Why Moniya won't let go of Akash & her ugly kurtas

chainedreamer thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

So this is the real mystery, isn't it?

I mean one day you wake up and realize you have the entire world at your disposal, the hottest Prince is your fianc, all the comforts are an order away and to make matter better, even a caring family. A family that is so overwhelmed with re-uniting with you after 16 long years that they overlook all your immaturity and mistakes, fulfill all your demands and put up with your tantrums. They have sworn to do right by you, and give you everything you ask for - except your old life, of course.

Then why won't Moniya just embrace it all? Why is she trying so hard to hold on to her chawl lifestyle, Chikki and Soni and most importantly Akash?

Because that is all she has left of her identity. Think about it. A girl who has just lost her father (figure), who has no place to call her home cuz she has been on the move all her life, and who's only souvenirs growing up as a nomad have been the colorful swearwords and the wide variety of cuisines she enjoys.

On some level, coming to Mumbai was like finally finding a home for Moniya. The very first episode showed her describing the odd familiarity she felt with the city. It was here that she finally decided to go out and get a job, it was here that she formed close alliances and it was here that saw herself settled down for a good while ahead.

No wonder then that she doesn't want to change, no wonder she won't give up her ways, no wonder she will go to any extents to fight for her right to stay the same. Because changing into the Rajkumari and giving up these seemingly 'bad habits' equate to giving up her very essence for Moniya.

Similarly giving up Akash would mean giving up her ability to make decisions. He is, along with Sonu and Chikki, the last remnants of her last 16 years. They were her first 'family'. They made her feel loved and wanted as no doubt her previous friends had done but they were the last ones she didn't leave willingly. They were ripped away from her and this is what makes them dearer to her.

She maybe a princess now but she is still essentially a chawl girl, a self respecting one, who doesn't even consider a guy like Udayveer a match possible. She is just a girl who loves a boy who is too good for her (in her opinion). This is why she cuts corners, makes compromises and goes out of her way to appease Akash. Because she genuinely believes he deserves better. Because she is no princess, she is just a jhalli girl who can't speak in English and never even went to school.

This is why, she is trying against all odds to hold onto the dreams, hopes and plans she had invested into finding a stable home, into finding love. Akash for her is a means to achieve that dream. While she may yell and shout as much as she wants that she loves Akash, the truth remains that she is more in love with the idea of stability and home that Akash promises.

Come what may, Moniya won't want to give up her relationship with Akash. As short and new as it maybe, giving up on the relationship won't just mean dishonoring her words, and breaking a commitment she made but also giving up on 16 years of her life and everything she knows.

While DS and the entire royal clan might slowly and eventually succeed in making sure she looks and behaves like Rajkumari Manyata, UV, it seems, might have a greater task cut out for him.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.5k

Users

8

Likes

42

Frequent Posters

DJ.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
You have made some very valid points.

Maanyata can become a case study for understanding confused emotions and stubbornness bunched up together.

Circumstances never let her settle. Finally when she felt she was settling in life everything got shaken up.

In one split second she lost (Monaya) and gained her identity (Rajkumari Maanyata). And it is very unnerving when you are not sure of yourself. Who you are, who is your family, whom to call your own, which is your home?


Though it may seem that the whole world is at her feet, all her family's love to fill the void but the confusion she is in refuses to let her accept it. She will take time to understand assimilate facts and accept them especially after what Murari did to her (kept her in the dark). She has trust issues now which seems very clear. When a person has trust issue he/she will definitely want to go after what he/she know the best. In this case it is her previous lifestyle and Akash Chikki and Soni.

Chikki and Soni being her first real friends and Akash the dream man. You have rightly pointed out that giving up Akash is giving up her decision ability. But also cause he was her choice. Giving up Akash is like negating her choice her belief of him being the right man. Also cause for her at the moment he is the only one who is accepting her for what she is i.e. Monaya.


As for Akash being the channel to provide that stability and home which she dreamed of can come from UdayVeer too. But due to her trust issues, UdayVeer become the villain automatically. Furthermore his alliance is imposed and not of choice.


