STORY CONTEST - 1 : CRY FOR HELP [Contest Closed] - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

174

Views

38k

Users

18

Likes

133

Frequent Posters

prabha. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#71

Hello Everyone I am back. Thankfully I took all you stories with me, so atleast had some entertainment away from home. I have completed my comments for all the stories here

I request readers to please send me ratings out of 10 for every story you read. Those who send me feedback for stories kindly be careful and sure about the story number. There seems to be some confusion between Story No.2 and Story No. 3. Check the first post of this thread.
@Sunny - I think your feedback for Story No. 2 is actually for Story No. 3. Kindly verify.
Edited by prabha. - 15 years ago
prabha. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#72

FEEDBACK FROM A READER

===============================

My Analyses for each story... Authors, please dont mind whatever am going to say!!! Though I have guessed some writers, very specially undoubtedly one of them, I am still not sure of the identity... Irrespectively am going to treat everyone equally!!

Story 1
- Very unusual plot! The writing is good! The idea is fresh. It was awkward reading dialogues in hindi, but nevertheless the writer has written with confidence. And I have an idea who wrote it 😛 Kudos! And keep it up!👏

Story 2- Loved it! Very simple and straightforward! Language is crystal clear and the culprit is slightly unexpected. And the way she was framed- wow, fantastic! And I seem to know who wrote this too!! 👏 All the best for the future stories!😃

Story 3- Very nicely short and crisp!! The writer hasnt wasted any time with unnecessary scenes. Everyone in this story is professional!! 👏 Writer of this story, This is really a nice story with a very cool fantastic twist! You keep it up!👏😛

Story 4- Very good and stylish and professionally handled story. No unnecessary scene, though the dinner scene is a bit tarika-centric. U cud have given some other conversation! Abhi-Daya dont always talk abt tarika! But the rest of the story was really really good and unexpected. Salunkhe's way of analysing the photo was really great!👏😊

Story 5- Really fantastic, fast paced, active, no-nonsense and realistic! The only thing is it took some time to read because of the coloured fonts. It made my eyes strained. But I enjoyed reading it!👏😛

Story 6- 😊 As usual, very unusual ending! Very much like the old CID era! Twist after twist and d culprit actually a culprit. Really well written!👏 Reminded me of the Asha-Sudhakar era!

Story 7- The writer I have seemed to guess... And it was fun to read it!! Really clear and fast and realistic! Nothing to criticise actually! Really well-written! Keep it up!😊👏

Story 8- A little confusing nevertheless good handling of the plot. Well managed trick to bring up a bit of Abhi's past, but then it shifted a bit from the plot. It became Abhi-centric at the end, with him (Again!) in the hospital. Still too emotional scenes were not there and that was gud. Anyway. Good writing😊👏

Story 9- Guessed the writer again and its quite wow! Really touching! And Acp shone through out and Abhi had full trust in wat he was doing! Daya and others were also very gud! Professionally handled story with a twist! really gud!😃👏

Story 10- No comment. quite okay and a little long and abrupt! But a gud reading! Hindi too simplistic! Culprit was expected! But nevertheless very nice attempt. But more confidence is needed to write such stories! And have guessed who the writer is... There are some bits of unrealistic loose ends too. But very nice and refreshing to read too!😛👏

Story 11- Ending was fantastic and realistic! Very funny scenes in parts of the stories- I liked that! Especially in the disguise discussion and the disguise scenes! Abhi sir and his disguise- well utilized! Very gud work!👏 Really keep it up!😊

Story 12- Unusual and full of suspense👏. Several subplots merged together in a gud attempt! Slightly confusing and a bit away from the central plot, but nevertheless really gud job! Wonderfully written!😃

Story 13- A very well written story. But confusing at parts... Ending was a twist 👏and that was unusual! Very gud job! Kudos! And I feel I know who the writer is!😛

Each story is well-written and each writer has really tried! Very difficult to rate! Keep it up!

sneh. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#73
hey thanx prabha for that analysis new story writers like me really require it I hope its fine wid u if I pm u the ratings for the stories by tom
Edited by sneha_fighter - 15 years ago
Bhavanab thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#74
hey thanks for commenting on the stories,i've understood my areas of improvement very well and will definitely try and improve my next one for sure
sunnyp1414 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#75
At prabha thanks for pointing out my area of improvement. I will surely try my best in next story keeping in mind pointed out by prabha and anonymous reader . Thanks for encouragement.
Shagnika thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#76
Thanx prabha di for commenting...will keep in mind ur suggestions while writing the next stories...😃
prabha. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#77

FEEDBACK FROM A READER

===============================

Story 1: Found it a bit difficult to digest in English

Story 3: Would have liked it to be longer

Story 5: Nakli gun, good

Story 6: Loved to see that she was guilty in the end

Story 8: Complicated medical terminology, couldn't follow that bit, and again...shooting Abhi Sir was not necessary

Story 10: Two stories running in parallel was a bit confusing

Story 11: Didn't the previous investigators look for fingerprints on the guitar? Otherwise very interesting; our team in disguise is always a pleasure to imagine, scene 9 was a bit out of place

Story 12: Again two stories running in parallel was a bit confusing

Story 13: Good opportunity given to Tasha

Edited by prabha. - 15 years ago
sneh. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#78
what about story 2 4 7 9 😕
prabha. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#79

There was another thing I wanted to thank all the participants for. I am happy that all participants have concentrated on the plot and not gone crazy with trying to write dialogs in every CID Team Member's style. I was dreading that I will get to read Abhi Sir's Hain Hain countless number of time, but that did not happen. Silly humor and the non-sense in the Forensic lab were not used much. Freddie is mostly not used as a joker.

@sneha_fighter Possibly has not read yet.
Edited by prabha. - 15 years ago
sneh. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#80
ohhhk and we are not supposed to rate our own stories rite? I mean we cant actually atleast I cant
Edited by sneha_fighter - 15 years ago

Related Topics

CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

5 months ago

CID Banner Contest 2025 Results

Hello everyone, it is with great pleasure that I announce the BC is now over and we have a fresh new banner for the forum! Firstly our runner-up...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

5 months ago

CID Banner Contest 2025 Voting

Hello everyone, It is time for the CID Banner Contest Voting round. Before you jump in, please do read the rules. You can vote for TWO Banners...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

5 months ago

CID Banner Contest 2025 (Date Extended)

Hello folks! With the return of CID we obviously need a new banner, so it's time for CID Banner Contest 2025. Before you jump in, please do read...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: TianaWrites

22 days ago

Memories of a Shadow ~ A Short Story Chapter 5 Page 2

My rendezvous with chatgpt inspired me to start writing again... so here I am with a new story. The story will be of genre drama with a...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: SilverBell

2 months ago

Writers Write A Story Where The CID Finally Kills The Eye Gang

Hey Writers Please A Write A Story Where The Eye Gang Gets Killed Off By The CID Officers Instead The Dragging In The Series So We Will Be Happy...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".