Yes we exist! Even the court of law can blame a partner of not being able to satisfy the other's sexual needs "post marriage"? Then how does Sumo denying Aditya an ILU or a kiss made her any wrong for him? She had earlier only told to him that she will take time to get there as all this is new to her. And it was the jerk who didn't have enough sensitivity or sensibility to understand that she was just nursing a bad past. And in case he didnt want a girl with baggage, he like a spineless man he wad always been could have opted out of the alliance. But he went a step ahead and proved how he was so much more disgusting than we all knew. It's heart-wrenching some even went to the level of justifying Aditya's act against Sumo's apathy or Shravan's lie. Which is why Namik was appalled and made it to twitter saying "Nothing can justify assault"...I understood his anger then only but the impact, I realized off late.

And in all this the only conclusion I could draw was that Aditya was a jerk of the highest levels. He not only eyed Sumo's modesty but continuously invaded her personal space too because as a typical MCP he thought that being her fiance he owned her...even her feelings and choices 🤢 I feel sad someone even compared Shravan's act to that of Aditya because what Shravan did was nothing but a weak moment. The weak moment of a betrayed and trodden down son. It was unfortunate that in his junoon he didn't realize that his own best friend came in the line of fire. The pain of losing his mom and love together in one go made him go insane. And though he too was terribly wrong but nowhere comparable to the heinous act done by Aditya.

As for Sumo, I believe if she ever wronged anyone by saying YES to Aditya, It was Shravan 😭 So many times she herself confessed that she knew Shravan loved her. Even when Shravan used to be Jealous of Aditya during PreeKar wedding track she would internally know why he is acting that way and still when he took up a fight with her, all she could do was pity herself for not knowing his "true feelings" and believing he hates her? LIke really woman? Not even once she tried to know what went wrong with a guy who till the last day was consoling her and saying he would stand tall by her side forever. She believed his words at face value and dissed all his love she herself had felt always (even read his letter). She didn't even think what he will do alone when she will be gone despite she had all the idea how Ramnath would destroy his life. And this wrong of Sumo really made her too eligible for if not an equal but a very strong apology from Shravan. To our misfortune, that never happened 💔

But all I can say is in that whole fiasco if there was anyone who was the real anti-hero...It was Aditya. ShraMan were both flawed and perfectly so for each other. Only they had the ability to rinse off each other's flaws and forgive each other too. Only they had that much love to make up for the wrongs they did to each other. And amidst all this, Aditya's angle was a mare mirage to our society's chauvinism.


Edited by Malika - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

832

Users

8

Likes

40

Frequent Posters

LubnaK786 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Hey Malika,
I totally agree with you. What Aditya did was what he was, an insecure fiance who couldn't accept the fact that she had a past. And she does not reciprocate his feelings. Sumo was not wrong at all, you cannot just say I Love You to someone who you don't love and specially like you said in an arranged marriage. It takes time and she accepted it and was ready to give it a chance, anyways she didn't have any option.

Even though Shravan was wrong by saying what he said, it cannot in anyway justify what Aditya did. You wont' believe that during the wedding preparations of Aditya and Suman I felt that Shravan says that his relation with Sumo was more than that of a husband and wife, of course not like that in a way that was shown on the show, but I was thinking he should tell him in away how he knows Sumo inside out, because husband and wife relation doesn't mean just physical.

Both Sumo and Shravan were flawed and at fault. Everyone says that Sumo didn't confess or said sorry to Shravan which is right though, but I feel the makers didn't let her, they might have shot it but edited in the end because of lack of time. They were in such a hurry that they only showed Shravan's apology and his confession, they didn't even show her confession. I don't think the way Sumo's character was she wouldn't have confessed. The makers didn't do justice to both Shravan and Sumo's character in the end. I really wish they give us Season 2 so we get to see what was left unsaid.

Great post Malika, this is the first time I felt like talking about it.


Lubna.
Arpi1234 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Actually ba***** like aditya wants vergin girls doesn't matter how many affairs they themselves must have.. . Why he was forcing sumo to say ILU, does he know anything about what love is?... Love is trust, love is respect, love means faith but did He trust suman? No, he believed what Shravan said.. Hell he went on to molest a girl just that she had a past (instigated by Shravan)... where was his respect for suman at that moment?... On the other hand sumo is more or less a selfish Self centered girl who can't think beyond her family, her nanaji, her Mother, everything about her... Where is Shravan in her life... She is always taken him for granted.. She only thanks Shravan as Ramu kaka's son(not her friend) , that's why when Ramnath told her to stay away from Shravan she gave up on him so easily... I think she is more guilty than Shravan in their relationship because for Shravan she is the first person in his life but for sumo he is not...
EmeraldStar thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Agree with u..well said👍🏼
_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: LubSha

Hey Malika,

I totally agree with you. What Aditya did was what he was, an insecure fiance who couldn't accept the fact that she had a past. And she does not reciprocate his feelings. Sumo was not wrong at all, you cannot just say I Love You to someone who you don't love and specially like you said in an arranged marriage. It takes time and she accepted it and was ready to give it a chance, anyways she didn't have any option.

Hey Lubna ..thanks for the comment 🤗
And I have to say I concur with you! She genuinely tried to give it a chance which is why she was even ready to give up on her dream, her PCT (which she never even gave up for Shravan) just to make that marriage work. Also I think she put a lot of hope in Aditya because he was Nirmala's son..she did say it to Preeta...she was happy to get a mother like figure in the form of MIL. These things very well showed that just for Nanu she was ready to give her everything to make this loveless marriage work. I dont see anything wrong in this. Most of the girls in our country do this in an arranged marriage. And she only wanted her feelings/intimacy for Aditya to come naturally over time but he was an asshole.

