Sneha & Vrushika: Call on Members Input MOD NOTE PAGE-15 - Page 11

Originally posted by: Mihi4VruShan

You can criticize Sharon if you are a SwaRon fan! Someone who is seen in normal happy go lucky or agonizing SwaRon topics and is a die heart VruShan fan is free to comment whatever she feels like against Vrushika because it would be constructive . But if someone who isn't even seen in regular SwaRon topics all of a sudden tells that Vrushika isn't doing well..she isn't good as Sharon at all , then people are bound to interpret this statement differently! Isn't it?

Originally posted by: Anu_TanHa

Okay so finally SwaRon fan has right to criticize character. Good to know this😊

But still condition apply..😆

Yes I want this rule to be implemented Iam fed up with these fights ( I saw other fans also taking advantage of this situation) so Mods please implement this rule

Originally posted by: SanskritiS

why only criticize?

Originally posted by: Anu_TanHa

Plz dear do read my previous comment I never said ONLY criticize ...I said ONLY praising is not good for the actor/actress..as it closes all doors for improvement.

A true fan is who point out mistakes too so their fav.can work on it to improve but only praising praising still knowing he/she on fault is called chaplusi or buttering and its bad for our fav.tooo😊

Hope i made my point clear here😊

Why is the point shifting from the main point to 'healthy criticism of characters'? Sorry but healthy criticizing posts keep coming up and proper discussion is done there too be it Sharon or Swayam and I have hardly seen those threads getting closed coz mostly people stick to episode related analysis there. And recently both KR and SS fans together do comment on those posts.

Finally some rules I am happy. Now ppl say we even cant say our sharon is best so if sk fans says sk is best ,vrushika fans do have all the rights to say vrushika is best whats a big deal. Now coming to criticism its good for both actors n the show but I dont understand why few ppl want to only criticize, even few dont watch d3 anymorestill ready to criticize thats really weird. I appreciated sk when I felt she was good n I did the same for vrushi. When sharon character butchered during sk time ppl used to blame cvs even after knowing sk had her restrictions to justify sharon still ppl say she is the only one who is able to justify but if the same cvs started butchering sharon the same ppl blames vrushika! !why she is doing what cvs want to do with sharon what is her fault. Its about acting i'll say vrushika starting days are average but ppl who used to criticize her acting wont open their mouth when she performed during ganesh mahorhsav, manor trip, break up scene, yaadein but if something goes wrong they start with vrushika. Criticism ki baath karo tho I never saw these ppl when same vrushika fans requested not to show sharon as silly, comic we did that to but ppl blame we are immature, we dont have any taste hmm by doing this they used to show their own taste. N about other fan base recently these ppl very much interested in swayam sharon they start judging before watching scene n few ppl are the same who themselves said they love vrushika, just bcs we are not making any post on their fav.that doesn't mean we considering them as best, we can also criticize then bcs its an open forum but if we do that may hurt feeling of many n forum pe aur rules badenge. Still they want to continue we are also ready to criticize as it is so good for actors, characters n show.

Originally posted by: Anu_TanHa

Plz dear do read my previous comment I never said ONLY criticize ...I said ONLY praising is not good for the actor/actress..as it closes all doors for improvement.

A true fan is who point out mistakes too so their fav.can work on it to improve but only praising praising still knowing he/she on fault is called chaplusi or buttering and its bad for our fav.tooo😊

Hope i made my point clear here😊

But if u still have any question or doubt about my post feel free to scrap me..

Not here any more, otherwise it may lead this thread into danger😊

Originally posted by: muskurana

Why is the point shifting from the main point to 'healthy criticism of characters'? Sorry but healthy criticizing posts keep coming up and proper discussion is done there too be it Sharon or Swayam and I have hardly seen those threads getting closed coz mostly people stick to episode related analysis there. And recently both KR and SS fans together do comment on those posts.

Seriously yaar I have the same question if they are so concerned about sharon then y they never open their mouth when same vrushaan fan made posts on disliking sharon comic sense, immature behavior, weird behavior during secret admire, when sharon denied her relationship almost whole forum filled with sharon hate posts tab kaha gaye the sab. Ab achanak se sharon ki padi he n their reaction for this almost like cvs did this bcs actress is the reason. Really?

Originally posted by: tannuluv

Seriously yaar I have the same question if they are so concerned about sharon then y they never open their mouth when same vrushaan fan made posts on disliking sharon comic sense, immature behavior, weird behavior during secret admire, when sharon denied her relationship almost whole forum filled with sharon hate posts tab kaha gaye the sab. Ab achanak se sharon ki padi he n their reaction for this almost like cvs did this bcs actress is the reason. Really?