Bahubali 2's success shows up the north's ignorance of south - Page 10

Originally posted by: Padfoot_Prongs

But they have English on their boards. instructions in Hindi helps whole north India. According to ur logic, Placards wud have to be placed in every language. Any regional office like Andhra Bahwan or Tamil Bhawan etc. have boards in their languages. and hindi populaton going there and settling wont change much except may be learning the native language just like Keralaites who reside in Delhi do. I dont see them changing the South culture. It is Indian Culture's beauty. A migrant hardly affect things on bigger scale. Keralite residing in Delhi will adapt to its culture and a north Indian going to Kerala will do the same. They are not putting Hindi above native languages. they did not remove regional language from the boards.

On Brahmanism, the person said that UP Brahmanism is being transported to South. South have their more vicious version of Brahmanism. In politics. they may not have big say directly but they are bigger part of bureaucracy. every part of India have Brahmanism differing from others and nothing can change them. UP's different from Tamil Nadu and UP's one cant effect TN's one.

@bold shows the issues is. India in now caught up and learning English. So English and local language(s) should be enough. Kearalites who reside in Delhi, their second generation learnt and speaks HIndi. How many in Bangalore whose second generation does not speak the local language.

You can say a migrant hardly affects, and say Keralite living in Delhi willa deapt while NI going to Kerala will do the same. But when the services and education are set up in a way in which they don't need to, that is exactly what will happen.

And yes, local language was removed from many highways. I will try to search for the pics, but they were. And all it proves is that if not now, after the outcry, it will be attempted again. Then again, then again. Until it becomes norm.

It's not just the boards. It's everything else combined with it. Policies designed to help Hindi speakers over others.

South have vicious version which social changes and politics have kept in check. But who is getting free hand where, and that's the politics that they try to import down to TN and Kerala to undermine the advances made to keep it in check.

Originally posted by: guess.wh0

Some of the posts on here are so ridiculous. I have 0 interest in south Indian cinema, I don't understand the languages and I have no desire to watch a dubbed film. Meri marzi...
Its as ridiculous as a Punjabi calling South Indians ignorant because they have 0 knowledge of Bhangra/Punjabi music, which is way bigger than Bollywood music, except the few tunes Bollywood 'rearranges' and 'rehashes'.
The Hindi Propaganda has been there for years and isn't just relegated to South Indian states but I get the point behind it. It's made to make communication easier when moving from one state to another. Hindi had the largest number of speakers so they decided to go with Hindi. It makes sense on a lot of levels. You can't be expected to learn a new language moving from one state to another. How would that work? The point is you should learn your mother tongue, but it would be to your own benefit to know Hindi & especially English if you plan to pursue life and opportunities away from the little caccon, that is your state.
Lastly, none of this has anything to do with Bahubali, anchors make mistakes all the time. To make this a political debate and call others ignorant just reeks of insecurity.

And have local languages relegated as lower class, which is in the Railways Act itself. Hindi's large numbers come after including the so-called 'dialects' which are older than Hindi itself.

Once again, cannot be expected to learn a new language is bull. How many times do you move from state to state? And English as link language is enough. Hindi is not needed. English is enough, there is no need to promote Hindi over other languages. If need, let states who are Hind-speaking promote. Union promoting, giving incentives, placing Hindi-fluency levels for jobs which Hindi is not needed--all directly hurt the local languages.

Originally posted by: guess.wh0

Some of the posts on here are so ridiculous. I have 0 interest in south Indian cinema, I don't understand the languages and I have no desire to watch a dubbed film. Meri marzi...

Assam
https://twitter.com/himjyoti/status/856174058253279232

Odisha
https://twitter.com/GargaC/status/855389456055943168
https://twitter.com/SirDebasis/status/855397359018168320

Railway Week Celebrations in Chennai
https://twitter.com/boopalsridhar/status/852051529251119105

Karnataka coming up

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

And have local languages relegated as lower class, which is in the Railways Act itself. Hindi's large numbers come after including the so-called 'dialects' which are older than Hindi itself.

Once again, cannot be expected to learn a new language is bull. How many times do you move from state to state? And English as link language is enough. Hindi is not needed. English is enough, there is no need to promote Hindi over other languages. If need, let states who are Hind-speaking promote. Union promoting, giving incentives, placing Hindi-fluency levels for jobs which Hindi is not needed--all directly hurt the local languages.

Originally posted by: lailaMai

ok here i agree with guess who!! hindi the dilect know as (khadi boli) is our national language and english the official language!!The official languages of the Union Government of the Republic of India are 21 languages and English as mentioned in article 343/1 of the Constitution of India.,you can't expect people to know regional languages unless they are living there or moved to some state!!

Hindi is not the national language. There is no one national language in India. India has no national language. Hindi and English, after the South fought for it are the official languages of the union.

States were/are allowed to conduct in their own languages.

But when Railways, Highways, Education, Banks, all have various Hindi imposition by the Centre, then Hindi being the sole official Indian language of the union poses a very serious problem.

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

Assam
https://twitter.com/himjyoti/status/856174058253279232

Odisha
https://twitter.com/GargaC/status/855389456055943168
https://twitter.com/SirDebasis/status/855397359018168320

Railway Week Celebrations in Chennai
https://twitter.com/boopalsridhar/status/852051529251119105

Karnataka coming up

Karnataka markers in only Hindi

https://twitter.com/hariprasadholla/status/775890934407888896

https://twitter.com/hariprasadholla/status/769805052290535427

This is all just the tip of the iceberg. Those who want to look into it, can do so.

And those who will continue to say the same old, same old--it's obvious that it's never going to make any impact no matter what and you will go on to support Hindi imperialism and flick off/ dismiss why people are opposing it in their own lands.🥱

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

Hindi is not the national language. There is no one national language in India. India has no national language. Hindi and English, after the South fought for it are the official languages of the union.

States were/are allowed to conduct in their own languages.

But when Railways, Highways, Education, Banks, all have various Hindi imposition by the Centre, then Hindi being the sole official Indian language of the union poses a very serious problem.

Hindi versus other languages debate. This is defenitely not because of British. If they had not ruled us, we all would have belonged to different kingdoms. We would have fought and got our independence separately and be different countries (like countries in EU). Let us not blame British for Hindi domination.




What bothers many South Indians is the way they are perceived by many North Indians. South Indians are just some dark human beings who are not as handsome as them. This is despite being economically and technically more advanced. Four decades after independence, India was still underdeveloped or developing country. In few years, it changed its course. India and China's name started appearing in prime time news of western media. The man who made this happen in few years time was a South Indian who probably looked like an ape to North Indians. Brain is beyond looks.

But when Railways, Highways, Education, Banks, all have various Hindi imposition by the Centre, then Hindi being the sole official Indian language of the union poses a very serious problem.