Interesting Fact - how fair is it? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Taz-A.Crazy.Fan

Parvez tried out for DID 1 and so did Vandana
iono why Meenu and Binny got the spotlight from it but anyways
no i really dont think its a plus point for the contestants well maybe for teena thats bout the only person i was like O_O about when she was chosen over amrita

Parvez did?? I didnt know.. Even Vandu is new until someone said it here... They only mentioned that about Meenu and Binny all the time...

I also dont think it's a credit for any contestant in the audition - I explained the requirements for them to be selected in my earlier post in this thread - they need all 3 votes to be in whereas others require only 2 out of 3, and these "other" will include even the returning ones like Meenu, Binny... Only those who have worked with or trained with one of the Masters will need 3 votes to be in...

In fact Teena was better than Shruti imo.. But Amu should have been in than these two for sure, and I was shocked too since I was expecting to hear Geeta calling Amrita's name to be in... I didnt know Teena's connection with Geeta at that time and I kept wondering why...

I think the only one who got an unfair advantage because of this was Teena.

btw... does anyone have Vandana/Parvez season one auditions?

Originally posted by: Awww

I was just sitting today, trying to recall the auditions...when the contestants were picked, I thought it was based on merely their talent, but now when I think about it...half of the contestants made it through knowing atleast one of the mentors ............. interesting eh?

Shakti knew Terence

Altaf knew Geeta

Punit knew Terence

Teena knew Geeta

Dharmesh knew Remo

Binny (repeat from DID 1)

Meenu (repeat from DID 1)

Naresh being bro of Mangesh, ofcourse knew the mentors

I just wonder if the rest of the candidates from india were given a fair chance?

Pls...no bashing, this topic is for only healthy discussion!

D Sar Knew Gabbar? That's a news ! I always wondered why all of them were asking Dharmesh if his teacher was D-SIr because I thought all 3 of the judges had a form where the basics of a contestant were already written ...
Also, do all the aspirants see the 3 judges directly ? Looking at the crowds, that looks like an impossible thing to do. Isn't there a pre screening ?

You have a point... but all the contestants that were chosen were all deserving..

All I knew that Binny and Meenu tried in DID and I just found out by other reply's tht Parvez and Vandana tried too. I don't get by Zee always discussed about Binny and Meenu but never about Parvez and Vandu... This is how they are sooooo unfair..