When Salman and Ranbir film clashed

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Yuvika

@Yuvika_15

Moderator

+ 9

Posted: 11 years ago

#81

Originally posted by: ..Kirann..
I see your point TM. Yes every actor has flops in their career. Hits and flops are part of their life. Besahram's result isn't going to make RK any less of a star but it will certainly shut some people who were over hyping him and exaggerating about his star-power. I personally remember reading some posts by fans claiming RK will take over Khans, Besahram will beat CE's records and also few articles stating the same. I think that's why Khan fans are celebrating. Not because this makes RK any less of a star but because all those people who were making such big claims have been proven wrong. So I don't see why same people are crying foul now and coming up with excuses like 'every star has flops', or 'even Khans had flops' and blah blah. Sure every star has flops and no one's denying that. But don't come up with such lame excuses when you've been proven wrong. At least stick to your words.

Personally, I love watching RK on-screen. I think he is amazing and he already is a big star. Maybe not as big as Khans yet but he's big enough. This one flop isn't going to affect his career. Hopefully, he'll bounce back with his upcoming movies. All the best to him!

good points u have made... I mean even HR who has been here longer and proven to be a good actor over the years when placed in the same league as Aamir, SRK and Salman is said to be unfair and wrong - I remember once Anil Kapoor said on KWK, that HR has a long way 2 go and its not right for him 2 be put in the same league as actors who have established themselves in BW for longer years. the same goes for Ranbir...compare him with those who started off with him... i.e. Imran. not with those who have been here longer! in comparison to Imran who started off abt the same time as him, RK has done a lot better. when u make such a comparison it seems a lot more fairer.

Quote

kiran khurana

@.Kiran.

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#82

Originally posted by: Yuvika_15
good points u have made... I mean even HR who has been here longer and proven to be a good actor over the years when placed in the same league as Aamir, SRK and Salman is said to be unfair and wrong - I remember once Anil Kapoor said on KWK, that HR has a long way 2 go and its not right for him 2 be put in the same league as actors who have established themselves in BW for longer years. the same goes for Ranbir...compare him with those who started off with him... i.e. Imran. not with those who have been here longer! in comparison to Imran who started off abt the same time as him, RK has done a lot better. when u make such a comparison it seems a lot more fairer.

Even if people wanna compare him with Khans, they are more than welcome to. I, personally, remember reading some posts saying 'RK's Besahram will beat CE's records', 'he will take over Khans' etc and honestly, I don't have any problem with them making such posts but at least stick to your points. Don't cry foul later and come up with lame excuses.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Yuvika

@Yuvika_15

Moderator

+ 9

Posted: 11 years ago

#83

Originally posted by: ..Kirann..
Even if people wanna compare him with Khans, they are more than welcome to. I, personally, remember reading some posts saying 'RK's Besahram will beat CE's records', 'he will take over Khans' etc and honestly, I don't have any problem with them making such posts but at least stick to your points. Don't cry foul later and come up with lame excuses.

I don't get why people make such speculations so early on...let the film be released and then analyse your predictions cos till its released u don't even know the story for sure. u only get a brief idea from the trailer but even that can sometimes be misleading...

u know for sure if a movie will break records if it maintains consistency in its BO performance... which will indicate that people are returning to watch the movie again... its repeat sales that make the hits what they are... one offs can only give business for the first few days but for the business to remain for coming weeks its all down to people going to watch it again and again.

agree that people should later make excuses for it. but I guess that's all they can do. 😕

Quote

Johnny.Balraj

@Johnny.Balraj

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#84

Originally posted by: ..Kirann..

Even if people wanna compare him with Khans, they are more than welcome to. I, personally, remember reading some posts saying 'RK's Besahram will beat CE's records', 'he will take over Khans' etc and honestly, I don't have any problem with them making such posts but at least stick to your points. Don't cry foul later and come up with lame excuses.

I never said anything about Ranbir beating Khans.

it will take years for Ranbir to reach stardom of Salman , SRK etc. I am just saying everyone has a bad film or a flop.

MAYBE I presented my point in a manner, which offended some Salman fans. I shouldn't have done it.

No way I meant to disrespect Salman khan by comparing him to Ranbir with these figures.

Edited by DAKDAK - 11 years ago

Quote

kiran khurana

@.Kiran.

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#85

Originally posted by: DAKDAK

I never said anything about Ranbir beating Khans.

it will years for Ranbir to reach stardom of Salman , SRK etc. I am just saying everyone has a bad film or a flop.

MAYBE I presented my point in a manner, which offended some Salman fans. I shouldn't have done it.

No way I meant to disrespect Salman khan by comparing him to Ranbir with these figures.

No NO I didn't mean you said it. I just meant in general. & There's nothing offensive in your post. I'm sorry if my comment offended you. I was just saying in general. Every actor has flops in their career, one flop isn't going to ruin their stardom. It didn't ruin Salman's stardom and Besharam's result isn't going to end RK's career either:)

Quote

Yuvika

@Yuvika_15

Moderator

+ 9

Posted: 11 years ago

#86

Originally posted by: DAKDAK
I never said anything about Ranbir beating Khans.

it will years for Ranbir to reach stardom of Salman , SRK etc. I am just saying everyone has a bad film or a flop.

MAYBE I presented my point in a manner, which offended some Salman fans. I shouldn't have done it.

No way I meant to disrespect Salman khan by comparing him to Ranbir with these figures.

I don't think u presented ur point in a bad manner at all... im a huge salman fan and was surely not offended by ur post... everyone will perceive your post differently, but don't start questioning if u were wrong, as long as u know u didnt mean any offence, that's all that matters. u'll always find a few that won't agree with u and in response will bash u - its always the case on this forum.. plus u clearly said that u don't mean 2 offend salman so I wouldn't worry about it.

what I personally made of ur initial comment was that u may have been trying to say that when RK and salman clashed RK did better as a newcomer than SK who was an established actor...and by showing that I I thought u were trying to prove that if the script is bad then even the biggest star can't save it from a disaster i.e. SRK with paheli and Salman with GTGH...and that's the same with RK with Besharam... and that those flops didnt affect SK and SRK's star power so besharam wont affect RK's starpower either.

I noticed u said in a previous comment ur leaving IF - hoping its not due to the bashing u got. anyway if u want to de-activate ur a/c u'll need to contact the GMs... meli is active so contact her... she's Aahana. Good luck with whatever u do in life.

Edited by Yuvika_15 - 11 years ago