Defense For Akash/Abhi:Discuss here-Mod Note Pg 46 - Page 21

Created

Last reply

Replies

351

Views

14.3k

Users

143

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

_Poulomi_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
Hi HatpreetM...

First question to you:

HAVE YOU WATCHED EACH AND EVERY EPISODE OF "Dekha Ek Khwaab" ?

After you answer that question i will answer yours.😳

And also i would like to ask you to refrain from using the term "hypocrisy" until and unless you see our POV. It sounds RUDE.

If you still feel we ARE being HYPOCRITES...then feel free to USE it... we wouldn't CARE!

Another thing is, we have been Ardent followers of the show, and some of us from day 1, so we would know the story, the flaws and everything about it MORE accurately. So PLEASE respect OUR POV and see through it, before you call us HYPOCRITES.
Edited by poulomi12 - 13 years ago
kananya thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
I think earlier on in the show when Manyata was sensible, her and Akash romance was making some sense. It was very sweet. But even then her Baba was not too happy with her friendship with Akash. Then nobody had a problem and nobody said murari is a hypocrite. That's how a father would react though some of them may be more broadminded.

But with the entry of Udaybeer, anybody could see that the pair just clicked. (Though now a days I am so bored with Manyata that I wish that Uday is paired with another heroine sometimes. ) And everybody was looking forward to the sparks between them and somehow the Akash moniya lovestory became pale and it also does not help that Uday has a better characterization and has a terrific screen presence.

Added to that, Manyata herself has become very unpredictable now from the sweet girl she used to be in the chawl where she used to respect elders, her baba and used to behave much better than she is now. How to have sympathy for a character who always had everything, first her baba's love, then her family's love and wealth(she is the heiress) . She is not the underdog here though she would like to behave like one.
neharaizada thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Harpreet.M


I do not think that its infatuation. Akash loves Moniya for who she really is while everyone else keeps on trying to change her. Yeah that's true, akash should encourage her to be with her new family, but he knows that they will never accept Moniya for who she really is. Sometimes being in love can be selfish at least in the real world. You do not want to let go of someone you love a lot.

@bold trust me, that always happens in movies sacrifices and all that. Personally, I've been trying to do that for the past 2 years and am still clinging on.

And even if he takes her back to chawl, at least they will be happy together. Manyata lived with her dad all these years at the chawl and she did fine.



If that was the case Harpreet, why did he back off when Rajmata and Uday went to get her back. She cried and howled and begged Akash not to let her go and that too in front of press. There he backed off and said "now you're Rajkumari Manyata" and even called her by that name. He was avoiding her at all instance as he felt that she needs to be with her family. Then one day we see him sneaking past into the palae!! What was that for? He shouldve just stuck on the fact that he loves her and should have fought for her when Uday said "Yeh hai Rajkumari Manyata, humari hone wali Maharani". Instead he just stood gobsmacked.
Hudaak thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
Da main reason dat I hate Monash luv story is firstly coz der r no sparks, it luks luk forced luv story n especially Moniiya is jus infatuated or say is luv wid da idea of luv !!
N 2ndly dis Akash is causin problems or say nt allowing Moniya 2 accept her identity as Rajkumari Manayta , as DS says he is always dragging her 2 her past wer she was Moniya nt Manayta !!
NightStarr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Hi Harpeet, while I respect your opinion I think your misunderstanding many who are ganged up against M and A. I think your frustrated as to why would people be against love of two people which I don't think is the case here because I don't think its them being so much against their love as they are against the characters specifically. I think its not so much that viewers are against the "love" specifically compared to how it is portrayed and how the characters are going the wrong way about it. It seems like it's the inconsistencies in the actions and in characters that seems to make the viewers not like the A and M. The pair has been holding the show from progressing because every episode people think something will happen that will make the story progress but we get an episode of M pulling something that makes the Royals mad and seeing A which then goes into a love scene with a background song. From the surface Akash's character is the perfect guy for any girl b/c he is a hard working guy who respects and takes care of his parents and is an overall nice guy BUT his actions such as leaving his job whenever he wanted, getting a promotion after getting a warning from his boss, NOT helping M to get close with her family (because any nice guy would help their loved one with all the sorrows in their life especially problems with family) is what makes the audience to not like him. It's simply unrealistic to think that someone who has such a great job and big responsibility towards their job could leave at any time of the day, talk/txt on his phone while at work and other such actions. Also, love is selfless not selfish. He shouldn't want to hold M back from anything that would make her successful but rather help her be the most she could be. Also both M and A are suppose to be people who hold don't lie, respect others, and overall likable people, so then how come M lies every chance she gets and laughs about the lies with A? And let's not forget that regardless of what kind of a lie you tell, whether it is for a good cause or a bad cause, a lie is STILL a lie and eventually will come out. I am not even going to get into how M has been acting like a 7 years old ever since she moved to the palace: many like myself can't help but ask what happened to the mature, respectful, free spirited girl who expressed her opinion but with outmost respect towards other and helped strangers(Ex. Amma the older lady she liked taking care of at chawl)?So I don't think viewers are against M & A pair as much as they just don't connect with them because the story has too many inconsistencies and unrealistic scenarios.

