RAANJHANAA REVIEWS - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

163.4k

Users

133

Likes

2.8k

Frequent Posters

Swetha-Sai thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#41
^ Reviews are good.
Will watch this movie for sure this weekend.
ViccoTurmeric thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#42

Review: Dhanush's Bollywood take-off 'Raanjhanaa' is a terribly one-sided affair

Pitching an outdated love story that could've (probably) worked in the 90s, is a sure-shot hint at box-office disaster

By
  • Sneha May Francis
PublishedThursday, June 20, 2013

Just when you thought that Bollywood had (slowly, but steadily) matured in its take on love, director Aanad L Rai quashes our faith with a shockingly outdated love story.

Set on the rustic bylanes of Benaras, 'Raanjhanaa' is unimaginatively archaic and extremely convoluted that it gives love a bad name.

While most Bollywood romances (logically) involves a couple, who obsessively dance around trees and fight objecting parents (and society) only to reunite to live 'happily ever after', in 'Raanjhanaa' it's an unapologetically one-sided affair.

Here, the hero is left on his own to fight for love that only he feels.

And, strangely he's quite happy doing so.

The unrequited love isn't the problem here, but how he taunts, teases, tortures and even threatens his ladylove into submission. She apparently gives in only because he's "consistent" and not because she has any feelings for him.

And, to think that they are still in school while these events unfold is highly unsettling.

So, a few slaps and a slitting-his-wrist exercise later, they fall in love.

Yes, love (in Bollywood) does strange things to people.

However, their romance is short-lived as her parents discover their secret and she's promptly packed away to another city.

Eight years (and a Holi song) later, she returns to her hometown only to find her man still deeply in love, and equally eager to slit his wrist if she declines his proposal.

Thankfully she has matured and doesn't give in to his demands.

But, things go completely haywire then on.

Double marriage plans, an untimely death, revenge, and even a political campaign are weaved into the narrative.

Aanad and his 'Tanu Weds Manu' writer Himanshu Sharma go from bizarre to absolute absurdity.

At 140 minutes screen time, the roller-coaster ride is far from bearable. There's only one scene that's impressively original and genuinely funny – when a bunch of university students surround the hero and analyze what led him to become a "thief".

Tamil movie star Dhanush and his screen-lover Sonam Kapoor pale out in front of Swara Bhaskar and Mohammed Zeeshan Ayyub. Despite being written half-baked characters, the two create immense affability towards the loud-mouthed, hopeless romantic Bindiya and the ever-loyal Morari.

Not that Dhanush isn't earnest in his portrayal of the small-town romeo Kundan, but Himanshu gives him the most infuriating dull character to play. He's either attempting to take his life or threatening to take his lover's, without much thought. After hogging the chunk of screen-time, Kundan's character deserved a lot more thought and reasoning.

In fact, the only prep that has gone into determining Kundan's journey is his facial hair – from a clean-shaven schoolboy to a mustached much-in-love youngster, to a bearded repenting soul.

Sonam is easy on the eye, and plays herself. She's clearly worked on her costumes, and that's about how much she has given to Zoya. A little more soul would've gone a long way in understanding her.

Abhay Deol walked away with the most impressive few minutes on-screen. Not that he had any scope for performance, but his desi-style and dimples will come as a great relief from all the doom that Kundan is busy creating.

While music maestro AR Rahman tunes the track, and leaves us occasionally cheerful, the moments are far too few to erase the horrid aftereffects of this movie.

Take our tip. Skip this one.

tina59 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: edgarwright

http://www.emirates247.com/entertainment/films-music/review-dhanush-s-bollywood-take-off-raanjhanaa-is-a-terribly-one-sided-affair-2013-06-20-1.511289

Really like Dhanush myself - some of his Tamil flicks are top draer, but from what I hear, this is apparently the case. I feared this tbh.

Not every love story is set in foreign locations, dancing in weddings in palatial setting, and happily ever after.
The critic maybe wanted a typical Masala love story . The story is set in Banaras with two normal people, not ultra rich travelling around the world people. Obviously it has to be rustic and flawed. It cannot be a kjo types right and theres absolutely nothing wrong with it.
why are we so obsessed with typical and Happily cheesy love stories, why cant it be different and real
edgarwright thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: tina59

Not every love story is set in foreign locations, dancing in weddings in palatial setting, and happily ever after.
The critic maybe wanted a typical Masala love story . The story is set in Banaras with two normal people, not ultra rich travelling around the world people. Obviously it has to be rustic and flawed. It cannot be a kjo types right and theres absolutely nothing wrong with it.
why are we so obsessed with typical and Happily cheesy love stories, why cant it be different and real


