Ajay or Aamir?

Sultan Mirza - Ajay Devgn - the one who won NATIONAL AWARD BEST ACTOR.

I think people should be selected from IF BW forum to be jury in all the award shows including National Award..they are becoming sooo good at judging..so many "better actor/actress" threads...

Both are one of such people in BW who I really like & admire as an actor. Ajay is a fabulous actor but I find Aamir much better than AD. Aamir has that acting gene in him. He's effortlessly phenomenal & more natural Ajay IMO

Ajay is more talented, but Aamir makes up what he lacks in talent with sheer hardwork and preparation, plus I will give Aamir one more point because unlike Ajay, he gets in the physique of the character. He can convincingly look like a college student in 3 idiots and than convincingly look like middle aged man in Talaash, look literally like a out of the world alien in PK and than look like a old, strict man in Dangal. He is incredible when it comes to physical side of acting.

edit: Don't get me wrong my vote is still for AD, just explaining why Aamir is also a great actor, who always get neglected in great actor discussions because for some fab groups every thing he has achieved is because of others and not him 😆.

Ajay .. Zakhm was fabulous, so was HDDCS.. even in PTHHT , Omkara and dhrishyam Ajay acted brilliantly.. Aamir is good only when given a good script, he was constipated in Dhoom3, average in Ghajni .. I loved his performance in Talaash though, his best in this decade.

Originally posted by: Love_Katty_24-7

Ajay is more talented, but Aamir makes up what he lacks in talent with sheer hardwork and preparation, plus I will give Aamir one more point because unlike Ajay, he gets in the physique of the character. He can convincingly look like a college student in 3 idiots and than convincingly look like middle aged man in Talaash, look literally like a out of the world alien in PK and than look like a old, strict man in Dangal. He is incredible when it comes to physical side of acting.

+1 Very nicely explained. He literally looked like an Alien in PK to be frank 😆 He was just incredible in the film.

Ajay is the best actor from his generation

Ajay is a better actor with the ability to potray diffrent characters that are given to him. He can do a better job than Aamir in Drama & Intense roles e.g. The Legend of Bhagat Singh, Zakhm, Company, Once Upon a Time in Mumbai, Gangaajal, Omkara, Drishyam, Dilwale & ect.

Plus, he scores over Aamir in negative roles e.g. Deewangee, Khakee & Blackmail.

Aamir is terrific when it comes to doing unique roles and PK is just a prefect example as he was superb. I can't imagine any other actor doing it. He's more capable than Ajay in terms of Comedy & Romance.

Originally posted by: TeAmo_Messi

Ajay .. Zakhm was fabulous, so was HDDCS.. even in PTHHT , Omkara and dhrishyam Ajay acted brilliantly.. Aamir is good only when given a good script, he was constipated in Dhoom3, average in Ghajni .. I loved his performance in Talaash though, his best in this decade.

is it reaction due to an Aamir fan bashing Hrithik? 😆 just asking bcoz I remember last time I read ur comment in some post where u had mentioned that u liked his performance in Ghajini...

I would say Ajay Devgn is the overall better actor, he is more versatile and more expressive.