dont you think its unrealistic?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

UMDU

@UMDU

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#11

Yes it is unrealistic. They are trained first and those like Sandhya who are physically unfit are given extra coaching after hours to make them come up to the standard. More over the CVs seem to have concluded that IPS training is about outdoor activities. It is not so. They have regular classes on forensics, criminology, law, cognitive interviewing techniques etc...It is not just the play ground. The physical strain is balanced with indoor activities. This helps them to recoup your energies. CVs please thoda research karo.

Quote

HalleNJ

@HalleNJ

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#12

a good point, this is another extreme...all seems to be a complete trained IPS except sandy 😆

and as I mentioned in another thread, i dislike the attitude of this IPS trainees being overly competitive with one another, by right it should be more about team work...agree with Umaji, and how about thinking skills and intelligence, will they not be trained from that aspects?

Edited by niruba - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

SKS

@SKS74

Beginner

Posted: 11 years ago

#13

Agree with many people as above.

When setting a fiction in the context of true life situation e.g. iPS training; CVs not being more careful to be realistic insults the intelligence level of the viewer.

Quote

EXOL

@EXOL

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#14

as far as i remember one of the member had said the cv's dint even show all the steps of IPS examination...

so how can we expect the same cv's to show cut to cut steps of training process..

yes IPS cadets are atleast mentally and physically trained in their own way..most of them must have been part of NCC etc..its not like one fine morning they wanted to become IPS...

u have to be competent in this field..its not like any other field ...sharp,focussed and above all that passion n zeal is required which unfortunately cadet sandhya lacks

so for me cadet sandhya's dream lecture looks unrealistic ...atleast have that passion in ur eyes if not in action😕

Edited by nneeiill - 11 years ago

Quote

radhika_2001

@radhika_2001

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

#15

isnt the current track like the movie Lakshya when Hrithik was failing at everything during his army training before a certain point, and after self-realization he completed the training with full determination? I think they will show Sandhya victorious miraculously at the end...all they are showing are only physical activities, what about classes they attend or theory they learn..

Quote

EXOL

@EXOL

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: radhika_2001
isnt the current track like the movie Lakshya when Hrithik was failing at everything during his army training before a certain point, and after self-realization he completed the training with full determination? I think they will show Sandhya victorious miraculously at the end...all they are showing are only physical activities, what about classes they attend or theory they learn..

not even near to lakshya...there HR's character was actually a lost n confused soul unlike sandhya for whom this was her dream.😕

Edited by nneeiill - 11 years ago

Quote

thala

@thala

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#17

well here is my take

this is a show and they need to complete this training session asap as the crew is shooting in two places simultaeneously

there is pressure of consistency

and training from scratch is highly impossibe

they started from running to boxing and now this hurdle

for how long can they show sandy given training and she learns slowly

wont you feel boring to see the same practice before any task

which will mean a practice session and the main task

it will be repeated twice in every episode

i think they are giving it in correct dosage

Quote

EXOL

@EXOL

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#18

exactly i have no complaints they have been asked to do training..coz we have to assume they received all necessary pre training stuff...

i mean all of a sudden just coz zakir was arrogant to sandhya...we are saying it is unrealistic

Quote

shruthiravi

@shruthiravi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#19

I also felt it to be unrealistic. Atleast if it was shown after 1 or 2 weeks of Sandhya in training it would have been fine. Atleast we could have assumed they got some training and then the test. It looks very unrealistic in the 2nd day. I had also posted the same in another thread. Because I felt so irritated I switched on to Malayalam version of DABH where scene after accident was going on.

To be frank was happy to watch that romantic epi compared to this one. 😳

Quote

FrozenRain

@FrozenRain

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#20

I don't think it's unrealistic...

coz peope who are aiming to become an IPS officer is well prepared for their training...my friend is an IPS officer and he asked to do all the rigorous tasks like running 10 km in a specified time,horse riding,swimming etc n the first week itself...

to become an IPS officer along with passing the UPSC exams they have to clear a medical test...

and one of the main criteria is woman can't be pregnant during their first medical test before getting into the academy...so I wonder if the cv's will introduce this track it's gonna a lame one...

and for me the unrealistic one is sandhya...IPS is her dream from her childhood...and she is unaware of the rigorous training in the academy...?🤔..why she is unprepared...i know she is the bahu of a conservative family and all...but if u have a dream u can spend some time for exercise and can take care of ur eating habits naa..any one can't restrict u from that...so it can't be an excuse...if she can't go outside her home to join a gym and all then my question is do she have her own room in that house...she can do some exercise in the early morning and night time aftr closing the door if she was shy or hv any confusion abt the reaction of her saasuma...😳..if there is a will there is a way...her pati anyways wud help her as always...anyways i think this is the most unrealistic track in this show...

and one more.. cudn't get why she is thinking abt bhabo's words during the task...i know bhabho asked her to win the trophy..but for once think abt ur father's words or ur dream...coz u dreamed to become an IPS officer from ur childhood and you have to achieve it for urself and not for any other person...coz it was ur dream and u pushed others to dream along with you...and bhabho hvn't dreamed abt to see u as an IPS officer..she just supported ur dream...SO firstly think abt ur aim...not acting like u r doing all these tasks for someone else...CV's need to take care of sandhya's character...coz it's the odd and unrealistic one among ur characters..nowadays her character looks like confused...she always saying one thing..IPS going to be very important for me n it's my dream...but she never considering tht as her goal but she acts like she want to achieve it for someone else...it's the unrealistic track n not the training session...

know what you want, work to get it, then value it once you have it..If you want to achieve your dream, only think aboutyour goal, not to people or things

Edited by SanaJasmine - 11 years ago

Quote

1 2 3

dont you think its unrealistic? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics