I see. Sana’s provocation then and Asim’s provocation now are of the same nature, magnitude and intensity, eh? Neat.Originally posted by: Kinginthenorth9
When Sana in that snakes and ladders task had instigated, provoked and shoved Dey which led to Dey abusing (wrong of him) her toh then everyone sided with Sana and said that instigation is part and parcel of the game and Dey shouldn't have reacted so badly.
When Sid instigated Mahira while cutting veggies it was fine.
When Shilpa used to non stop provoke Vikas in BB 11 then Salman and the public used to enjoy the provocations and would ask Vikas to take these insitigations in stride and that Shilpa's provocation was fun.
But now that Asim has done the same thing albiet at a much lesser level toh all of a sudden everyone has a problem with it. Suddenly Asim is the worst person to exist for instigating some one even though it is part and parcel of the game.
This is not a Sooraj Barjatiya film like Hum Saath Saath Hain, it's a realty show where all sorts of mind games are the norm.
But what is not the norm or excusable is Sid's over the top violence. For that Sid needs to be evicted or nominated for the entire season.
Don’t quote other seasons and don’t quote others’ responses to them. Shilpa was never right in her provocation. I never said she was. Plus no season is like another and BB producers are one of the most manipulative ones ever. So, let’s not even go there.
What makes a difference here in case you are really interested in my reasoning is that Asim stuck by Sid until he understood the game. He knew what Sid was- Sid really hasn’t changed from Day 1. He has been this rogue bullish Alpha figure right from the beginning. He never blamed Sid for his aggression or his attitude when he was within the group. He knew even if nobody was there Sid would be with him. And his popularity was nowhere.
But now with WC entry, everything has changed and he, knowing quite well Sid’s nature from inside, is provoking him and jabbing him in and out. And they were supposed to be brothers while Sana Dey and Shilpa Vikas has no such camaraderie between them. Within context, Asim’s reaction is definite ethical breach. Sid’s is too. But jab apna karta hai, he will be judged accordingly- it’s a backstab whether you want to accept it or not. Maybe Sid deserves it too for the aggression he has shown on the show, but that doesn’t make what Asim’s been doing right.
And yes, it’s a game. So let Asim instigate and hear whatever he deserves to or doesn’t deserve to hear from the public and let Sid react however and hear whatever he has to as well. And let them all be nominated for life. Fair grounds 😏
There are posters here who have identified the guns comment from Asim as genuine, but I didn’t have the patience to dissect their shit, so I shall give him benefit of doubt, but I did hear the comment from Asim that if Sid had done this outside, he wouldn’t have his hands any more. I don’t wish to say a word more after that.