Poll

who's prfomenc is d best???

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

2.3k

Users

21

Frequent Posters

blueblue3 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#11
i love Mayuresh!!!!!! hes just superb!
Edited by blueblue3 - 16 years ago
andysah thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#12
I think people are confusing between degree of difficulty and execution. Lets say an Indian ice dancer tries to land a quad Salchow in a competition and breaks every bone in her body. So does she get a gold medal because of the degree of difficulty or does the judges look for execution also?
Salman's dance was with a high degree of difficulty (accepting Remo's argument about mask and bandages in the body, though chou dancers are able to perform with all these) but just was not executed well. I liked that he is brave and literally flaming hot but Mayuresh was simply superb today. He executed perfectly.
Bhavna was surprisingly good. Siddesh, Jai as usual were great. Rakhi was unsurprisingly bad and the judges still supported her. What else is new?
Loved Geeta's comment about Sholay and Mausi.
Mithunda had an unintentional funny moment. So the winner will get contract, money and fame but above all he will get a Topi. Topi is above everything else. Let us bow down to the power of Taqdeer ki Topi.
ready2rock thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: andysah

I think people are confusing between degree of difficulty and execution. Lets say an Indian ice dancer tries to land a quad Salchow in a competition and breaks every bone in her body. So does she get a gold medal because of the degree of difficulty or does the judges look for execution also?

Salman's dance was with a high degree of difficulty (accepting Remo's argument about mask and bandages in the body, though chou dancers are able to perform with all these) but just was not executed well. I liked that he is brave and literally flaming hot but Mayuresh was simply superb today. He executed perfectly.

I completely agree with u...whatever salman did was also commendable but still mayuresh was fantastic of the lot...and like terence said no one cud have done it better than mayuresh bcz what he did was already the ultimate is liye meri taraf se teen taliyaan 👏👏👏...and yeah i also liked alisha's car driving move😉 and bhavana's contemporary style👏
chutneyx4404 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#14
salmaan is a good dancer. no doubt. and he's usually absolutely amazing. but i don't know why this performance is even being held in comparison to mayuresh. personally, i think this was his worst performance minus the stunt. i have to agree with the majority and say that it was mostly stunts and less dancing. mayuresh was simply amazing. he showed great skill in dancing and carried out the stunt well.
*fairytale* thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#15
Purely based on this weeks performance, I'd have to say Mayuresh.
swetha10 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#16
Mayuresh is unbeatable.. but Salman's gud too.. i would go for both....
-Ashoo- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#17
i have to say both..both are versatile!
Dabulls23 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: chutneyx4404

salmaan is a good dancer. no doubt. and he's usually absolutely amazing. but i don't know why this performance is even being held in comparison to mayuresh. personally, i think this was his worst performance minus the stunt. i have to agree with the majority and say that it was mostly stunts and less dancing. mayuresh was simply amazing. he showed great skill in dancing and carried out the stunt well.

4404 X chutney ji,
I agree with you completely on both Salman & Mayuresh....👏
Tamedtempest thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: andysah

I think people are confusing between degree of difficulty and execution. Lets say an Indian ice dancer tries to land a quad Salchow in a competition and breaks every bone in her body. So does she get a gold medal because of the degree of difficulty or does the judges look for execution also?

Salman's dance was with a high degree of difficulty (accepting Remo's argument about mask and bandages in the body, though chou dancers are able to perform with all these) but just was not executed well. I liked that he is brave and literally flaming hot but Mayuresh was simply superb today. He executed perfectly.
Bhavna was surprisingly good. Siddesh, Jai as usual were great. Rakhi was unsurprisingly bad and the judges still supported her. What else is new?
Loved Geeta's comment about Sholay and Mausi.
Mithunda had an unintentional funny moment. So the winner will get contract, money and fame but above all he will get a Topi. Topi is above everything else. Let us bow down to the power of Taqdeer ki Topi.

👏👏👏 Very intelligent post, I appreciate it! Thank you for that!

Very good distinction. At times I can't help but feel people confuse attractive with great dancer...Im just saying.....
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: andysah

I think people are confusing between degree of difficulty and execution. Lets say an Indian ice dancer tries to land a quad Salchow in a competition and breaks every bone in her body. So does she get a gold medal because of the degree of difficulty or does the judges look for execution also?

Salman's dance was with a high degree of difficulty (accepting Remo's argument about mask and bandages in the body, though chou dancers are able to perform with all these) but just was not executed well. I liked that he is brave and literally flaming hot but Mayuresh was simply superb today. He executed perfectly.
Bhavna was surprisingly good. Siddesh, Jai as usual were great. Rakhi was unsurprisingly bad and the judges still supported her. What else is new?

Very well said!! 👏 👏 I completely agree with you here... I pick Mayuresh in terms of performance. 👏
Even what Mayuersh did was equally risky - remember what Terence had said after that - and how he was sitting there so tensed with his fingers crossed... If Mayuresh had made a mistake, it would have cost him a lot, and we would have lost a good dancer from the show - he would have got injured real bad, and he did all that without any protection - we got to take that also into account. 😃
What Salman did was a copy of an already existing traditional dance form for a group of people... I find it hard to accept it as a great talent, as it's more stunt than dance, as many have pointed out... Those people have been doing that for generations, with lesser practice and protection anyway. If it was a cultural night, and he did that to dedicate to those people and to promote their culture, I would have understood, but this is a competition and he should have done a good dance instead... 😊
I like Siddesh too and he did a very good job; and for the first time I enjoyed Bhavana's dance! Jai, Alisha and Vrushali were good too. Everyone else was so-so... Rakhi - gees!! What a vulgar number!!! It made me puke - literally!! 🤢 Remo is making her use her underrated and unwanted body projections to seduce people to vote for her!! Disgusting!!! 😡 Even the cabaret item dancers in the movies do a way better job than her!! She looked so cheap with that dance - I wish someone makes her understand that...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".