Reason why Sandy refuses to leave - serious post

mythical thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

have read all the WU when i have not been able to watch due to the how unbearable this serial gets at times. i have even tried putting myself in both sandy and suraj's shoes and could not connect to them. the actors are very good looking but thats it. this serial is too different from the reality that i come from, then i thought, wait i have read somewhere about stuf like this. so i went into my study, where i have a whole lot of books and mags lying around and there i came across a novel i had read. it talks of Stockholm syndrome and it made me realise why sandy is not leaving and instead makes excuses to stay. here is what i found on the net about this disorder:

The Stockholm Syndrome comes into play when a captive cannot escape and is isolated and threatened with death, but is shown token acts of kindness by the captor. It typically takes about three or four days for the psychological shift to take hold.
A strategy of trying to keep your captor happy in order to stay alive becomes an obsessive identification with the likes and dislikes of the captor which has the result of warping your own psyche in such a way that you come to sympathize with your tormenter!

The syndrome explains what happens in hostage-taking situations, but can also be used to understand the behavior of battered spouses, members of religious cults, Holocaust victims, household pets, and perhaps even users of Internet Explorer. I think it may also help explain the popularity of government and of the mass institutionalization of young people.

my point of view is that sandy is emotionally and mentally battered and has been since the moment she entered that house. she has not been threatened with death but being told to leave your husbands house and losing all dignity and self respect is like murder on a girl like sandy. plus the continuous bhabo and entire family playing bad cop and suraj playing good cop has taken a mental toll on the girl. otherwise i have no other excuse to give for sandy's behaviour. i am not defending the girl as i truely believe that she needs severe counselling and rehabilitation and suraj's family(bhabo, sister, both bros and sister-in-law) needs to go to jail and suraj and his father can spend the rest of their life in their mithai ka dukkan making jalebi's.sorry not intended to hurt anyones feelings. this is just the way i relate to the characters of this show. hope to see some improvement in the relationships in that house and that cvs realise that they have taken things too far. do comment and let me know how you relate to the characters of sandy and suraj and what is your take on their psychology. the actors will not be discussed here. no fighting allowed, everyone is entitled to their opinions.

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

4k

Users

13

Likes

166

Frequent Posters

..Anusha.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Stockholm Syndrome was discussed some weeks ago.

We've gone through every available, reason/explanation/scenario. Nothing fits I'm afraid. So this isn't a show that even remotely connects with real life.

Take the current situation. Mithai ki dukan is closed! But the highlight is teaching Sandy to cook? In the middle of the night? Now the latest promo has finished with the cooking comp, Sandy has a badly burnt hand and next...yes, mehndi challenge. Bhabo is on hand to screech at Sandy for not knowing how to draw on her hands. This is a demented show.

Rather than analysing the characters/story, we have to analyse the Cvs.
Edited by Hiral_Madame - 13 years ago
kkate thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
i also find the characters confusing , really sooraj is behaving soo bad with sandhya only because he have seen those divorce papers like what he will get by behaving in such a manner , what do i feel any husband will do in such a codition is will talk to his wife on try to win her heart but sooraj is just ooposite.i can't figure out what he will get out of it...
mythical thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Hiral_Madame

Stockholm Syndrome was discussed some weeks ago.


We've gone through every available, reason/explanation/scenario. Nothing fits I'm afraid. So this isn't a show that even remotely connects with real life.

Take the current situation. Mithai ki dukan is closed! But the highlight is teaching Sandy to cook? In the middle of the night? Now the latest promo has finished with the cooking comp, Sandy has a badly burnt hand and next...yes, mehndi challenge. Bhabo is on hand to screech at Sandy for not knowing how to draw on her hands. This is a demented show.

Rather than analysing the characters/story, we have to analyse the Cvs.

oops didn't know it was already discussed. well we can do it again. just wanted to know others thoughts because this continuous torture is getting too much. it is very stressful. this show can be renamed as DIYA HAI STRESS ONLY (my mom came up with it).
Juna04 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
@mythical
You got it right and I have heard of the stockholm syndrome and I have been thinking the same thing with regards to Sandy's behaviour...
She has become numb from the trauma of her parents violent death then forced into a marraige where her dreams and hopes are shattered
Brother cheating her and marrying her into ill-matched household where the husband and his families values and thinking do not match with her upbringing and thinking...
On top of all this having to deal with daily dose of abuse from several family members...
She has accepted all this as her fate and compromised or blanked all her inner dreams and happiness and struggling to survive in the world that she is now surrounded by from which she has no escape as she sees it.
In a way she has surrendered her life to the current life and the world that she lives in...
I am curious to see how the cvs will show her open up and become happy again - for this to happen her relationship with her husband Suraj need to improve and get better with trust and love and respect.
Bec only he can understand and give her the happiness that she deserves
In the current scenario that trust is broken with the D papers - bec Suraj instead of confronting her and getting to the truth is assuming things and behaving immaturely like his mother -
In this instance the cvs have projected some consistency and reality as the apple cannot fall far from the tree - and he is after all Bhabho's son and with her upbringing - hurling insults and taunts must come more easily to him as he has been hearing it from birth...
..Anusha.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Ya I go along with Juna's view that Sandy is just numb...it's the easiest and kindest explanation, although few nights ago she was behaving like a kid with ADD...again in the middle of the night.

