CarulinaTina thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#1

Ever since the gala episodes have started, I have become more and more disappointed in this show, more specifically the judging. After having seen shows like Dance India Dance, my expectations were really high from a show like this that had so much potential. But sadly, I have no expectations left for this show.

Starting with the choreographers, it seems like they are more focused on forming a concept rather than working on a dance performance. And despite the many flaws made during the performance, the other choreographers scores give them high scores, not bothering to mention abt the many errors in sync, postures, etc.
And I have NO clue why Shiamak is called 'super-power' when he has no power whatsoever. All he can really do is say if he agrees or disagrees, and request the other choreos to change their score. I mean, they cud have atleast given him the power to choose Man of the Match or to award an extra point to a certain team. But it seems they gave all the powers to Rani, and have left Shiamak with nothing.
Altogether, I am really disappointed with the judging of this show.

Created

Last reply

Replies

1

Views

798

Users

2

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

mmmai thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
shiamak should be given some power to give some marks, like choose the man of the match or given the extra one point or something. but rani is getting all the powers. and i feel the most of the time when she gives the points she doesn't really look at the dance. on friday when desi pardesi's ruelle performed, she gave him an extra one because he played the guitar and sang a song for her. i mean come on!! this is a dance show, people should be judged for their dance not what they did for someone. and ruelle didn't even play the guitar, the guitar music was played, when he was singing his hands didn't even touch the guitar strings.

edit.
also on the first episode on uttar ke puttar and south's duo performance, annie was criticised soo much for her dance. on the other hand bindu from south was selected as the man of the match. yet uttar got more points because of their concept. i didn't like the performance at all, there was a guy dancing upside down, and annie dancing with him. but there wasn't much dance in it, cuz the guy couldn't move about properly as he's upside down, annie had more steps but she was very weak.
but south team's bindu was great, and the guy was not so bad either, and they had more dancing. so dancing wise, i felt that south was better on that round. but uttar was given more points because of their concept 🤢.
after the first episode, the judging got a little better, but still i wouldn't call it good judging. shiamak seems to be the most sensible judge their, but the poor guy only has the power to say if he agrees or not, and request to change the marks. but its in the others hands whether they want to change the marks or not.
Edited by mmmai - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".