chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#1


Sigh...The most discussed phrase in EDKV, I suppose.

I remember one of my early posts had been expressing disappointment over the way Shravan had totally overlooked Suman's professional capabilities. I had even mentioned how thrilled I had been that Nirmala had acknowledged that entrepreneur in Sumo- One of the few things I deeply appreciate about the character.

Kaun hai Suman Tiwari?

This was partly answered by Suman as she stood up and explained her identity to Shravan. She wouldn't be bound to him as a slave just because she carried the sindoor in his name. It was not a sign of obedience, but of love. Mamiji had clearly explained the significance of the sindoor...she did not wear it because she didn't want her family to feel hurt...She wore it simply because a married woman not wearing it denoted something else- that her husband was no more- it was that sentiment that made her wear it, even though Shravan refused to do it for her.

I had been so looking forward to this track, not because it would make Suman out to be the wronged one...simply because I was waiting for Shravan to open that book called Suman.😳 Knowing the PCT side of her would be just the beginning...there was so much more about her past that he had to show us.


The tragedy of it all!

On Shravan's part- I loved the way he paused at the importance of PCT because her mother' s name was attached to it...but he wouldn't allow her greed to excel get in the way of his family's priorities. I was touched that he still respected that part of Suman he had always known was special to her. ā¤ļø

To all people who are still fuming at Suman for disregarding Chachi's request- fret not. By the end of the day(which would be Monday, I guess), the whole forum will be attacking Kamini for what her friends have to say at the munh dikhayi. After all, that is what she is inviting her friends over for- To point fingers at Suman's character and get her riled up even more!

I am so looking forward to this..This is going to be THE turning point in the story.

And Shravan:

Uff! Could feel him burning in indignation. Of course, no one take away from the fact that he put in the effort to reach where he was...he had an identity of his own. He was not known by his father's name in London- and he had a successful law firm there. Even here, he has just chosen to remain in his father's shadows because his father needed him right here. Breaking off and starting on his own wouldn't look right. But there was also truth in the fact that had it been not for his father's support he wouldn't be who he is today...But who says he wouldn't have been successful if he had stayed back in India and went to a Law College. But that was not Suman's point. Her argument had just been that, GIVEN HER CIRCUMSTANCES, she had done pretty well...she was going to proudly stand up and let the whole world know that not for appreciation, but to declare that she had an identity that had to be respected. The whole scene was written brilliantly.šŸ‘

Of course, Shravan wouldn't attempt to put her down if she had not come out with the I am ashamed I let my name be attached to you' dialogue.

Deep down, all he needs is her love...Problem is, he started demanding it and that led to this ugly turn of events between them...The day he understands and loves the girl Suman Tiwari is, respect would come naturally...and then he would see the love flow. Because even now Suman loves him...despite everything he has said and done. She loves him enough to wear that sindoor because it signifies her husband is alive and well.

PS: Just CPing the argument on why what Suman said did not appear wrong to me.

He pushed her to a corner. He shouldn't have put her down in front of the whole family. She was not rude to chachi. She had asked her nicely. And Nanu is not Suman'S Nanu as per Shravan. Nanu is his Nanu too. So whatever he did was not to respect her family, just out of respect for the old man who meant so much to him.

Kamini doesn't have that equation with Shravan or Suman.

What Suman did was different, because because if she had sat down meekly like a gopi vahu, it would have been the biggest mistake in the script.

Kisike naam ka sindoor bharne se koi kisika ghulam nahi ho jaata. She was speaking about the respect she should get for being his wife.

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

1.5k

Users

8

Likes

72

Frequent Posters

springkissed thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Fabulous post! šŸ‘
I just ranted away in my post, so I really appreciate your grasp on each little moment in this episode, like shravan's slight hesitation when talking about suman's mother, and how the sindhoor is there out of love, not a form of shackle. Shravan basically is acting like a pubescent teenage girl at this moment, lashing out because he wants her love. I like how you pointed out how he demands the love and that's where things have gone wrong. Because you can never demand love, it is freely given and for it to be freely given, shravan needs to be the older shravan that he was for sumo, for him to respect her again, and be her partner, not her jailer. but that's just my take. lol. I'm sort of out of loop with this show currently, catching episodes here and there because shravan's misogynistic comments sometimes really infuriate me, and then I have to remind myself why I love shravan and why is doing what he is doing. šŸ˜†

But, great post nonetheless! Hope the show has a long way to go despite the dire circumstances currently, because shravan as a pair has so much need for each other's love that I would just like a glimpse of that before the show ends.
Edited by coolpixie - 8 years ago
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: coolpixie

Fabulous post! šŸ‘

I just ranted away in my post, so I really appreciate your grasp on each little moment in this episode, like shravan's slight hesitation when talking about suman's mother, and how the sindhoor is there out of love, not a form of shackle. Shravan basically is acting like a pubescent teenage girl at this moment, lashing out because he wants her love. I like how you pointed out how he demands the love and that's where things have gone wrong. Because you can never demand love, it is freely given and for it to be freely given, shravan needs to be the older shravan that he was for sumo, for him to respect her again, and be her partner, not her jailer. but that's just my take. lol. I'm sort of out of loop with this show currently, catching episodes here and there because shravan's misogynistic comments sometimes really infuriate me, and then I have to remind myself why I love shravan and why is doing what he is doing. šŸ˜†

But, great post nonetheless! Hope the show has a long way to go despite the dire circumstances currently, because shravan as a pair has so much need for each other's love that I would just like a glimpse of that before the show ends.


Thank U.

It is very difficult to get a balanced response in tumultuous times such as these...Deeply appreciate your thoughts. 😳


aidan34 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Good post chick.

