Mandana deserves to be threatened: Rochelle - Page 6

What I am not understanding is SUKISH did that to Mandana... And putting them aside hate threads are made on Rochelle and we all here are discussing Rochelle- Mandy when we(including me) should be discussing SUKISH Mandy... I mean ssly what's wrong with us...!!

As for your last post, Kwerky, people either hate on people they don't like or get disappointed with people they support. My criticism of Rochelle is because I'm disappointed with her. Without Keith she was actually a winner. In the rickshaw task she stood up for the right, even in the bitching task I thought Mandy was being mellow and Rochelle was just doing her task. In the two weeks' immunity task she did well in the car despite of being attacked by both Prince and Rishabd. Up until last week ALL my posts have been in favour of Rochelle.

But since Keith's arrival she's lost the basis of what made her a massive favourite. When something went wrong she would jump in and make her voice get heard, and her opinion has always been bang on. That's what I loved about Rochelle. And, again, I'm NOT expecting her to stick up to Mandy because at the end of the day she's there to win the game and she can do that fine without Mandy. What disappointed me was her entire stance on the scenario.

Originally posted by: Missy.90

As for your last post, Kwerky, people either hate on people they don't like or get disappointed with people they support. My criticism of Rochelle is because I'm disappointed with her. Without Keith she was actually a winner. In the rickshaw task she stood up for the right, even in the bitching task I thought Mandy was being mellow and Rochelle was just doing her task. In the two weeks' immunity task she did well in the car despite of being attacked by both Prince and Rishabd. Up until last week ALL my posts have been in favour of Rochelle.

But since Keith's arrival she's lost the basis of what made her a massive favourite. When something went wrong she would jump in and make her voice get heard, and her opinion has always been bang on. That's what I loved about Rochelle. And, again, I'm NOT expecting her to stick up to Mandy because at the end of the day she's there to win the game and she can do that fine without Mandy. What disappointed me was her entire stance on the scenario.

+1. This is exactly what I just wrote on another thread - forget Mandy, Roch's stance here was highly dissapointing regardless of Mandy being in the picture. Today, Roch (who I found likable because she spoke against what she feels is wrong irrespective of her relations with the people involved) condoned Suyaash's behavior, and sided with him saying he is not wrong.

I can see this happening for one of two reasons: one, Roch took this route as she is no longer friends with Mandana, and to suit her current alliances in the house, and this is dissapointing. Two, she truly believes there is nothing wrong with Suyaash's threats as long as he doesn't act on them, and this, if it is the case, is disgusting. And the second stance would also mean that her being vocal against the aggressiveness in the Rickshaw task was only a strategic move, because she was involved and it benefitted her to side with Mandana then, rather than a sense of right or wrong.

I'll say this again: it is not about supporting Mandana, or about Mandana being undeserving - No one deserves the treatment she got yesterday! It is about NOT condoning, and not siding with something so out of line. Regardless of how unlikeable some may find Mandana, she was openly bashed and threatened yesterday, and the housemates condoned it, then sat together and joked and gossiped about her; she has a right to be upset about that.

SP2684, Rochie is dancing to Keith's tune right now. I was truly disgusted with how Keith said he can guarantee Mandy only cried for the camera and at the right angle. Apna rona dona bhul gaya kya on the dyslexic comment? Rochie was doing haan mein haan milana which is nothing like she used to be! I really hope the spoilers are wrong and Keith gets eliminated as he's not good enough to win anyway but is spoiling it for Rochelle too! 😡

ASR-lover and Kwerky good job defending Rochelle. I like Rochelle and believe she will do better. She is not perfect and she has her share of mistakes. I read your defense and agree your points, nicely put across and convincing. she is not completely at fault, but it is coming across because she is friends with KSP. Kishwar, Suyash and Prince have been bullying Mandana and looking worst this week. Keith and Rochelle are taking all the bashing because they were friends with KSP. I agree KSP should be bash 10 times more, but it is happening the other way. I had said earlier in this forum bad act is expected by villains KSP but not from hero. Hero always gets bashed for a small mistake, Rochelle has build good image and is expected like super hero to fight bad guys (KSP) and stand in support for victim like (Mandana) or even if it was someone else. The expectation has disappointed many, including me.
I am sure by next week equation will change between Rochelle and Mandana, they will be friends again. What i have seen in past, Rochelle cannot hate someone for long term, it is not in her nature.

Everything that happens is blamed on Rochelle? Why should she support a friend who ditched her, bitched about her, claims she lectures her when Rochelle explains anything to her, acts victimised almost all the times?

Originally posted by: spicysagar

<font size="3">ASR-lover and Kwerky good job defending Rochelle. I like Rochelle and believe she will do better. She is not perfect and she has her share of mistakes. I read your defense and agree your points, nicely put across and convincing. she is not completely at fault, but it is coming across because she is friends with KSP. Kishwar, Suyash and Prince have been bullying Mandana and looking worst this week. Keith and Rochelle are taking all the bashing because they were friends with KSP. I agree KSP should be bash 10 times more, but it is happening the other way. I had said earlier in this forum bad act is expected by villains KSP but not from hero. Hero always gets bashed for a small mistake, Rochelle has build good image and is expected like super hero to fight bad guys (KSP) and stand in support for victim like (Mandana) or even if it was someone else. The expectation has disappointed many, including me.
I am sure by next week equation will change between Rochelle and Mandana, they will be friends again. What i have seen in past, Rochelle cannot hate someone for long term, it is not in her nature.

</font>

Thanks...!! Spicysagar...
Your Hero wala instance was a bang on comment... I totally agree with it... Well said...

Originally posted by: Missy.90

SP2684, Rochie is dancing to Keith's tune right now. I was truly disgusted with how Keith said he can guarantee Mandy only cried for the camera and at the right angle. Apna rona dona bhul gaya kya on the dyslexic comment? Rochie was doing haan mein haan milana which is nothing like she used to be! I really hope the spoilers are wrong and Keith gets eliminated as he's not good enough to win anyway but is spoiling it for Rochelle too! 😡

That was a ridiculous comment from Keith, particularly because any other woman in that house (including Kishwer) would be entitled to a cry after the crap that was pulled; and it all went down in front of these guys - but they still think Mandana deserves it? What?!

There seems to be an upset about Roch's stance being questioned over the other HMs. But the other HMs had not displayed a likable trait of being able to see and call out a wrong - some of them stay out of it, and most side with their friends. As a neutral viewer, who found Roch likeable on many occasions, her stance yesterday was wrong and gives rise to the thought that perhaps Roch's previous stands were equally calculative as opposed to stemming from a sense of right and wrong. Disappointing.

Huh! Who's the scorpion now?