I'd like to share my reasons as follows:
1. Promo: Sorry to disagree about the lead actor part as most TV shows only introduce the main lead and the main lead of this show is Monica. In case of TV shows, many new comers are taken and this isn't the reason of the flop of MMZ. I've seen other promos too where the lead male actors weren't shown in the promo.
Instead I believe that the promo itself introduced a boring concept of a girl wanting to achieve her dreams before marriage. They made the promo look comic as well showing Monica with many grooms but it just dint impress the audience. Instead if they had to show Bird Song and the employees, it would have made more impact.
2. Youth based show: I agree on that part that youth based shows fail to gain higher TRPs on SP and even Sony. They shouldn't expect it to get the same TRP like other saas bahu shows.
3. Time slot: I agree here as well that such a show could have been shown at 6:00 or 6:30 which could get higher TRPs or it could have been made a weekend show.
4. Selection of Actors: Well I would like to disagree on this. Kashmira only acted in one show that was not a HIT but it was Average. I have seen the show and it wasn't impressive enough. Like other shows have more popular faces playing second lead and they have more popularity and are more established than Kashmira. Same goes for Shravan too.
Monica is good in acting and like I said other shows too have popular faces, there's nothing wrong in this. In fact, Kashmira's character is given more importance than the established actresses of TV.
I don't think selection of actors is a reason as the PH and CVs had decided Monica as the main lead and were confident about her acting and her chemistry with Aham.
5. Concept: I too find the concept a bit boring but that's my viewpoint. Other shows which gain higher TRPs have far worse concepts and still are on TOP and not to forget that the concept is shown for the first few months and then they lose the plt depending on TRP pressure and audience response.
Being a youth show, they could have shown the office life like I said in point 1.
6. Logic: I have to disagree here as the high TRP shows have nothing like this term even in their dictionary. I would like to know any high TRP show having a logic. I could watch it then if time permits.
For me the CVs tried their best in making this show a saas bahu one but it dint go well as it lacked the amount of drama that other shows have.
7. Characterization: They made changes in the characters to gain TRPs but ended up butchering all the characters. Nothing different than other shows but each to their own viewpoint.
8. Depth in characters and relationships: Again as I said earlier that they dint have time due to TRP pressure else all this could be shown in the better way.
Revenge reason was really bad and they could have improved it with a better story. The overall script and story also was weak. They rushed many scenes in the start too and it made the show look confusing. They could have shown the past scenes of Samaira and Arjun and Nandini where revenge could be explained in a better way.
9. Jodi fights: Well in happens in each and every show these days and the CVs hadn't confirmed the pairs. Samaira being the second lead and Radhika the main lead, it was obvious that Radhika would be paired with Aham (who is the main lead again). It wasn't clear if they considered Aham the main lead earlier as even I thought they would bring in a new actor to play opposite Radhika.
The more fights, the more the show is popular. The CVs had the concept of revenge in mind earlier and this concept isn't a new one to fail. Movies too have shown similar jodi breaks and makes.
10. Scope of acting: I guess Monica was ignored. Well I added her here.
11. Expectations: Viewers now haven't to expect anything from SP and other channels as unless such shows are on V or MTV, they will try their best to make it saas bahu type of shows.
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki
Hindi TV Shows