Her stubbornness only comes from the fact that she is asked to do things differently. She is not scared of change but the reason behind it. For her it seems more on lines that if they love me then accept me the way I am. Her ego and stubborn attitude grows taller with every occasion where she corrected on her behavior, dressing, alliances, etc, etc, etc. Any person would like to be accepted for what he / she is. For her now it is more on lines that if you can't accept me for what I am then hell with you I also do not accept you. Hence she refused to let go of anything of her past, to an extent that she had turned JayNandini's bedroom into a camp ground.

I feel that DS or the royal clan will not be able to convert Monaya into Maanyata. It will be a pure circumstance that will. Nothing more and nothing less.



PS .. Amazingly written post Kudos to you and your analysis
Edited by DJ.. - 13 years ago
..SchnellBus.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
res
😃
just read the first 2 lines.
i think u have expained everthing more precisely so will read it dihaan se😉and after that will unres it😉
Edited by Kainat-K.Tacker - 13 years ago
-Misek- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Firstly.. A great post.. You've actually described M character in all possible ways..

I completely agree that M feels tht her identity of being Moniya is at stake.. And she is very much more comfortable in chawl with Chiki, Soni and Akash.. But the only thing that is not satisfying me is her denial in the process of being Manyata.. I knw she is more attached being Moniya but she can also not deny the truth of her life is that she is Manyata and the Royals are her family and blood ties..

When she first came to Mumbai, she made friends with Chiki, Soni, Akash and all in Chawl.. But to accept her own family she needs to think twice.. I knw now she is shown to be more attached at some point than before but still she kinda fails to understand them.. I knw it can't happen over night but making small steps won't hurt her pride..

Regarding Akash and her chawl frens.. the only reason I can find abt Royals on not letting her to meet them is because this might never let her to accept her reality.. As you can see Akash always calls her Moniya and the fact that she loves him makes a huge difference..Even you've mentioned that giving up on Akash meant giving up her ability to make decisions, her dreams on stability and home... So here Akash accepting her as Moniya and not Princess Manyata makes a difference on her to not to accept being Princess as she has already imagined a world with him..

On UV its completely diffirent scenario again.. But the only reason I can find her on not accepting the reality is her so called unconditional love for Akash.. And it actually makes me brainstorm that does it really happen in real life that you meet a person for 2 days and fall head over heels in love that you are actually denying your true identity.. 😕

I just hope in coming days Manyata realises that her family also loves her truly and dearly.. how they are always on her side and not pestering her for being a well behaved princess over night but in fact willing to endure most of her immature and stupid acts on her journey of being a Princess.. And tht her life is not only abt Akash.. Hope she thinks beyond Akash and all those 16 yrs of pain that her family had on her loss.. I knw she's lived her life very diffirently over the past 16 years but she should also make an attempt to knw on how her family have lived without her for 16 yrs as well.. I think its all abt emotions here which again seems lacking on her for her family.. This actually upsets me a lil bit 😔

As they say" no pain no gain" so may be she needs to endure the pain of letting go of her past life and embark on being a Princess soon..

Edited by limbu.simmy - 13 years ago
OmaRamdass thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
wow a lot to take in - i agree with you though - i feel she is fighting for the identity but will slowly accept her life as a princess.
Jaded thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
You have voiced or rather wrote how i percieve M's character ❤️...its not about accepting her family or her new circumstances for her...its about trying not to loose herself in teh malestorm that her life has turned into...this sudden change and this refusal from her so called family of the way she is...is grating for her...given of course she is wild, and crass and rude...but she is also very much lost and so so Alone in the whirlwind of change.
Her relationship with Akash...i loved how u put it...he symbolizes stability and a place to call her own...he is the only one who is accepting her as Moniya...there are no expectation of changing from him...he is sort of represents as her psuedo ID rght now.
I think, after such a long time...changing and adapting from place to place...M is just tired and afraid that what new change will bring in her life...she just cant trust herself to flow with the tides of time...she has to fight to remain afloat...to remain true to herself...afterall, in the end she has no one but herself...i believe she has locked her heart against her family as well...she just dont want to be betrayed again by the relations who are supposed to define a person...her whole identity was ripped from her with Murari's betrayal...how can she trust her heart and emotions to similar relations once again??
I also agree about the point that her change of attitude into Manyata will not be just for herself...either she will be forced to take teh mantle, to protect the innocent as displayed by her during the servants day off...or she will experience another betrayal...it will be shocking... that will break her out of this cycle of denail and confusion.
chainedreamer thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

I hadn't quite thought of it in terms of trust and betrayals before but I can see how that could also be the case. I think there is also a pure lack of association between her and the royal clan which makes it hard for her to even consider trusting them. She has on a number of occassions implied that DS and others don't understand the values and struggles of the working class. It's almost like a repressed resentment towards the way they lead their lives, as as made obvious during the Maali Kaka fiasco.