I don't think the critic was complaining about lack of "happily ever after" masala. Is that what you gathered from her review? Actually, if anything, she takes a few potshots at the tree-romances there. And from what I gather there, it doesn't seem much different from cliched Bollywood romance stories either, in essence at least. Her criticism about lack of character development re: Dhanush's character seems valid to me.
tina59 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: edgarwright


I don't think the critic was complaining about lack of "happily ever after" masala. Is that what you gathered from her review? Actually, if anything, she takes a few potshots at the tree-romances there. And from what I gather there, it doesn't seem much different from cliched Bollywood romance stories either, in essence at least. Her criticism about lack of character development re: Dhanush's character seems valid to me.

yes dhanush's character not being developed enough is constructive. However the comments on how the romance all happens in school etc. Believe it or not, romance does happen in school and some go an extent especially in interior india infact it happens in cities as well.
basically the review doesn't say whats the problem with the movie. it looks like the critic was expecting something and was disappointed that it didn't happen.
bonnefille thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#46
SPOILER ALERT: TEXT IN WHITE

The unrequited love isn't the problem here, but how he taunts, teases, tortures and even threatens his ladylove into submission. She apparently gives in only because he's "consistent" and not because she has any feelings for him.

Eight years (and a Holi song) later, she returns to her hometown only to find her man still deeply in love, and equally eager to slit his wrist if she declines his proposal.

Thankfully she has matured and doesn't give in to his demands.

But, things go completely haywire then on.

Double marriage plans, an untimely death, revenge, and even a political campaign are weaved into the narrative.


^ I do not like the sound of the story, especially the part in bold. 🤢

Edited by bonnefille - 12 years ago
DheeJattanDi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#47
The first thing I'll be doing after my exams is watching this movie. I just hope she ends up with Abhay/Akram/Jassi.. and not Kundan. Otherwise it would be the usual crappy love story.
edgarwright thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: tina59

yes dhanush's character not being developed enough is constructive. However the comments on how the romance all happens in school etc. Believe it or not, romance does happen in school and some go an extent especially in interior india infact it happens in cities as well.
basically the review doesn't say whats the problem with the movie. it looks like the critic was expecting something and was disappointed that it didn't happen.


Good god, did you read her review? Her problem is not that it happens in school, but the whole setting of Hero bullying heroine by threatening her or cut himself, and the whole thing happens in the setting of school. I can't say I blame her, that's pretty disturbing. Unless you're not supposed tike Dhanush's character, which is not the case here as the story builds. And that's not exclusive to this movie either, I'm sick of movies portraying stalking as romantic in general, let alone this, BTW.
Edited by edgarwright - 12 years ago
bonnefille thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#49
I hope in the climax Kundan realizes that he wasted his time for Zoya when it should have been Swara Bhaskar's character whom he should have always loved. That would be one explosive ending! In the wake of Jiah's death, films should not promote obsessive love.

One sided love affairs are urgh! Love should not be wasted on someone who doesn't reciprocate.

And yup, the sound of Kundan's character is disturbing! I hope in the end he let's go of his obsessive love.
Edited by bonnefille - 12 years ago
tina59 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: edgarwright


Good god, did you read her review? Her problem is not that it happens in school, but the whole setting of Hero bullying heroine by threatening her or cut himself, and the whole thing happens in the setting of school. I can't say I blame her, that's pretty disturbing. Unless you're not supposed tike Dhanush's character, which is not the case here as the story builds. And that's not exclusive to this movie either, I'm sick of movies portraying stalking as romantic in general, let alone this, BTW.

its all right calm down, its only a movie review and I am stating my opinion on how I read the review that's all. From what I see , these things does happen and that's the truth. Not everything is hunky dory love story. Every love story is different and this type also does happen. Maybe most doesn't end up happily but exceptions do exist.
That should not be the criteria to judge a movie. How I see it, looks like the critic expected something and was disappointed and hence the review which is completely fine.
chill, cheers I am purely commenting on the crtic's review based on how I read it which can be different from ur perceptions

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: beena_jon · 1 months ago

The re-edited so-called “happy ending" version, has altered using artificial intelligence, was reportedly released without the creators'...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Rosyme · 2 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMQTansTzoV/?igsh=NDlxNTFjdDJpbHox

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMQTansTzoV/?igsh=NDlxNTFjdDJpbHox
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Elvis12 · 3 months ago

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgm1u2gPxzw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YzoTG7AbzQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgm1u2gPxzw
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 12 days ago

https://x.com/filmibeat/status/1968397140549345682

https://x.com/filmibeat/status/1968397140549345682
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 13 days ago

https://x.com/varindersingh24/status/1955662282345808161 https://x.com/aavishhkar/status/1967618349535518917

https://x.com/varindersingh24/status/1955662282345808161
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".