A girl like Sandy, with her background and inexperience due to age, can just turn into an ice maiden. It's a defence mechanism. Very difficult to get out of that and show any emotion, let alone romantic feelings. Just not possible.

In the current climate, she better stay frozen for her own good and hope things improve, or they run out of challenges and tests.
mythical thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Juna04

@mythical

You got it right and I have heard of the stockholm syndrome and I have been thinking the same thing with regards to Sandy's behaviour...
She has become numb from the trauma of her parents violent death then forced into a marraige where her dreams and hopes are shattered
Brother cheating her and marrying her into ill-matched household where the husband and his families values and thinking do not match with her upbringing and thinking...
On top of all this having to deal with daily dose of abuse from several family members...
She has accepted all this as her fate and compromised or blanked all her inner dreams and happiness and struggling to survive in the world that she is now surrounded by from which she has no escape as she sees it.
In a way she has surrendered her life to the current life and the world that she lives in...
I am curious to see how the cvs will show her open up and become happy again - for this to happen her relationship with her husband Suraj need to improve and get better with trust and love and respect.
Bec only he can understand and give her the happiness that she deserves
In the current scenario that trust is broken with the D papers - bec Suraj instead of confronting her and getting to the truth is assuming things and behaving immaturely like his mother -
In this instance the cvs have projected some consistency and reality as the apple cannot fall far from the tree - and he is after all Bhabho's son and with her upbringing - hurling insults and taunts must come more easily to him as he has been hearing it from birth...

hey juna04. the thing is the only way i can see any happiness in sandhya's life is if suraj stands strong against his family and embraces sandy without caring about bhabo or her crazyness. he is a mama's boy and must turn into sandy's shield. then we need a cook for sandy and she must be given a break from all this household chores as she is really bad at it. then she must be allowed to study. this is something that is difficult for the cvs to show. they glorify mental torture, spousal abuse and basically all bad things. bad times are here to stay. bhabo will never soften, babasa will never stand against his wife, suraj's siblings will forever remain evil and meenakshi is a gone case. so ta ta hapiness.
Juna04 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Hiral_Madame

Ya I go along with Juna's view that Sandy is just numb...it's the easiest and kindest explanation, although few nights ago she was behaving like a kid with ADD...again in the middle of the night.😆🤣


A girl like Sandy, with her background and inexperience due to age, can just turn into an ice maiden. It's a defence mechanism. Very difficult to get out of that and show any emotion, let alone romantic feelings. Just not possible.

In the current climate, she better stay frozen for her own good and hope things improve, or they run out of challenges and tests.

😆😆😆 You are a riot my dear... Glad to be able to read posts here in the forum from all of you as that is the only entertainment I am getting - the show is getting too bleak and silly if you ask me... but I still watch it bec I like Anas expressions but dont know how long that will work as well... as his character is not attractive at all...
We need to rename the show as DABH does not seem appropriate title for this show
Juna04 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Mythical you are right all the shows focus on the negatives and the channels, ph and cvs think that that is what gets them trps
Maybe it does for a short time bec they cheat the viewers like they are doing with this show by grabbing attention to the theme and concept of the show
We the gullible viewers start watching it as it seems like promising and the entire PH has taken a lot of pain to make sure the viewers are hooked to the show - once they are sure of it they start playing their game...
They really dont care if the show closes soon bec the trend now is that none of the shows last for more than a yr or 2 and some even close early... but they have nothing to loose as they have made their bucks and on to another similar show...
mythical thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Juna04

😆😆😆 You are a riot my dear... Glad to be able to read posts here in the forum from all of you as that is the only entertainment I am getting - the show is getting too bleak and silly if you ask me... but I still watch it bec I like Anas expressions but dont know how long that will work as well... as his character is not attractive at all...
We need to rename the show as DABH does not seem appropriate title for this show

DABH = Danger of Abuse and Bad Health 😆😆😆😉

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".