P.S. You and many other Monash fans says supporters of Udayveer like him because of his looks isn't that judging a book by its covers? Also you say Akash went through hardships with her- what hardships? He was supporting her for half a day when her dad got arrested and then they got into an argument and she went through hardships by herself and got herself to police station…then palace. He left her at her worst time and it was her friends that made A come back to her.

LOVE_DMG thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
you do have a point, and i personally had no prob with akash entering moniya room.

but i guess we want to be entertained , akash as you could see in today and yest epi, he is the perfect bf. and that is like said b4 is boring to watch. yes i can see the love akash has to moniya but we want something more fun, for sake of entertainment.
as for pple here bashing akash, they are afraid that cv would focus on akash-M story ruin perfect good show . so they are getting their point across.
lakshyasss thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
i honestly go by what u said...TRUE LOVE...ya akaash loves monia...and monia loves him...but see here is the difference
monia is manayata the princess of devgarh...the girl who has to be made queen soon...the girl who has to be made responsible to handle devgarh state...


This guy was with her through all the hardships she went through. The royals should understand that before she met them, she had a life and akash was part of that llife.

About the topic of akash being in her room, here are all the times everyone here on IF was okay about a guy and girl being in a room together before marriage:
the royals should understand...u wrote..but monia is too a royal now...she herself too had wanted that she becomes a princess...and she became...just a question how would ure parents react when will see any other guy in ure room...take common man only would they listen to u or would u listen to them??Same case here ,forget royality,forget princess part...take it in common man era what do u feel...is this wrong or right!U also said before marriage but here its not so...there is no chance of marriage,there is a total different story here.here akaash was given chance by monia herself to accept her as monia but he didn't do that instead he told her to go to her family...and now he accepts her when her family needs her ...When devgarh estate needs her ,when time needs her to change at this point of time he wants her to be his…..
Just wanted to say, just because Udhay is "hotter" or "cuter" does not mean everyone side with him and call Moniya annoying and all that other stuff

Ok! U only saw cuteness,hotness in him didn't u saw like others a sense of responsibility,a sense of wisdom,knowledge, a sense of becoming great leader…..also the way he can handle manayata …the way he can make her grow don't u see it .Akaash can handle only monia's smooth side not her rough one whereas udayveer can handle both …..Even if it ends with akaash then just answer whether akaash would lead monia to become manayata …to let her rule……I hope u get ure answer

Nizza

Sid4TeamCanada thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Harpreet.M


And even if he takes her back to chawl, at least they will be happy together. Manyata lived with her dad all these years at the chawl and she did fine.



they will be happy for awhile, but kab tak?
what life can he give her? the pathetic life murari had given her, with no education no friends no belonging, no nothing.. can he give her expensive private tutoring that could compensate for her lack of education? cud he give her the mother's love she has been deprived of all this time? can he give her the feeling of belonging, the feeling that comes from one's own family?
with royals, she has this whole world of opportunity and success open to her, and leaving all that to go live in the chawl with akash just does not seeem like the ideal way to go, atleast to me.
bas yaar, i don't liek akash, toh i end up finding like a thousand points against him. 😆
Edited by Sid4TeamCanada - 13 years ago
lakshyasss thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: poulomi12

Hi HatpreetM...

First question to you:

HAVE YOU WATCHED EACH AND EVERY EPISODE OF "Dekha Ek Khwaab" ?

After you answer that question i will answer yours.😳

And also i would like to ask you to refrain from using the term "hypocrisy" until and unless you see our POV. It sounds RUDE.

If you still feel we ARE being HYPOCRITES...then feel free to USE it... we wouldn't CARE!

Another thing is, we have been Ardent followers of the show, and some of us from day 1, so we would know the story, the flaws and everything about it MORE accurately. So PLEASE respect OUR POV and see through it, before you call us HYPOCRITES.

😆POLO tera jwaab nahin laat khichna koi tere se seekhe waise i agree with u
saraaa. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
question is, why do you like Moniya and Akash? nothing about their love seems intriguing to me. It's just complete selfishness. They can't even sacrifice their love for each other ...
I'm sorry if we disagree on how true, eternal love should look like but honestly if you truly love someone, you should be able to sacrifice your own love for them. ONLY reason to not do that is if you know for sure that they won't be happy. Akash didn't even give her a chance to accept her identity and get to know her family. It's like he's pushing her away from what he will never be able to give her. I understand he can give her love but the other necessities in life?

atleast he should think about her for once and not just for what he wants :|

Moniya needs someone who will inspire her to be a better person, and good queen which Akash is pulling her away from. Akash is just making her a hypocrite and telling lies.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".