Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.6k

Users

11

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Sandeepa108

Thanks for a superb analysis Misti. I agree with all your points, especially about the way the show is depicting Kanha. I am a Kanha devotee and have been insulted by the CVs lack of sensitivity and basic spirtual knowledge since the burning track. Everything else I am feeling about the current track was expressed beautifully by Why3, so I have nothing more to add.

Thanks as always for your commentary!



You are welcome Sandeepa........the creatives are treating the audience faith in God.....Kanha here as a joke. They keep on insulting the audience and are not at all apologetic about it.............anyway why should they be when the adequate TRPs are coming in and so also the financial gains....thats what they are all interested it.........I am talking both for DJ creatives and ZEE tv.
radev_66 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
thanks for the analysis misti.
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: n_sinha

This is really nice...it's very well written and thanks for the interesting post.. 👏

I really enjoy your post. 😊

Love your writing style and humor.

Keep up the great work.. 👍🏼



You ae welcome n_sinha. I am glad that you liked it.
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14
Mishti,
Appreciate the review. You covered a lot of things that I was so p**sed off with CB lately. But there were some things that I do not agree with, but thats not the point.

Todays episode was completely loaded with melodrama in all caps, highlighted, bolded, underlined. 😡

Yday I read some of the forumers views and ended up watching the episode in the evening. So went and watched the episode of todays before I read anyone's views.

Giving more screen time to Mrinalini is just for "passing time" .. there is no depth/growth/extension to that character, just used as caricature bcos it has to drag to that their other scenes fall in place in the order they want. Her story stays there without moving an inch. What a waste of time, energy and money.

Yes, since they need Amma around, they can't let Radhika reveal Amma's atrocities bcos it suits them. Same with some of Radhika's new dialogues ...bcos it suits them. Not impressed at all and neither any sympathies. There was no need of screaching, screaming, echoing, pointing fingers. Also noticed that they have edited out the part where she says in the promo "people will lose faith on you, kanha" part.

Want to ignore the blunders, but then let it be on record -
1. She was standing so much away from the Kanda's idol in the house and she hold the kanha chain and drops it down. If done it correctly, it should drop near her legs, unless she is playing "throw-ball" with the chain, that it lands on the kanha's pedestal.

2. She was washing utensil .. the large utensils and they were round edged ones , how the heck did she manage to cut herself on the back side of the hand? If they want to show she getting cut, then show she was cleaning a knife ! or cutting vegetables at a catering place.

Just, remembered 1 more thing, so:
3. Mosquitos know that Dadima is not well so they don't bite her and only bite Mrinu dahling? What about Vivek, Birju, Vaishali, Radhika? Why show such illogical things chunnu-munnu? Atleast show others are also bothered about the mosquitoes but don't over-react like Mrinu? So, are we supposed to laugh at Mrinu's plight? Weird!

p.s: Mishti, there was a small mistake (a typo?) is the mosquito part of your review where you said "Dhanno gets angry and says because of you this is my condition and then starts scratching her back.....😲" , actually it was chamak, instead of Dhanno that says that.😊

Edited by bee5 - 15 years ago
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: why3

Misti,

....<snip>....
The creatives are writing the track in such a way where Radhika is a superwoman who single handedly looks after her family (cooking, cleaning and also working outside as well as doing all duties of DIL and grand DIL) and is the most suffering (doing menial jobs to provide food to the family) and searching for Dev at the same time. They just couldn't show the rest of the family pulling their weight or making the story more logical and consistent.
....<snip>....



Why3,
Exactly !!! She has to be shown "mahaan" and hence showing all these dramas.

These creatives make her point fingers, question, screech and scream at their whimps and fancies. Whenever they want, they make her questions someone and whenever they want, they keep her mum and let her be humiliated and abused about. Whenever they want they make her scream, screech and boast and whenever they want they use her to make others understand. So poorly handled character, not just her, its the same thing going on for so many months now. There is no consistency. I for one, do not see this as a growth in character or "becoming stronger" or "becoming tiger". I totally disagree on that part among a lot of folks here.

Yes, characters are the puppets in the hands of the writer .. but this shoddily treated characters ?! Do they even believe in what they write. Utter crap.


And about her doing all the menial work, they are copying their own previous story. They are doing it from the beginning, where Radhika was doing all the household work like cooking, cleaning, doing the dishes, feeding the cows , so on and so forth... If I am their advocate, I would argue, earlier when Dev was behind Radhika, she had this image of simple, hardworking dutiful girl and they got good TRPs, so why not now .. only difference Radhika is looking for Dev instead of the other way around. Simple formula to get back the TRPs.

Edited by bee5 - 15 years ago
Angie12 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: bee5



Why3,
Exactly !!! She has to be shown "mahaan" and hence showing all these dramas.

These creatives make her point fingers, question, screech and scream at their whimps and fancies. Whenever they want, they make her questions someone and whenever they want, they keep her mum and let her be humiliated and abused about. Whenever they want they make her scream, screech and boast and whenever they want they use her to make others understand. So poorly handled character, not just her, its the same thing going on for so many months now. There is no consistency. I for one, do not see this as a growth in character or "becoming stronger" or "becoming tiger". I totally disagree on that part among a lot of folks here.

Yes, characters are the puppets in the hands of the writer .. but this shoddily treated characters ?! Do they even believe in what they write. Utter crap.


