Pathaan is an exception. Many factors including fans yearning for SRK contributed to its huge success.
I guess pan India basis current tendency shows that mostly larger than life movie works. Be it RRR, Brahmastra,KGF 2,Kantara,Ponniyin Selvan all are either fiction ,purely fantasy or has elements of fantasy which demands theatre experience,also except for Kantara ,other movies comes from already acknowledged PH or director.
All other pan India successful movie except for TKF are either sequels or from well known directors whose previous films were consistently successful and demanded theatre experience.
There is Vikram which created havoc in south Indian box-office not just in Tamilnadu,in Kerala,Telugu speaking states.And it is well made action thriller.
IMO now a days movies will not work just because of the actor, more than before along with genre atleast the main crew members should be appealing.
However the makers would be wondering why a well made remake like Vikram Veda flopped while another remake Dhrishyam 2 got positive box office verdict.
5