Is Shivani really at fault? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

1.8k

Users

15

Likes

56

Frequent Posters

OodlesDoodles thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#21


That highlighted is the most of R;s doing. One Raghu lying to her about the paper being the duplicate will and two Rag not telling her he wants to give her back the property .

Shi saw Raghu meet with Abhi and instead of telling her the truth he lied . So why does anyone expect Shi to understand even if the lie is for her benefit. She had trusted Rag to be always truthful and the one lie is the reason for all the MU and things happening now

Two Rags told his family about him returning the will but he never uttered it to Shi. All Shi hears is that people want to snatch her property and still till this moment does not know of Rags true intentions
Uma-Arhaanfan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
Nice post priya..actually shivani is not at fault but the cvs are...the cvs are not really particular about the changes in shivani...the cvs are not clearly presenting shivanis character by showing lots of variations suddenly she behaves nice and again shouts at raghu.
OodlesDoodles thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Uma-Arhaanfan

Nice post priya..actually shivani is not at fault but the cvs are...the cvs are not really particular about the changes in shivani...the cvs are not clearly presenting shivanis character by showing lots of variations suddenly she behaves nice and again shouts at raghu.



Thanks Uma. I agree there are flaws and there is lot of tightening in the script and character that needs to be done.
rekrn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#24
a wonderful analysis 👏

Both Rashi have a part in this MU. Raghu by not confiding in her about what was happening he wanted to protect her but it is having the opposite effect and the evil trio are taking full advantage of it. Shivani by blinding trusting her brother and sil which I can understand you always want to believe the that your family has your best interest at heart.
OodlesDoodles thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: rekrn

a wonderful analysis 👏

Both Rashi have a part in this MU. Raghu by not confiding in her about what was happening he wanted to protect her but it is having the opposite effect and the evil trio are taking full advantage of it. Shivani by blinding trusting her brother and sil which I can understand you always want to believe the that your family has your best interest at heart.



Yup Rekha... Its not just Shi and fault. Like it says it takes 2 hands to clap to generate a noise . Same here it has Rags hand too . Both Rag and Shi are innocent and don;t know how to play the game and hence they are hurting while the Trio and Abhi taking advantage of this.
john909 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
just because someone has a pampered childhood like shivani does not give them an automatic right to be stupid. i mean it does not matter what type of upbringing one has but how stupid someone really be even after seeing everything with their own eyes. she forgot how much raghu has helped her and protected her before this will drama. she got to know with her own eyes and ears the true face of jass and mahima. if anyone with an ounce of brain goes through all this, they would never listen to those creeps again. she had doubts abt raghu. fine. did she use even an ounce of brain to really find out the truth?? no she just listened to those creeps and assumed.
OodlesDoodles thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: john909

just because someone has a pampered childhood like shivani does not give them an automatic right to be stupid. i mean it does not matter what type of upbringing one has but how stupid someone really be even after seeing everything with their own eyes. she forgot how much raghu has helped her and protected her before this will drama. she got to know with her own eyes and ears the true face of jass and mahima. if anyone with an ounce of brain goes through all this, they would never listen to those creeps again. she had doubts abt raghu. fine. did she use even an ounce of brain to really find out the truth?? no she just listened to those creeps and assumed.




She is really not stupid just the way she thinks is different and her upbringing does factor in her upbringing.If you have seen a lot of struggles then your approach to situations are different then those who haven;t .

What gets forgotten is Shivani always had a soft corner for Jazz even when dadu was around. And what she saw of Jazz and Mahima throwing her out was because she married Rags and hence the reaction of that. She was thrown out by dadu too so why are all picking just on Jazz and Mahima.

Thats exactly the point she has seen everything before her eyes. She saw Raghu talk to Abhi and yet he denied it was of importance. At that time she believed him despite knowing that Abhi could only be up to no good . It was her trust in Raghu that she took his word for it. Then next she knows is the real will drops from the cupboard . Agreed no one knew that it was there but the point is from Shivani's perspective she saw the will there. Then you hear baburaam all the time saying stuff that she did listen to . So its easy to say she just heard and listened to the Trio but the truth is she did hear more than that.