You know I sometimes feel she just humors them along, to get whatever she wants. It's like she truly believe somewhere that she can never be like them. She finds more honour in the chawl life with it's trials and struggles than in teh luxuries of the palace. It almost makes her guilty I think.

Originally posted by: DJ..

As for Akash being the channel to provide that stability and home which she dreamed of can come from UdayVeer too. But due to her trust issues, UdayVeer become the villain automatically. Furthermore his alliance is imposed and not of choice.



I completely agree with the imposed alliance part. However, I think that another reason, she doesnt even consider Udayveer, is because of their drastically different POVs and lifes. I don't think she even sees him as an option. It's like the idea of their marriage is so absurd she doesnt even wanna acknowledge it. Of course the fact that she sees him as being manipulative, calculating and evil incarnated doesn't help with the situation either.

While I agree that she wants to be accepted for the way she is, I think in some ways she is slowly caving in, she is slowly molding herself where she sees an obvious improvement eg. the sleeping on the bed thing. I think the more she accept her current family and life, the more she allows herself to embrace it - slowly but steadily. But like Maali Kaka said, the true essence can stay intact and I think she is slowly trying to embody that.

You know the only person who can change her is herself. The royal clan can and will help her along but it has to be an acceptance from within. I hope its a slow and gradual tranformation. I would hate for something hurtful and jarring to happen cuz that would mean Moniya will never ever be happy as Manyata and it would mean the end of the wild spirit and innocence that is the crux of her personality.

P.S. Thank you so much! :)
Edited by chainedreamer - 13 years ago
chainedreamer thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: limbu.simmy

Firstly.. A great post.. You've actually described M character in all possible ways..


I completely agree that M feels tht her identity of being Moniya is at stake.. And she is very much more comfortable in chawl with Chiki, Soni and Akash.. But the only thing that is not satisfying me is her denial in the process of being Manyata.. I knw she is more attached being Moniya but she can also not deny the truth of her life is that she is Manyata and the Royals are her family and blood ties..

When she first came to Mumbai, she made friends with Chiki, Soni, Akash and all in Chawl.. But to accept her own family she needs to think twice.. I knw now she is shown to be more attached at some point than before but still she kinda fails to understand them.. I knw it can't happen over night but making small steps won't hurt her pride..

Regarding Akash and her chawl frens.. the only reason I can find abt Royals on not letting her to meet them is because this might never let her to accept her reality.. As you can see Akash always calls her Moniya and the fact that she loves him makes a huge difference..Even you've mentioned that giving up on Akash meant giving up her ability to make decisions, her dreams on stability and home... So here Akash accepting her as Moniya and not Princess Manyata makes a difference on her to not to accept being Princess as she has already imagined a world with him..

On UV its completely diffirent scenario again.. But the only reason I can find her on not accepting the reality is her so called unconditional love for Akash.. And it actually makes me brainstorm that does it really happen in real life that you meet a person for 2 days and fall head over heels in love that you are actually denying your true identity.. 😕

I just hope in coming days Manyata realises that her family also loves her truly and dearly.. how they are always on her side and not pestering her for being a well behaved princess over night but in fact willing to endure most of her immature and stupid acts on her journey of being a Princess.. And tht her life is not only abt Akash.. Hope she thinks beyond Akash and all those 16 yrs of pain that her family had on her loss.. I knw she's lived her life very diffirently over the past 16 years but she should also make an attempt to knw on how her family have lived without her for 16 yrs as well.. I think its all abt emotions here which again seems lacking on her for her family.. This actually upsets me a lil bit 😔

As they say" no pain no gain" so may be she needs to endure the pain of letting go of her past life and embark on being a Princess soon..


