'Slumdog Millionaire' is mediocre, trashy

desihamesha thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
http://www.filmicafe.com/news_detail.php?news_id=9343

" 'Slumdog Millionaire' is nothing but a cheap trashy mediocre version of those commercial films about estranged brothers and childhood sweethearts that Salim-Javed used to write so brilliantly in the 1970s. And please quote me clearly on this. If the Golden Globe and Oscars committees have chosen to honour this trashy film it just shows their ignorance of world cinema," Priyadarshan told a news agency.

"Why has Danny Boyle not taken one shot of Marine Drive? Do his slumdwellers exist only within their slums? And look at the absurdities...A boy becomes a national hero on a game show. One cop takes him under arrest and interrogates him relentlessly. Where is everyone else? Is this kind of confinement possible in this day and age when television cameras enter your bedroom? If one of our filmmakers had made the same film we would have blasted him out of business."

"Let them give as many Oscars as they like. We don't need to be impressed," ends Priydarshan angrily.

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

2.3k

Users

17

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

ShadowKisses thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

Not really surprised he chose now to speak. After all, Billo Barber releases in a week or so.😛

"[SM] is cheap [and] trashy" or "[Plot is] absurd" - Coming from the man who made movies like "Malamaal Weekly", "Bhagam Bhag" and "Garam Masala", it is highly ironic.
"Ignorance of world cinema" And he'd know about that, wouldn't he? From Boeing Boeing which 'inspired' Garam Masala to Ramji Rao Speaking which 'inspired' Hera Pheri, Priyadarshan is definitely not ignorant of world cinema.😛 His "inspirations" have garnered him a special chart on Wikipedia which juxtaposes his movies with the original ones.
I'd give his opinion some credence if his criticism didn't originate on the basis that the movie had no shot of Marine Drive. For the nth time, SM is not a documentary and doesn't pretend to be one, either. It is a fictional tale that happens to take place in the slums of Mumbai. While Mumbai DOES have an aesthetic side - the one that is shown in every second Bollywood movie - it also has a side that isn't so pleasing to the eye; One that many would like to forget exists. SM encapsulates the poverty that DOES exist in India. A portrayal of reality is not an insult or "degradation".
P.S. You missed a chunk of the interview:
[quote]Priyadarshan, whose much-acclaimed film on the silk weavers of Kanjeevaram was shown alongside Boyle's film at the Toronto Film Festival last year, feels Indians are exercising prideful property rights over a film that denigrates Mumbai.

"I saw the film with a mixed audience at the Toronto Film Festival. The Westerners loved it. All the Indian hated it. The West loves to see us as a wasteland, filled with horror stories of exploitation and degradation. But is that all there's to our beautiful city of Mumbai?"

He is surprised that Mumbai is celebrating a film that shows only the city's underbelly.

"Why are we taking this treatment? Just because a white man has made 'Slumdog Millionaire', we're so happy with it? I've read Vikas Swarup's novel 'Q&A'. It should have been made by
Mani Ratnam. Then you'd have seen what he would have done with Mumbai."

The angry director wonders why there isn't a single shot in 'Slumdog...' that shows the more aesthetic side of Mumbai?
[/quote]
Edited by ShadowKisses - 16 years ago
Prenz~13 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Ok...now I'm really starting to get mad...who on Earth are all these people coming out and trashing Slumdog?!!!! I mean, for heaven's sake...this is the guy who made junk like Bhagam Bhaag...and all those other nonsensical comedies!!! Who is he to comment on world cinema?!!!
Gosh, why is Bollywood filled with such a bunch of sour grapes?!! Just because a British director made a movie set in India and it's gone to the Oscars, these guys are spewing illogical nonsense...I bet they'd give anything to be in Danny Boyle's place right now, but sadly, the Academy chooses to honour good movies rather than the stuff these guys create!! Mr. Priyadarshan, I suggest you either make movies worth talking about or keep your mouth shut on movies which are worth talking about...if he calls Slumdog trash...wonder what his movies are?!!!
apux thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Prenz~13

Ok...now I'm really starting to get mad...who on Earth are all these people coming out and trashing Slumdog?!!!!



People who want attention.
gossipgurls thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: apux



People who want attention.

gosh ppl can do anything for attention.......... ... he is forgetting that srk supports sm who is producing another trash movie of his
desihamesha thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
After Slumdog Millionaire, India will be portrayed as a slum - Preity Zinta

http://www.filmicafe.com/news_detail.php?news_id=9350

Bollywood's charming and adorable girl Preity Zinta celebrated her birthday yesterday. Since we are all aware that she has always been known to lend a helping hand to social matters this time around too she has a list of priorities through which she will step forward and make changes in the country and city. She will support a campaign called 'Light a Billion Lights' where one can sponsor electricity to a whole village in India. This electricity will be generated by using solar energy. This campaign is the India's first 24 hour Greenathon where one can sponsor electricity through solar energy.

She also feels that we as citizens of India should stop thinking about social matter and start implementing them in our own way rather than depending on others. One major problem she feels that as citizens of Mumbai we need to confront is the problem of illegal immigrants. She feels that the city is bursting to its seams and yet people keep pouring into the city. So to tackle this problem we need to get Citizen Identity cards. She feels that especially after Slumdog Millionaire Mumbai or rather India will be portrayed as a slum altogether.
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
I agreeeeeeeeee with this line -100%.. I mean hes right thew west wants to seeMumbai as some ugly city.. and since Danny Boyle made a movie like this ofcourse there gonna wanna appreciate the movie.. it'll just make them think that they were right alla long..
The Westerners loved it. All the Indian hated it. The West loves to see us as a wasteland, filled with horror stories of exploitation and degradation. But is that all there's to our beautiful city of Mumbai?"
293418 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
Maybe, I would take Priyadarshan's views more seriously if he didn't take brilliant Malayalam films and make bad copies of them in Hindi without acknowledging the people, who were the original creators of the story.
swan20 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
all those who are criticising SM & calling it a glorification of India's underbelly by a Westerner......have they forgotten that the original story is written by an Indian & the movie has been inspired from the same......so why blame Danny Boyle for putting the story into celluloid..............he merely came across a brilliant story & decided to make it into a movie with a few changes......where's the harm in that.....
Edited by swan20 - 16 years ago
chronic thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
Wow! Bollywood sounds jealous.....
Practically every second Bolly movie has focussed only on the more 'aesthetic' side of Mumbai....And focussing only on the good stuff is not going to magically eliminate the bad....Why pretend that it doesn't exist?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".