The storyline got deviated in between and shravan was never given a glimpse of who suman tiwari is . This part of the story was never explored, i guess the writer wanted this current track for mainly this reason. I saw that glimpse in today's epi at the dinner table.
I just wished if they could have brought this track a bit earlier, it would have been appreciated by all the viewers. I strongly believe we never really needed Aditya in the story. We already had a strong storyline with Nirmala Ahuja at the background and suman living under her shadow. The Cvs could have shraman got married along with Preekar and then strarted with this track, it would have done wonders to the story. Alas, we will never see the complete track. As of Monday things will start to wrap up.
If i look at the 7 months journey of edkv, i always felt there was something amiss despite a good storyline, then in midway it came to me and i'll say it here that the romance angle was never explored.Ppl might say the script never required romance but i beleive other wise.
noexcuse thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Good morning Chick. Agree with you that shravan had it coming. Had he not put down her work, she probably wouldn't even requested Chachi to change time.

My gripe is that cvs wrote that scene at dinner table in front of whole family. I never like bringing up personal issues in public. Had he started it in the bedroom and she gave it right back to him there, the scene would have been much more enjoyable to me.
Of course that's just me.
They both know that the both have the
Mojo to be someone on their own. Shravan has appreciated Sumon's cooking (May be not her skill as a business woman) and Sumon also said many times that shravan is a good lawyer but they are so blinded by their hatred they forgot each and every good thing about each other.
Anyway, everything is clear now why it is going off air.
Edited by noexcuse - 8 years ago
Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Lovely post Soupster. I have not watched tonight's episode, dont feel like... might watch tomorrow.

I want to rant about Kamini. What is her problem? Her hubby doesnt work, why and since when we dunno. Their family has lived off of Ramu kaka for so long... and the ungrateful wretch will plot and plan against Ramu and his son. What for? Just because they need an antagonist?

Now she has targetting Suman.

Would EDKV turned into saas bahu crap had it continued?
san2471 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: noexcuse

Good morning Chick. Agree with you that shravan had it coming. Had he not put down her work, she probably wouldn't even requested Chachi to change time.

My gripe is that cvs wrote that scene at dinner table in front of whole family. I never like bringing up personal issues in public. Had he started it in the bedroom and she gave it right back to him there, the scene would have been much more enjoyable to me.
Of course that's just me.
They both know that the both have the
Mojo to be someone on their own. Shravan has appreciated Sumon's cooking (May be not her skill as a business woman) and Sumon also said many times that shravan is a good lawyer but they are so blinded by their hatred they forgot each and every good thing about each other.
Anyway, everything is clear now why it is going off air.


Exactly my point. The whole scene should have been an intense bedroom conversation and not on the dining table. Shravan is always drinking when he needs to talk to his wife
noexcuse thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: san2471



Exactly my point. The whole scene should have been an intense bedroom conversation and not on the dining table. Shravan is always drinking when he needs to talk to his wife


I don't even want to waste my time writing about shravan. Acting like a total moron for too long. He has become repetitive and it's tiring to watch.
Loved sumo's comeback but just wish the scene took place in private.
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: saras_7

Hey there,

Just wanted to suggest the following option for EDKV Ending-

Suman bashed Shravan on 29th Sep 2016 episode while having family dinner - That she needed her own Identity & cannot leave her PCT & life behind. Further on, she added that Shravan's earnings were what his dad gave him, and that he doesn't have anything of his accord. From the beginning till 29 Sep 2016, Suman always belittled Shravan - Which is not right as Shravan is also a Lead Character. Story cannot go with just Female Domination.

From here Story Twists & Ending comes -
Shravan needs to take up this reason & hand over Divorce papers to Suman in a very polite manner stating that - Here you go, I am handing over these divorce papers as you wanted your own Identity. My family is very important to me just like how much your family means to you. I understand how much you value your profession & independence - Hence, I don't want to disturb your life. Stating this Shravan hands over Divorce papers signed by him to her & says I have signed them, and you can live happily from now onwards having your own identity as I will be going to London to take care of my business there. Shravan should be very polite & nice - It should hurt & pierce her Heart - Emotion.

While this conversation was going on, Preeti overhears Shravan & Suman's conversation. Just before she tries to stop Shravan, Shravan should leave. And, Preeti should immediately inform Pushkar & others who should brainwash Suman for what she did wrong. Then, Suman's side family should also know about this & brainwash her completely by making her realize her mistakes- She has to realize whom she is losing in life recollecting how she missed Shravan earlier when he went to London. She has already lost her parents, and she cannot lose Shravan as he was the only one who took care of her like a father, mother & a friend throughout her life.

Once Suman realizes her mistakes & Shravan's kind nature, she should go to airport to stop Shravan before he checks into the flight. As soon as she sees him, she should apologize after realizing her mistakes, confess her love to him by tearing divorce papers & telling him that she wants him only. Nothing else is more important than him for her.

Reference - Mouna Ragam Movie - Last Climax Scene https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fOL_GHdErQs

P.S. - Please let me know your thoughts & comments about this post :)


I am sorry to be leaving a hurried comment here...

But I don't think the divorce paper angle would work because nanu is still alive!

And I happen to believe Suman doesn't hate Shravan to the extent she would want to leave him...she still loves him. So unless she finds someone else as a better option for him, unlikely she would want to leave him.
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Nandy,
EDKV would never have gone the saas bahu way unless Sony forced them to..That is teh very reason they have to shut shop so early!

Kamini thinks she can direct Shraman..but they have their own free mind. She has no idea how much these two love each other anmd how well they know each and every relative...so Saas bahu would never have worked, unless it was for Kamini- Preeti as a sidetrack.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".