Is it Right ? - Page 2

Originally posted by: dhakarn

Yes raghu should ask ginni the reason... n more than that its ginni's responsibility to tell her brothrr why she is in a short dress n in another guy's apartment...

Originally posted by: Latha.I

Raghu asked Ginni only 1st...he did not jump on Karan immediately...

Yup, he did. But that was more like a shocked question before he turned on Karan. Wat I m waiting for is an interrogation, n I'll b very upset if v don't get one...whether ginni lies or not is another question altogether...

Originally posted by: DivzOnAir

Yup, he did. But that was more like a shocked question before he turned on Karan. Wat I m waiting for is an interrogation, n I'll b very upset if v don't get one...whether ginni lies or not is another question altogether...

@latha: no no, maybe I wasn't clear enough. I dint mean that raghu shouldn't b shockd to c ginni there. N I dint mean that raghu should hav been very polite to karan either. Any brother would go on a murderspree if they find a guy playing around with his sister. But the said sister didn't look exactly innocent. That is why I felt he was too soft with her. She deserved a slap then n there. Maybe raghu doesn't hit his sisters, but a severe scolding n warning is required, which hopefully v'll get to c tomorrow.

Originally posted by: DivzOnAir

@latha: no no, maybe I wasn't clear enough. I dint mean that raghu shouldn't b shockd to c ginni there. N I dint mean that raghu should hav been very polite to karan either. Any brother would go on a murderspree if they find a guy playing around with his sister. But the said sister didn't look exactly innocent. That is why I felt he was too soft with her. She deserved a slap then n there. Maybe raghu doesn't hit his sisters, but a severe scolding n warning is required, which hopefully v'll get to c tomorrow.

Originally posted by: Raghu-shivani

Thanks for opening this thread Latha.

It's Ginni's first mistake as you said. So KaShi thought maybe she will learn from it . Informing Raghu about it when he was angry may give opposite results.

Originally posted by: Latha.I

well a gentle man will not hit a girl without confirming if she is really at fault or not...maybe he will slap her when he comes to know the truth...see again we r biased here...for going physical with karan we r saying R is wrong...and for not going physical with ginni also wrong...how???

I can speak only for myself when I say I m not blaming raghu for either. He has every right to get angry on karan, n not to raise his hand on his sister.
But to think that ginni might b innocent is a bit farfetched...Ginni lied to babyji that she is going to a birthday party, n raghu finds her at Karan's place. She is in a very short dress, n is shocked to c her brother. So its only natural to believe that karan n ginni r having an affair, is it not? Mayb Karan did take advantage of her young age n influenced her, but that is not an excuse to not scold ginni... ultimately wearing that dress n going there was her decision or her choice. Unless, raghu thinks that karan somehow managed to get ginni into that dress without her knowledge or permission... lets c how things go...

Originally posted by: DivzOnAir

I can speak only for myself when I say I m not blaming raghu for either. He has every right to get angry on karan, n not to raise his hand on his sister.
But to think that ginni might b innocent is a bit farfetched...Ginni lied to babyji that she is going to a birthday party, n raghu finds her at Karan's place. She is in a very short dress, n is shocked to c her brother. So its only natural to believe that karan n ginni r having an affair, is it not? Mayb Karan did take advantage of her young age n influenced her, but that is not an excuse to not scold ginni... ultimately wearing that dress n going there was her decision or her choice. Unless, raghu thinks that karan somehow managed to get ginni into that dress without her knowledge or permission... lets c how things go...

Originally posted by: rekrn

Nice Post Latha😊

They tried to say something yesterday to Raghu but he was not willing to hear anything and it probably wasn't the right time he was very angry, but when Shivani goes back home she should tell him.

I don't think they should hide it, because it will come out and when it does the repercussions will be more painful.

I personally don't understand why they want to hide it. Raghu will be upset and hurt by what Ginny did but agree with you that Raghu could help Ginny understand what she did is wrong and by not telling him Sumi's overconfidence will increase( I know they don't realize Sumi sent her) just don't want her to do anymore to make Ginny suffer.

Originally posted by: Latha.I

Just want to bring up a topic for discussion...taking Ginni's incident from yest...is it right on part of Karan and shivani to hide abt ginni from Raghu ?

shivani might question Ginni later at home or she will try to make Ginni realize what mistake she did and all...

But karan's logic and reason for hiding this from Raghu...that Ginni would fall in the eyes of Raghu...is it really right?

Afterall...Raghu is her brother...if he knows fact he can take every measure in correcting Ginni...it's her 1st mistake and should be corrected on spot...if karan and shivani hide it from Raghu...it might look like encouraging her to do more such mistakes...indirectly I mean...it gives Ginni a sense of confidence that her mistakes will be saved as secrets by shivani...

what's u r thoughts??

Karan and shivani don't know the entire details of ginni ending up at that club...Ginni really doesn't have any explanation why was she in the club...I don't think Raghu has given enough time to explain karan's side of version
She wont tell details to shivani , shivani would be clueless about it Ginni might confide in sumitra but sumitra will twist the entire issue