Creatives Should Have Borrowed From Patita ... - Page 2

Originally posted by: instcris

Thanks for history/provenience of the song and for translation, Neerja! I like both, are the armonious melodies.

thank you Cristina , i just wanted to say Hindi movies are not about item-numbers and all , were very progressive in 50,s , really feel very sad , when makers do not want to come out of their narrow outlook ..

Originally posted by: set_raj

The best thing Dev could have done was to tell the truth and wait for the response and reactions from society, if they understand and supported him, matter cudhv been solved, if not then he wudhv renounce the RPship...or refuse to be a RP..and holding Radhika's hand he wudhv left the ceremony...

Yes , agree with you , but then how could have Makers favorite track of fake wife introduced in the story , without that their no soap is complete ..Thats why this movie came in to my mind ...

Originally posted by: sia_lovely

.This Film is about 50years old , and our CB is in 2011 still in the dark-ages ...Writers do not have the guts to write progressive story ...Really ashamed , try to find the easy way out ..

Exactly Neerja! This film, a 50 yr old one at that, is so progressive. But these people in 2011 made Dev such a coward? Why? Do actually people in 2011 object to this kind of marriage?

What makes a Good RPtian? Only the fact that she is an untouched woman, a pure woman? In Dev's nightmare he imagined people saying, that if a RP married such a characterless girl how will he lead the society? Why can't he? Didn't Dev have the guts to explain his stance? Wouldn't it have been better to show Dev as a true leader who brings about some reform?

His character took a decision based on his fear. If seen in a positive manner, whatever they showed did make some justice. But my main glitch -- why make Dev weak and scared? He was scared that now people would insult Rads and he would lose his sole support, Rads, who was against his belief! My main grunt against this track is that they brought down RaDev heavily! They both were given wrong ideas. I am damn sure, if Rads hadn't been so strong in her own belief, then Dev wouldn't have fallen weak either!

Society would keep pointing at every silly thing...but until someone doesn't come up to reform it, how will the society's outlook change? We wanted to see Dev standing strong despite all oppositions and asking if it would be right on his part to leave his wife? Would he be a truthful RP leader? People would scream, throw stones at him and ask him to step down. But can't he for once try to change the society. What are leaders for? Just for sitting and taking advantages of luxuries? In that case, Virat or Rohan can easily handle this post.

A RP needs to be a strong man who can withstand any situation and try to bring reforms in the society, try to preserve the righteousness in the society! Dev unfortunately failed because of his weakness!

Thanks a bunch Neerja for this beautiful song!

Thank you Sia , i agree with your comments , specially the above underlined lines ..Why makers are afraid to show some progressive thoughts still living in dark ages , in every other soap you will find some crap is going on in the name of family prestige , society or Dharam ...Makers should be responsible what they serving to the viewers as world has shrunk , soaps are watched by other countries , For your last bold lines . its the Creatives who have failed and turned leads weak and spineless without giving them any voice .in the name of Kanha ...Better Kanha should have been there with makers and gave them solid for tarnishing His name .😉.

Originally posted by: misti73

Neerja Zee is a regressive channel now...majority of the shows are regressive, so why will they show progressive thoughts?

You are right , last show i saw on this channel was Astitav and after that CB.. but i really feel sad ,about this channel as have seen some very good soaps in early day of Zee ...One was Sarhaden , was love story and many more , itself is responsible for its debacle ...

thax for telling good things from movies

Originally posted by: NiHa24

Neerja very touching song.

Thank you Niha , you are right , its very poignant song ...

Dev could have told the truth ...then after this whatever happens or questions arise He as a RP definitely could have solved the problem..but why did he lie?according to me it is a thappar or shame to RPship as a RP.. Rp should follow the truth.. My Q is if u that much love and care for ur idiot wife then resign from RP or refuse to be R P ship " and y dont u hold ur wife's hand leave from there... instead of same boring dialogue repeat na karke.."like parrot or tota ,maina.. "Radhika meri patni hai mai saara zindagi' ...,whatever... i dont even feel like to type..same lines...😆Dev is like paani mai rehna bhi hai lekin badan na bheege..

anyway very nice song i dont know it goes on Radhika or not but i love this song thats all i can say..thank u neerja..

Originally posted by: avina900

vey good songr

Thank you avina900..

Originally posted by: anu17

wow di really lovely...

Thank you Anu ..