Originally posted by: Fashion_2005
thats your opinion and i have different. It is not important if our views and opinion are different. Atleast we all can respect each other decisions. I love preity in KHNH and veer zaara. I disagree on the thing that if the role black offered to preity she would done good as rani did. What rani did in Black i don't think any actress could had done. What rani did she earned it by herself. Rani became number one from black and she earned the role, she worked hard for the movie as well. She learned the deaf people language of their signs. Even on her birthday she didn't celebrated but went to their school and spent her day with the kids. If jaya bachan loves preity then Amitabh loves rani mukerjee. Every person have their own views and i respect everyone fan but i think it's very unfair to call someone ugly. As a person grow older their beauty fade but heart always stay beautiful depending on what we are. I have no problem if preity talks alot or do whatever as its her life. Talking of Kajol comparing to Rani, there was an article that rani has proved by movie black, that she is one the best actress in bollywood history.If preity got the award for KHNH then rani did got the award for hum tum, yuva and black. When a actress gets to the position number one it because she earned it. Rani achieved it by herself. Even Karan johar said in the making of KANK that what rani is today because her own hard work as I never given her a big role in the movie but she proved by black.
who is talking on looks anyhow, though most mags , reviewrs, viewers, etc, said that Preity in movie was just hotttt, herbody, outfits etc, if want proof goto google and surf the net and read articles. I n this movie the winners are abhi, preity, amitabh, SRK(they mixed on him, yet I luv him yet role was not good yet kj pal so took).....all did tp pleass KJ, Maya role was weakest link in movie(goto to net and see reviews, since they speak more)
Also, I never have against any actress ok, they all human beings afterall, though most will say Ash is pretty yet acting not good which most think..
Its afact that Preity made on own, and howdare anyone say she could not do a black, she ciould, I think any actress in the top could, actually any actress if given rt training can..
Madhuri start with horrible start, thancame tezaab(and ek do teen she became a success and ruled), kajol with Gupt and kuch kuch hota hai emerged, etc,,
rani mow since kajol and madhuri out, ash only good movies were sanjay ones, and if see not at falling out ash was todo black, sanjay is a good maker and can make any actress/actor shine.. Preity is great actress in Kal ho na ho she stood out and won, she could do black(given opportunity)Its the script and role have tobe rt and Preity ios able to pull off any role, in KANK she plays a cold woman when in real she sweet outgoing, she pulled it off, so its wrong to sterotype( when u not seen her in the role) I always say right script is needed, and good wroter, etc...
also:
"Rani hadconnections, no struggle, a fact(yes she can act, so can Kajol(who too had patrent in industry) even raveena one of myoldfavs, kareena, kariushma etc, I not once said theybad in acting..I just said and its true they have connections and not had to endure hsrdshiops, if they not make it rt away they got money of parents,...this pt seems u ignore..and just want to point that rani us great...im stating facts
88