What was at fault is Raghu not defending himself at the right time to save the situation.
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#28
Lovely post 👏👏

I too hv similar views on Shivani .. she has not really seen the outside world and so her trust issues r quite natural .. her world always revolved around her Daaju and haveli ..so she is not smart enough to actually catch all these manipulations and internal politics that her own family members r doing against her ... She has got a very clean and pure heart and thats where people take advantage of her

Also its human nature that we always trust our family people .. blood relations to b precise over outsiders irrespective of how many times those same blood relations hv backstabbed us ... same is the case with Shivani too ... Despite Jaswant throwing her out of the house , she still goes on to trust her brother over Raghu ...

But after today's episode , I feel somewhere she is actually in love with Raghu and so the thought of Raghu betraying her or trying to slap her is affecting her so much 🤔... She does not really bother about what others r doing .. for eg today when that Aunty and Mahima was pressuring her to go back to Raghu's house , she simply blasts them and asks them to get out of her room .. thats it .. she just stops thinking about them ... But any matter which is related to Raghu affects her the most and she just cant stop thinking about why the hell Raghu did this ... Even though Raghu dint slap her but still he raised his hand on her is big for her and she just cant believe it ... When Raghu came to her room to say sorry , see the way she starts hitting him in pain ... it was more of a girlfriend throwing tantrums in front of her boyfriend who broke her heart 😆😆😳...I dint see hate in her eyes today for Raghu bujt it was more of hurt and pain that she feels because out of all its Raghu who did this and he is affecting her the most ...
OodlesDoodles thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#29

Thanks Jyo. Its been ages we had a good discussion. hoepfully will have many more.

In this episode I did not feel she was actually in love more I felt a strong friendship that was being broken. The person who you always went to for help has left you helpless. Whenever she was in trouble the jadugar and his magic wand would take care of it.

Today the way she was hitting him was about that betrayal of being there as her backbone. Although she is upset with him she cannot totally discount the good times shared. Thats why the tantrum she threw to make him realize his mistake . She wanted him to realize that she has lost one of her most cherished relationships and that pain she gave him was nothing compared to what he had done. He totally destroyed their friendship.
Edited by OodlesDoodles - 11 years ago
john909 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: OodlesDoodles


She is really not stupid just the way she thinks is different and her upbringing does factor in her upbringing.If you have seen a lot of struggles then your approach to situations are different then those who haven;t .


point taken. 😊


What gets forgotten is Shivani always had a soft corner for Jazz even when dadu was around. And what she saw of Jazz and Mahima throwing her out was because she married Rags and hence the reaction of that. She was thrown out by dadu too so why are all picking just on Jazz and Mahima.

there is no comparison between jazz and dadu's actions. situation was quite different.

Thats exactly the point she has seen everything before her eyes. She saw Raghu talk to Abhi and yet he denied it was of importance. At that time she believed him despite knowing that Abhi could only be up to no good . It was her trust in Raghu that she took his word for it. Then next she knows is the real will drops from the cupboard . Agreed no one knew that it was there but the point is from Shivani's perspective she saw the will there. Then you hear baburaam all the time saying stuff that she did listen to . So its easy to say she just heard and listened to the Trio but the truth is she did hear more than that.


ok so she saw the will, and also saw raghu talking to abhi. so what?? she just goes ahead and believes that raghu is bad and he can stoop so low to grab her property? she has known him for a long time and after everything he has done to protect her and everything he has been through, she still suspects him? jazz and mahima had said themselves about their intentions when they threw shivani out. raghu has been supporting shivani before this will drama started. so based on one conversation between abhi-raghu (she does not even know what they were talking abt), a will paper that drops outof cupboard, she thinks raghu is a bad guy? well if she had even a little sense in her brain she would have atleast tried to investigate this matter and trusted raghu/ after doing so much for someone, anyone deserves that much benefit of doubt. instead she is busy listening to same people who have stated their intentions from the very start. you said it yourself that she has misunderstood raghu based on what baburam, jazz mahima keeps saying. what does that say abt her? tht she does not have her own brain to find out truth herself.

What was at fault is Raghu not defending himself at the right time to save the situation.

what is raghu suppose to say when she is behaving like this? she recently insulted his family and you still expect raghu to keep giving explanations? if she cant see right from wrong and has no sense in judging people, is it raghu and other people's fault?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".