Kalank may be plagiarised...

MedhaRathore thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
Characters of Alia, Sonakshi and Aditya are complete rip offs from a book called "WHAT THE BODY REMEMBERS"

Here are some book reviews that you can take as SPOILERS.




"Roop grows up believing that she is destined to a better life. When Bachan Singh gets a proposal from one of the wealthiest men in the village for his daughter, he is delighted, only to be disappointed when he realizes that it is not for one of the wealthy man's sons. but for an already married relative of his. However, already in debt after his elder daughter's wedding, Bachan Singh does not have much of an option but to agree. Bachan Singh might have been heavy hearted but Roop was delighted. She was convinced that she has a wonderful fate in store for her. Even becoming a second wife does not faze her. She believes that she will be a little sister to her older co-wife.

Satya, Sardarji's wife is sophisticated, the perfect mate to the Oxford educated Sardarji. Perfect, but for the fact that she is barren. She tries hard to fight her fate, hoping that Sardarji will refuse to take a second wife, only to realize that despite his educational credentials, Sardarji is still bound by his roots. Having an heir, a son, is very important to him.

She is hit hard by the fact that the new bride has got handed all her jewellery. Everything that was hers is now Roop's. Satya tries everything she can to ensure that Sardarji's second marriage is ruined.

It is a touching story woven through the landscape of political landscape of unrest and eventually India's Partition into India and Pakistan.

Roop's initial innocence, trying hard to please everybody, believing that she and Satya would be like sisters, her compliance and her slow metamorphosis into her own person, somebody who understood that she had to fight for her rights in every way she could. She learns the ways of the world to survive, to hold on to her position, as the mother of Sardarji's children.

Sardarji, again a complex character, educated in England, a civil engineer, outwardly a modern person, but when it came to his inner self, someone who held on to the views of his society. He tries to saddle both his worlds, wining and dining with his English colleagues, while looking down on them(just as they did him), and his life in Indian society.

Satya's bitterness, her inability to accept her fate, trying everything she could to ensure that Roop is just a baby maker, and not Sardarji's wife. Satya comes across as a strong person, someone who knows her rights, and tries to fight society in the way she could. A woman who argues with her husband, who refuses to be sweet-sweet' in front of her husband, a woman who believes that she is her husband's equal.

The book is also sprinkled with instances of how underprivileged women(and girls) were in those days. At her father's place, Roop had never tasted meat or fish that was reserved for her brother, because the whole family's fortune rested on him. The girls would just be married off. Roop's unmarried aunt (MAYBE MADHURI'S CHARACTER), who keeps planning to leave, but everybody is aware, that she will never leave. After all, as an unmarried woman, she does not have a house of her own, to go to.

The book also deals with the way political unrest changed life as they knew it. Once Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs lived together in harmony, but with the partition looming closer, things changed, loyalties changed...Life as they knew it changed. It also reflects how Sikhs viewed the partition. While carving out countries keeping in mind the two main communities, Sikhs were the ones who were uprooted from their land and made to migrate into a new, foreign land. One stroke of the pen that made them foreigners in their own land.. A partition when one minority was almost entirely ignored.."

...



"The two women, their completely different characters and their love for Saradarji are at the heart of this book. Satya, the first wife, comes from a aristocratic family and is elegant, intelligent and beautiful. Sardarji is her life. She showers him with love, protects him and his interests fiercely, manages his home and estate and strives to match his progressiveness and intellect. She cannot believe that he can cast her aside for Roop, the village girl with nothing but beauty and a fertile womb to offer him. Roop on the other hand, the butt of Satya's anger and hurt pride, must learn to combat her powerful opponent in order to survive and secure her place.

The heartbreak that underlies every aspect of the book comes from the hopelessness of each struggle. Sardarji cannot become an Englishman no matter how much he wants to. Partition is an inevitable reality and the family is destined to lose everything. Roop and Satya, are pitted against each other as co-wives by the man they both love. And saddest of all is Satya's undying desire, to be born into an age where women are cherished, wanted and are considered equal to men in all things. A desire she takes to her untimely grave."
Edited by MedhaRathore - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

68

Views

5.8k

Users

39

Likes

107

Frequent Posters

1123190 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
So its adapted from this book.
MedhaRathore thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Malpua

So its adapted from this book.


Only 3 characters, Zafar is nowhere in the book.

Kalank basically focuses on Zafar and Roop. So I guess that is a mystery.


Edited by MedhaRathore - 6 years ago
mystic786 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#4
Why haven't they said that it's inspired by this book? 😕😆
cool-boy_018 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5
You are making this claim based on the teaser that didn't even have 1 dialogue?
lol
cool-boy_018 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: MedhaRathore


Only 3 characters, Zafar is nowhere in the book.

Kalank basically focuses on Zafar and Roop. So I guess that is a mystery.




The title of your thread says Kalank is a total rip off. How could it be a total rip off if the book doesn't even have a character like Varun who the lead actor of the movie?
anjs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 6 years ago
#7
So Ark sonakshi's characters are as important as roop in the book...but of course here its kjo...
So it means roop will be married against her wish, sardarji will die during partition rights and roop will go with zafar in the end, maybe satya herself will send roop n zafar away...

By the way, the songs and the sets doesn't show roop's or her aunts poor financial conditions.
astha36 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#8
Karan could never make a movie on this story. He can't make anything this complex and real. Pretty sure Sonakshi won't have much depth to her character and Alia will get the best dialogues, best scenes and a lot of layers to hers. Varun is the kandha to the bechari second wife and then their extramarital affair will start. Let's see how it fares out eventually.
Chikni_Khargosh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#9
I guess they adapted the storyline and modified.
But they should have mentioned this 😕
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

So our guess abt the story was right? 😆
Aristocrat's wife unable to bear children so he marries a younger girl to beget an heir.
They copied this part of the story but what abt the rest? Madhuri's character who is a courtesan, Zafar who is her illegitimate son, and is Sanju ARK's and Zafar's dad?

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood ¡ 1 months ago

https://x.com/i/status/2024419741725552894

https://x.com/i/status/2024419741725552894
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche ¡ 1 months ago

https://x.com/alwaysbollywood/status/2018865271461814479?s=46

https://x.com/alwaysbollywood/status/2018865271461814479
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche ¡ 2 months ago

https://x.com/Rahulrautwrites/status/2008945092095300046?s=20

https://x.com/Rahulrautwrites/status/2008945092095300046
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: iamrebelheart ¡ 3 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/p/DR8svztDPtU/?igsh=MTNzbmNraXFqMXh2NA==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DR8svztDPtU/
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".