Are you satisfied with Raanjhanaa's Climax ?

Page

Next Last

Tanya

@tanya.91

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

Ranjhaanaa forsure wrote its name in hindi cinema's classics, and for all the right reasons.
I am not just sure about how everyone reacted to its climax... do u think the climax of Raanjhanaa's was:

*The most appropriate taking into consideration the whole movie ?

* Was Vague climax and needed more clarity ?

* Was an open-end that leads the viewer to get engage to think about the movie even after its being over, and everyone can culminate his/her own end...and in a way its good for a movie of such a great magnitude/impact to not limit its ending to the director's uni-layered' single climax ?

* Was way too tragic for you to digest, u were expecting a pleasant and happy climax ?

* The happy ending would have limit the impact of the movie and would have made this outclass movie just like any other routine love story ?

or anything other you like to share about its climax in the comments plz.

Quote

Frequent Posters

664269

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

happy ending, means, kundan-zoya ending up 2gether, and that really wudnt make sense, and wud also go agaisnt d plot..

climax, acc 2 me, was perfect, otherwise, d film wudnt be as successful, if the ending wudnt b a tragic one..

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Neeta

@U-No-Poo

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

I think the climax was perfect. It wasn't too melodramatic and yet it moved me to tears. Absolutely perfect.

Quote

MeeraXD

@MeeraXD

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

I think the ending was appropriate because the plot led up to it... so yeah agree with the others ^^

Quote

Caillou

@Caillou

Rocker

+ 5

Sarcastic Chatterbox

Posted: 12 years ago

i didn want kundan zoya to end up together. but still the climax was absurd. in fact everything after abhay's death was absurd. all the political happenings were pretty senseless and dumb.

Quote

ShamrozSays

@ShamrozSays

Voyager

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

well if kundan would have survived than zoya😡 would have used him to the core selfishly in future!!!😆

yup even i was a bit emotional to see this tragic ending!! par woh classic love story hi kya jisme koi unexpected ending na ho!!

If they would have ended being together then the film would have been just hit but if the ending is smthing like this i.e. totally unexpected and unpredictable then the movie goes superr duperr hittt!!!

well i have a doubt in a story!! can any1 plzz explain it 2 me!!

in the end the policeman says 2 zoya that he called kundan in the morning and he was already aware of all this.

my q) is what kundan was aware of??? that there is going to b a big dhamaka in the rally during the speech??? OR he knew that chief minister and zoya 2gether are plotting against him??

Edited by shahidamritafan - 12 years ago

Quote

664269

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: shahidamritafan
well if kundan would have survived than zoya😡 would have used him to the core selfishly in future!!!😆
yup even i was a bit emotional to see this tragic ending!! par woh classic love story hi kya jisme koi unexpected ending na ho!!
If they would have ended being together then the film would have been just hit but if the ending is smthing like this i.e. totally unexpected and unpredictable then the movie goes superr duperr hittt!!!

well i have a doubt in a story!! can any1 plzz explain it 2 me!!
in the end the policeman says 2 zoya that he called kundan in the morning and he was already aware of all this.
my q) is what kundan was aware of??? that there is going to b a big dhamaka in the rally during the speech??? OR he knew that chief minister and zoya 2gether are plotting against him??

he knew already that he was planned to be killed, and understood that zoya was pretending to be in love wid him ... i guess he had pretty thoughts on that zoya knew about the attack on him.. i felt he understood zoya's motives.