Safest option = Press the Buzzer! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

2.5k

Users

25

Likes

187

Frequent Posters

Kwerky thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
Very well explained.👍🏼
WreckLass thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#12
Well put!

It was 3 people in the DT room. Now that makes it hard to predict what the other two would do(unlike the case of Aman n Kish)
All the 3 not pressing the buzzer is highly unlikely.

So obv the safest option would be to press the buzzer n avoid being a sevak.
Roch chose the safe option by pressing the buzzer.
Now those saying that she was selfish...yes she was. She should be selfish and why not?
Everyone is selfish.. Not just her.
Mandy n Yuvika were dumb not to press the buzzer...doesn't make them saints. They were just dumb lol.
Although I wish Roch didn't have to do all the justification later.

And BTW this is a game...being selfish is the key. If one isn't selfish then he or she isn't fit to participate...one cannot win.
If one wants to be all nice n keep all the usools intact n be a saint, they can participate in one of those bhakti channels or sth😆
Edited by WreckLass - 10 years ago
nehlove thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: WreckLass

Well put!

It was 3 people in the DT room. Now that makes it hard to predict what the other two would do(unlike the case of Aman n Kish)
All the 3 not pressing the buzzer is highly unlikely.

So obv the safest option would be to press the buzzer n avoid being a sevak.
Roch chose the safe option by pressing the buzzer.
Now those saying that she was selfish...yes she was. She should be selfish and why not?
Everyone is selfish.. Not just her.
Mandy n Yuvika were dumb not to press the buzzer...doesn't make them saints. They were just dumb lol.
Although I wish Roch didn't have to do all the justification later.

And BTW this is a game...being selfish is the key. If one isn't selfish then he or she isn't fit to participate...one cannot win.
If one wants to be all nice n keep all the usools intact n be a saint, they can participate in one of those bhakti channels or sth😆



She had to give some justification to keep people on her side since she has to still stay in that house for a while. That's why she even mouthed sorry to M&Y. And even her explanation was sound IMO. But yeah, crying for that fake mandy after was a bit much.

Even the HMs didn't stand by her and explain it to that idiot Mandy. Esp when half of them were shit scared that they're going to have to bear the load if none of them pressed the buzzer. What a bunch of ungrateful idiots!
CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#14
There is nothing wrong if she pressed the buzzer and Mandana was just overreacting, all of them understood the task but confused what to do?
I think there is no confusion regarding task in forum too. This process has been repeated nth times.I don't know how Rochelle is selfish? She did whatever she wanted.

Problem is her contradicting statements. First she said she knew other two won't press buzzer and wanted them to do all work (how did she know what's going on in mind of other two? ) whatever it is fine be firm on ur statement and later when Mandy confronted her she started crying ( one should cry only if there is regret or feels decision was wrong) and changed her statement that she pressed to save other HMs.

Either say I am not answerable to anyone or give one justification and stick on it. Except Mandana no one had any problem. It was really easy to give back her but she preferred to cry and whine. Tell her that you didn't want me to press buzzer so that others should pay for our mistakes.
Edited by White-Rose - 10 years ago
nehlove thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: White-Rose

There is nothing wrong if she pressed the buzzer and Mandana was just overreacting, all of them understood the task but confused what to do?

I think there is no confusion regarding task in forum too. This process has been repeated nth times.I don't know how Rochelle is selfish? She did whatever she wanted.

Problem is her contradicting statements. First she said she knew other two won't press buzzer and wanted them to do all work (how did she know what's going on in mind of other two? ) whatever it is fine be firm on ur statement and later when Mandy confronted her she started crying ( one should cry only if there is regret or feels decision was wrong) and changed her statement that she pressed to save other HMs.

Either say I am not answerable to anyone or give one justification and stick on it. Except Mandana no one had any problem. It was really easy to give back her but she preferred to cry and whine. Tell her that you didn't want me to press buzzer so that others should pay for our mistakes.



I don't see how those two statements are contradicting. She said she knew they won't press so she wanted them to do all the work and in this way she also saved the HMs. Her action brought both the results so the statements are not contradicting. Shecan have more than one reason for making the decision, right?

But yeah, she shouldn't have cried.
ananya2010 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#16
Agree with you. Mandana is very selfish.
uscgirl thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#17
When a person like Mandy who keeps fighting on the same topic over and over & says that I dont want to hear your explanation you got to understand that she knows Rochelle did something greater than her and she cant stand it and she doesnt want audience to notice that Rochelle did something better for the HMs. She is evil like that.

The moment Rochelle told the HMs the very first time when Mandy attacked her (thinking all great in her mind and constantly passing condescending statements on Rochelle) she was taken aback when R said I did it for the betterment for the HMs. If we are responsible for breaking the most rules then the punishment should stay within us too! Thats very righteous thought. Even though I dont like Rochelle that much but appreciate her gesture.👏
Edited by uscgirl - 10 years ago
CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: nehlove



I don't see how those two statements are contradicting. She said she knew they won't press so she wanted them to do all the work and in this way she also saved the HMs. Her action brought both the results so the statements are not contradicting. Shecan have more than one reason for making the decision, right?

But yeah, she shouldn't have cried.


There is huge difference.

One statement means she wanted Mandy and Yuvika to suffer which mean personal grudge AND second statement means it was last option and didn't want others to suffer coz of them and there was nothing against yuvika or Mandana from her side.

Main question she claimed that she knew what Mandana and Yuvika would do. How? That was a big fat lie. She could have said that I had no idea what both of you would do and I thought pressing buzzer would be right choice. Period. Put your answer such way that no one could point finger at you.
lovely_lady thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#19
I agree with everything you've said! Perfectly articulated what I was thinking! Rochelle was the least selfish, Mandana was the selfish one.

But I think even HMs knew this. ALL of the HMs (barring maybe Mandy, Yuvi Vikas and Suyyash) thought Rochelle decision was right. Kishwar, Prince, Diggy, Aman, Keith, and even Arvind said Rochelle was right. No one was convinced by Mandy's explanation and no one even really believe it.
Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: White-Rose

There is nothing wrong if she pressed the buzzer and Mandana was just overreacting, all of them understood the task but confused what to do?

I think there is no confusion regarding task in forum too. This process has been repeated nth times.I don't know how Rochelle is selfish? She did whatever she wanted.

Problem is her contradicting statements. First she said she knew other two won't press buzzer and wanted them to do all work (how did she know what's going on in mind of other two? ) whatever it is fine be firm on ur statement and later when Mandy confronted her she started crying ( one should cry only if there is regret or feels decision was wrong) and changed her statement that she pressed to save other HMs.

Either say I am not answerable to anyone or give one justification and stick on it. Except Mandana no one had any problem. It was really easy to give back her but she preferred to cry and whine. Tell her that you didn't want me to press buzzer so that others should pay for our mistakes.


Hi nice to see you here after last season

Bold-i dont think she changed her statement .By saving she meant she didn't want non rule breaker's to work which is what she was saying from the start

Crying part i agree with.She did the right and smart thing so there was nothing to cry in that

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".