Did Shafeer deserve to get eliminated??

Page

Next Last

aaryanhunk

@aaryanhunk

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

No I dont think so.. He was far better than Vaibhav..

Vaibhav should have been eliminated as geeta and terence also commented he didn't do so well..

And like always Remo tried saving his contestants...

I also think it was the most amateur choreography and me being a professional krumper will say "REMO" U being a choreographer should not give wrong knowledge to the Indian audience..

International Dancers are laughing at u. Speak whats real...

Quote

Frequent Posters

Wicked

@SomeOldUser

Sparkler

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

Remo hasn't changed one bit. He still takes things personally.

No, Shafeer's elimination wasn't justified, considering the fact that he's the only one who knew Kalaripayattu. As it is, for the past 3 weeks there haven't been any classical or Indian forms, and above that this nonsense.

I am speechless. No idea what to say. If I am not wrong, your elimination is based on the dance ki kasauti. Kasauti means test. And here, the test is at that point of time. When Shafeer proved himself, Vaibhav bored us.

Is it possible to bring in a better GM? I think we should raise our voice. He's keeping crappy dancers like Piyali, Lipsa and Vaibhav and eliminating good ones like Sanchita, Sneha K, and now Shafeer.

He needs a reality check! The only part where I agreed was his decision to keep Abhik as opposed to HR. They were both awesome, but I felt Abhik was a notch ahead.

Disappointing, seriously!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Westwick

@Westwick

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

In a very simple English " NO" Shafeer doesn't deserved to be eliminated. MD played a nasty socialistic role to please RD.

Quote

dancemania

@dancemania

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

Totally shocked with his elimination...Shafeer's was one of the best performance on sunday without any flaws...either Vaibhav or pradeep should have gone out. Vaibhav's performance had more attitude than dance and Pradeep's performance had some wow moments but some mistakes too. All the Masters had appreciated his performance that day.Don't understand at all on what basis MD made this decision He was such a strong dancer and has given excellent performances so far.

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Sorry guys but I think Pradeep was the weakest within the three and should have gone. Even he got comments that his over emotions in the dance had affected the actual dance performance

Quote

fari_ha

@fari_ha

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

A big No...

Shafeer was best among three... i cant understand how GM can eliminate him ...so shocked😲 About pradeep and Vaibhav i can say that pradeep is very good and verstile dancer in the show but that night he made mistakes and also missed beats several time... in my view base on performance that night pradeep shoul hve been eliminated not shafeer... And i liked vaibhav performance... In girls radhika was definitely weaker that night... i like her .. but she being unlucky that night

Quote

605921

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: suresh555
Sorry guys but I think Pradeep was the weakest within the three and should have gone. Even he got comments that his over emotions in the dance had affected the actual dance performance

i think i agree kal pradeep weak tha!

Quote

Cool_Ishu

@Cool_Ishu

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: aaryanhunk
No I dont think so.. He was far better than Vaibhav..
Vaibhav should have been eliminated as geeta and terence also commented he didn't do so well..

And like always Remo tried saving his contestants...

I also think it was the most amateur choreography and me being a professional krumper will say "REMO" U being a choreographer should not give wrong knowledge to the Indian audience..

International Dancers are laughing at u. Speak whats real...

It's quite natural that every master will try to save their contestant but what dada was doing? why didn't he consider other master's opinion? elimination already fixed?

Quote

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Shafeer's kalari steps were very good, despite him being not a trained Kalari person... And Kalari is not easy to do, and doing it on a stage is even harder with the kind of jumps and moves it requires to do... I felt sad to see Shafeer leave.. I feel the channel doesnt want to keep more than one dancer from the South, because it's not a big voting region for DID, and so the few votes will get further divided with more than one contestant from that region.. This is only my assumption, I have no proof, but just an assumption based on what on many posts...

Quote

dancemania

@dancemania

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: akanna
Shafeer's kalari steps were very good, despite him being not a trained Kalari person... And Kalari is not easy to do, and doing it on a stage is even harder with the kind of jumps and moves it requires to do... I felt sad to see Shafeer leave.. I feel the channel doesnt want to keep more than one dancer from the South, because it's not a big voting region for DID, and so the few votes will get further divided with more than one contestant from that region.. This is only my assumption, I have no proof, but just an assumption based on what on many posts...

But the voting hasn't even started yet? He was the strongest performer on Kasauti so his elimination was totally unfair.

But as you have said that maybe the channel thought he his not going to bring in the TRP's and the votes because he belongs to the South, they decided to eliminiate him.

Quote

1 2 3

Did Shafeer deserve to get eliminated??

Related Topics

Explore Topics