Thank you so much! No she can't deny her identity but she can't become someone she has no understanding of. I think the issue here is not that she doesn't want to accept her real family - it is that she doesnt want to become all that she thinks Princess Manyata stands for. She needs to understand the reasoning behind why they do what they do, she needs to see them all as being more than just priviledged, powerful people. She needs to be convinced, instead of threatened or pressured to become the princess they want. A point I feel DS understands.

I agree with you in terms of why they wont let her go visit the chawl. I think they fear that whenever they take one step ahead with her, she goes back to the chawl and takes two steps back. Its this weird push-pull between who she was and who she can be that has gotten everyone twisted too.

With UV, a huge hindrance is her love for Akash but it's not just that. The issue is that Moniya hasn't started thinking like Princess Manyata yet, she doesn't see herself there and clearly knows she isn't from that mindset, wavelength and lifestyle. Which is why for Moniya - a chawl girl, marrying a prince and one as complex as UV is way beyond comprehension. She doesnt even consider the possibilty of it. If you notice she always laughs it off everytime someone mentions it because in her head it's nothing short of absurd.
You know after yesterday's episode, I'm convinced that while her methods and intentions may be wrong but it will bring out real feelings and emotions for her family. Better yet, it will all be because of her 'love' for Akash. But in the process, she will have changed so much that suddenly she wouldnt need what she once wanted anymore i.e. Akash.

Also, I think it's not her love for Akash but the fact that marrying him now would also mean leaving behind her palace and title and all the new transformations that await her. If she marries Akash, she gets back the life she has always led.

I am afraid to see how much she is willing to stake in the process though.
libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
You are the first one to give such a positive post...as everyone seems to give only negative opinions regarding Manyata's behaviour...m not saying that its their fault...she is getting annoying by the day...but what you wrote is very much valid...👏👏👏APPLAUDS TO YOU,MY FRIEND...

Akash,Chikki n Soni...are not just friends or lover for her...they are a way for Manyata to hold on to Monia...a life that she has lived for 16 years...n all of a sudden if you ask her to throw it out of your life...she will not be able to do that...

Even though she is bordering on insanity,immaturity and crudeness...it is very much justified by her behaviour that she will not be able to cut out the "MONIA-PART" out of her life...

N yeah...U r ryt about Udaybeer's job being cut out...he will never be able to tame her...n yeah...his opinion that he is THE ULTIMATE GREEK GOD will be shattered by Manyata...as wo usko apni barabari ka nahi manti...n that's the reason y he is so enamoured n intrigued by her...he hates her n also likes her...same goes for Manyata..."They can't be with each other neither can they be without each other"😉

chainedreamer thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sinistera

You have voiced or rather wrote how i percieve M's character ❤️...its not about accepting her family or her new circumstances for her...its about trying not to loose herself in teh malestorm that her life has turned into...this sudden change and this refusal from her so called family of the way she is...is grating for her...given of course she is wild, and crass and rude...but she is also very much lost and so so Alone in the whirlwind of change.

Her relationship with Akash...i loved how u put it...he symbolizes stability and a place to call her own...he is the only one who is accepting her as Moniya...there are no expectation of changing from him...he is sort of represents as her psuedo ID rght now.
I think, after such a long time...changing and adapting from place to place...M is just tired and afraid that what new change will bring in her life...she just cant trust herself to flow with the tides of time...she has to fight to remain afloat...to remain true to herself...afterall, in the end she has no one but herself...i believe she has locked her heart against her family as well...she just dont want to be betrayed again by the relations who are supposed to define a person...her whole identity was ripped from her with Murari's betrayal...how can she trust her heart and emotions to similar relations once again??
I also agree about the point that her change of attitude into Manyata will not be just for herself...either she will be forced to take teh mantle, to protect the innocent as displayed by her during the servants day off...or she will experience another betrayal...it will be shocking... that will break her out of this cycle of denail and confusion.


I agree with you. With Akash, she won't have to change a thing and that could be a big appeal. He takes her as she is - no questions asked. Which is why she is willing to stake everything she has just gotten to be the person she always was.

I really really hope there isn't another betrayal in store. I would rather she willingly transformed into the princess, slowly and gradually than be forced to become one instantly. That would mean alot of suffering and heartbreak and a certain loss of innocence that I find endearing in her. She needs to grow up and mature into a leader and a woman but not at the cost of her feelings and emotions and definately not cuz of Akash.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".