Originally posted by: Kwerky
SoPunk...I think you need to revisit the options because sorry, but you are mistaken here. When you press the buzzer (irrespective of what the other two did)...you take this option OUT of the picture/out of running/out of consideration... which stated: if no one presses the buzzer, then another HM (barring these three) will become the sevak.
She obviously had no idea what the others would do. But when she pressed the button, she ENSURED that no other HM would be in the running for the sevak...because it FAILED this condition: no one pressing the buzzer.
She was right. Which is why she got the support from everyone in the house except Mandana.
And yes, pressing it also ensures that you don't bear the punishment.
1. If you press you are 100% safe in all four options (3 options available)
2. If you don't press you have only 33 % chance of being safe through 4th option (3 options available)
Come to saving the HMs:
1. If you press you have 33% chance of making the HMs work (3rd Option) & 67% chance of other two/one person in DT Room working.
2. If you Don't press you have 33% chance of making the HMs work (4th Option) & 67% chance of you working.
**03 options are available for pressing & not pressing.
So she tried to save the HMs from working is a myth. In each case the HMs possibility of working is equal. What varies is CHANCE OF BEING SAFE.
Alex, please give these options some time, I'm sure you will not be fooled by rochele's stupid logic. That's mathematically wrong. 😆
Edited by SoPunk - 9 years ago