Even though Shravan was wrong by saying what he said, it cannot in anyway justify what Aditya did. You wont' believe that during the wedding preparations of Aditya and Suman I felt that Shravan says that his relation with Sumo was more than that of a husband and wife, of course not like that in a way that was shown on the show, but I was thinking he should tell him in away how he knows Sumo inside out, because husband and wife relation doesn't mean just physical.

Apparently! It wa s a pretty risky statement actually because the way you interpret it defines the kind of mentality you have 😆 The cvs played very smart there What Shravan said didnt 'define' him in anyway but the way Aditya interpreted it was what defined him. Shravan's only mistake was that he lied.

Both Sumo and Shravan were flawed and at fault. Everyone says that Sumo didn't confess or said sorry to Shravan which is right though, but I feel the makers didn't let her, they might have shot it but edited in the end because of lack of time. They were in such a hurry that they only showed Shravan's apology and his confession, they didn't even show her confession. I don't think the way Sumo's character was she wouldn't have confessed. The makers didn't do justice to both Shravan and Sumo's character in the end. I really wish they give us Season 2 so we get to see what was left unsaid.

Yup I wish we got the whole thing! Both ShraMan needed to realize their mistakes and not just realize but make up for them. And now I feel the kind of built up that was given that track would have been so amazing. It's late I have realized that how much we criticized our show but the cvs were amazing with their script skills. The intricacies of Aditya-Sumo-Nirmala-Shravan equation were master-strokes and some real brilliant writing. Now that I see shows like beyhad, KRPKAB or many new shows on tv, even the trip the lazy writing literally irritates me, EDKV had one helleva amazing writing team.

Great post Malika, this is the first time I felt like talking about it.

Thankyou Lubna 😊


Lubna.

Edited by Malika - 8 years ago
KitkitMkb thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Good post!
I agree with whatever you said but there is one thing I'd like to pinpoint. Sumo's biggest flaw has always been that she does not realise the consequences of her actions and if she does the damage has already been done. This is why when she wanted to make Shravan feel jealous by "using" Aditya, I was really not for it, because both would have been hurt at the end. Thankfully, she didn't get to do something extreme.
Another thing, Sumo has been blamed for, is ignoring Shravan, we know the reasons and I wish she had been more understanding towards him, some people also said that she should have told him after Preekar's marriage. But why would she tell him ?
He had broken all his relationships with her, he didn't even want to see her face. So on this part I completely understood her.
Lately I have realised something, let's imagine if the roles were reversed and Ramnath would have not given his permission to Shravan to confess his feelings to Sumo, we all know it he would have chosen his father and he would ignore Sumo in the same way otherwise he wouldn't be able to control his feelings.
He would have done the exact same thing and Sumo would have chased him in the same way.
I don't know if this makes sense but it's incredible how even after months we are able to discuss this show.
LubnaK786 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Hey Malika,
I totally agree with you that the CV's did an amazing job with their writing. I said this in my message to Sony that "Once you get used to the highlife there is no looking back", there is no other show like this, and I'm not going back to watch those nonsensical shows again. Can't believe I stopped watching TV.
Just want our EDKV magic back. We can disagree on some things but still no CV's like them and no show like EDKV. 👍🏼

Lubna.

vimikrao thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Nice post Maliila

Even I agree with you If Shravan is guilty than Suman also equally guilty...she can give any excuses she is orphan she got her family they gave her shelter she can't be selfish thinking herself not about Preeti..usse karz chukana hai becuase unhone usse sahara diya, pyaar diya this that whatever reason...but she knew Shravan loves her but for Shravan he was not aware of all these he is clueless about her promise to Ramnath for him she is betrayed her so his attitude towards her is justified to him...Shravan is wrong he shouldn't tell about Sumo to Aditya but what he did to Sumo is not justify his act but he got good answer from Shravan... They portrayed Suman's character mahan where Shravan character guilty..he asked her apology for his behaviour he confessed he loved her but Sumo she didn't confess nor she apologised when she is also equally fault...because of abrupt ending they have destroyed beauty of the show...
Arpi1234 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: KitkitMkb

Good post!
I agree with whatever you said but there is one thing I'd like to pinpoint. Sumo's biggest flaw has always been that she does not realise the consequences of her actions and if she does the damage has already been done. This is why when she wanted to make Shravan feel jealous by "using" Aditya, I was really not for it, because both would have been hurt at the end. Thankfully, she didn't get to do something extreme.
Another thing, Sumo has been blamed for, is ignoring Shravan, we know the reasons and I wish she had been more understanding towards him, some people also said that she should have told him after Preekar's marriage. But why would she tell him ?
He had broken all his relationships with her, he didn't even want to see her face. So on this part I completely understood her.
Lately I have realised something, let's imagine if the roles were reversed and Ramnath would have not given his permission to Shravan to confess his feelings to Sumo, we all know it he would have chosen his father and he would ignore Sumo in the same way otherwise he wouldn't be able to control his feelings.
He would have done the exact same thing and Sumo would have chased him in the same way.
I don't know if this makes sense but it's incredible how even after months we are able to discuss this show.

can Some body write an ff where Shravan owing to his Father's word of forgetting sumo started avoiding her and it is sumo following Shravan. . That will be nice
Namiksfan thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Superb analysis 👏👏
I completely agree with you

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".