And about her doing all the menial work, they are copying their own previous story. They are doing it from the beginning, where Radhika was doing all the household work like cooking, cleaning, doing the dishes, feeding the cows , so on and so forth... If I am their advocate, I would argue, earlier when Dev was behind Radhika, she had this image of simple, hardworking dutiful girl and they got good TRPs, so why not now .. only difference Radhika is looking for Dev instead of the other way around. Simple formula to get back the TRPs.

Bee, right now all the dialogues and the track is written to boost TRPs. So, instead of showing consistent growth (once she decides she is not going to take abuse, she won't from anyone and why should she now anyway? She was a respected Mrs. RP who is loved unconditionally by her husband and is at least treated with respect from most of his family members) in Radhika's character, they ping pong to suit their tracks. So, she can be tigress with Shantanu and a lamb with Amma and Vishaka. She is physically strong enough to do all the punishments and all this household work as well as running around doing various errands, yet weak enough to be tied by Vishaka and then almost getting strangulated by her. She can see through Mrinalini's shennanigans, but can't see her mother's culpability in the entire mess. Even though she is an orphan who was abused throughout her life for having bad blood, she calls her MIL "Devi" for giving up a new born based on some superstitions.
Look, how they are not even showing Dev now because they are not sure what kind of story would increase the ratings. Also, they want to keep mystery as they for Vishaka and Shantanu. The first two backfired badly on them, but they still haven't learned from their mistakes.
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
Totally agree with you Why3. You have elaborated my points. Thanks.
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: bee5

Mishti,
Appreciate the review. You covered a lot of things that I was so p**sed off with CB lately. But there were some things that I do not agree with, but thats not the point.

Todays episode was completely loaded with melodrama in all caps, highlighted, bolded, underlined. 😡

Yday I read some of the forumers views and ended up watching the episode in the evening. So went and watched the episode of todays before I read anyone's views.

Giving more screen time to Mrinalini is just for "passing time" .. there is no depth/growth/extension to that character, just used as caricature bcos it has to drag to that their other scenes fall in place in the order they want. Her story stays there without moving an inch. What a waste of time, energy and money.

Yes, since they need Amma around, they can't let Radhika reveal Amma's atrocities bcos it suits them. Same with some of Radhika's new dialogues ...bcos it suits them. Not impressed at all and neither any sympathies. There was no need of screaching, screaming, echoing, pointing fingers. Also noticed that they have edited out the part where she says in the promo "people will lose faith on you, kanha" part.

Want to ignore the blunders, but then let it be on record -
1. She was standing so much away from the Kanda's idol in the house and she hold the kanha chain and drops it down. If done it correctly, it should drop near her legs, unless she is playing "throw-ball" with the chain, that it lands on the kanha's pedestal.

2. She was washing utensil .. the large utensils and they were round edged ones , how the heck did she manage to cut herself on the back side of the hand? If they want to show she getting cut, then show she was cleaning a knife ! or cutting vegetables at a catering place.

Just, remembered 1 more thing, so:
3. Mosquitos know that Dadima is not well so they don't bite her and only bite Mrinu dahling? What about Vivek, Birju, Vaishali, Radhika? Why show such illogical things chunnu-munnu? Atleast show others are also bothered about the mosquitoes but don't over-react like Mrinu? So, are we supposed to laugh at Mrinu's plight? Weird!

p.s: Mishti, there was a small mistake (a typo?) is the mosquito part of your review where you said "Dhanno gets angry and says because of you this is my condition and then starts scratching her back.....😲" , actually it was chamak, instead of Dhanno that says that.😊

Thanks Bee for pointing out my mistake.As soon as I saw Radhikas rant I lost my patience with the creatives. They continue doing it agian and again ....just for melodrama to ensure that the TRPs come in........the other stuff is not important for them. Ithink hey removed the "people might loose faith on kanah" part because that will be too close to home.Since they are still not clear about what to do with Dev and this new girl they are inserting these useless parts like Mrinalinis rant, Vaid coming in saying weird dialogues that his expert opinion is that the patient is mentally sick.........any person with brains can say that seeing dadimas reactions and questions ...Vaishali going around saying choti bahu, choti bahu.....nobody saying anything about earning money and Radhika again being mother India and now washing heavy utensils.........the story is stuck at the same place that she saw someone who looks like Dev.........and they are going to continue on this theme until their TRPs tell them what to do.......that means this thursday............in the meantime they will show that girl clinging on to Dev again couple of times to see how people react and on the basis of which they will then write another track which might break away from whatever story this serial has. Thanks for pointing out the blunders........I didn't see them because the first scene was enough for me .
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#19
Mishti,
yes, thats right, they are "buying time" and nothing else. They drag the crappy part and don't do any justice to things that requires a decent narration. They should shut their shops and go home.
misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: shinyclassic

misti,,when we blame the cvs for all these unnecessary melodrma they show us in CB,,they start to blame kanha,,and I think cvs are blaming themselves ,,,now,,bcoz they are the fake kanha,,,who are doing all the deeds in the name of kanha,,,, first they save rad in small incidents but allow that lady to burn rad in a bid accident,,show us that radev are inseparable but bring elements like vish and santanu,,now they have made dev amnesiac and will try to make kanha's presence felt by making him ok,,,they are the one who brought kanha element in the show and contradict themselves,,,,then again when the trps will be down,,will again bring kanha...

Shiny I like this idea of CVs blaming themselves......😃.........yep actually the creaTives Kanha is the all important TRP.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".