myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Can someone pls answer in history
1) Did Udai Singh marry a veer bai at this late age?
Fom history what i read Udai Singh liked some sister of Mahmood Shah(i guess it was Mahmood shah forgot the bname of ruler) and they both fought over that. But did Maldeo fight with Udai Singh for Veer bai?
2) Ajmer war - Akbar won in 1559 when he was 17 years old. But here Akbar is 14 and Pratap 16 so how come war at such young age to win Ajmer
3) Did Marwar and Mewar get together to fight Akbar for Ajmer fort??
4) Marwar was won by Akbar in 1561, 2 years after Ajmer fort. So will phool marry Pratap after or before this war?
5) Chittor war was fought in 1567-68 where Akbar killed 30,000 civilans. But i want to know did any queen of udai singh commint jauhar? Where was shakti singh in Mughal army or with his family? What about sagar singh? Why did Pratap not fight the war?
6) Did marwar and mewarr really enemies? If so why? Then how phool married partap
7) What is samanth a vassal king or minister?
Edited by myviewprem - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

7.4k

Users

10

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

Shivam... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Can someone pls answer in history

1) Did Udai Singh marry a veer bai at this late age?
Fom history what i read Udai Singh liked some sister of Mahmood Shah(i guess it was Mahmood shah forgot the bname of ruler) and they both fought over that. But did Maldeo fight with Udai Singh for Veer bai?
2) Ajmer war - Akbar won in 1559 when he was 17 years old. But here Akbar is 14 and Pratap 16 so how come war at such young age to win Ajmer
3) Did Marwar and Mewar get together to fight Akbar for Ajmer fort??
4) Marwar was won by Akbar in 1561, 2 years after Ajmer fort. So will phool marry Pratap after or before this war?
5) Chittor war was fought in 1567-68 where Akbar killed 30,000 civilans. But i want to know did any queen of udai singh commint jauhar? Where was shakti singh in Mughal army or with his family? What about sagar singh? Why did Pratap not fight the war?
6) Did marwar and mewarr really enemies? If so why? Then how phool married partap
7) What is samanth a vassal king or minister?


i would like to answer all your doubts one by one:

1. yes, udai singh did marry her and war was fought between mewar and marwar. Mewar won in that. However, the circumstances shown are wrong. Veer Bai's father himself approached Udai Singh for her hand and not because they were found in tent together. 6000 soldiers from marwar and 8000 soldiers from mewar took place in war.

2.About the dates, you are right. Timeline is wrong in the show.

3. mewar and marwar never came together to fight akbar. In fact , they fought many wars between them. Sometimes marwar won and sometimes mewar. Haji khan was main provocative man behind these wars. For his selfishness, he instigated both kings against each other.

4. Yes, Marwar was won by Akbar in 1561, Rao Maldeo died in 1562 , then tensions between the kingdoms cooled down somewhat , and pratap was married to phool in 1563, almost 5 years after his marriage to ajabde.

5. In 1568, Chittor was left ungaurded at the hands of just 9000 soldiers under Jagmal. This was mainly due to Udai Singh's cowardness and bad planning. The royal family escaped thrugh a tunnel . Udai singh later died in 1572, so no question of Jauhar. In fact, Jaivanta Bai died 10 days after death of pratap

6. Samanth are rulers controlling and operating small portion of the kingdoms of powerful kings. Practically, no more than minister.
Edited by shivam030291 - 11 years ago
CallmeCel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
I can tell one thing that don't trust everything showed in the show.
CVs to make the show interesting make silly stories to entertain us and increase the TRPs.
Joyness thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Cvs history ka kabara kar rahe don't trust the story line of the show it is completely distorted to suit trps..shivam has rightly answered your queries. .read history books they will clarify many of your doubts
harshil_radhi28 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: shivam030291


i would like to answer all your doubts one by one:

1. yes, udai singh did marry her and war was fought between mewar and marwar. Mewar won in that. However, the circumstances shown are wrong. Veer Bai's father himself approached Udai Singh for her hand and not because they were found in tent together. 6000 soldiers from marwar and 8000 soldiers from mewar took place in war.

2.About the dates, you are right. Timeline is wrong in the show.

3. mewar and marwar never came together to fight akbar. In fact , they fought many wars between them. Sometimes marwar won and sometimes mewar. Haji khan was main provocative man behind these wars. For his selfishness, he instigated both kings against each other.

4. Yes, Marwar was won by Akbar in 1561, Rao Maldeo died in 1562 , then tensions between the kingdoms cooled down somewhat , and pratap was married to phool in 1563, almost 5 years after his marriage to ajabde.

5. In 1568, Chittor was left ungaurded at the hands of just 9000 soldiers under Jagmal. This was mainly due to Udai Singh's cowardness and bad planning. The royal family escaped thrugh a tunnel . Udai singh later died in 1572, so no question of Jauhar. In fact, Jaivanta Bai died 10 days after death of pratap

6. Samanth are rulers controlling and operating small portion of the kingdoms of powerful kings. Practically, no more than minister.

wow Shivam
this is a great info
do mind me asking where did u get the info from
thanks for the information
LOVE❤️
RADHI😊
bitblue thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
As per my knowledge akbar had to fight a lot to get ajmer under his wings on and off.

CVS are adding all available historical fact with perfact TRP tadaka.

After praja wedding they will make jalal marry rukaiya for sure.

Jalal was 2 years younger than pratap but we have older jalal as he has to match up to our pratap streanth sub chalta hai
_Poulomi_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: bitblue

As per my knowledge akbar had to fight a lot to get ajmer under his wings on and off.

CVS are adding all available historical fact with perfact TRP tadaka.

After praja wedding they will make jalal marry rukaiya for sure.

Jalal was 2 years younger than pratap but we have older jalal as he has to match up to our pratap streanth sub chalta hai

By now Rukaiya and Jalal are married, but she is not shown here. 😕 They got married in 1551... Jalal was just 9 years old. 😆 The timeline shown here is 1556-57. So, 5-6 years of married life.
bitblue thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: poulomi12

By now Rukaiya and Jalal are married, but she is not shown here. 😕 They got married in 1551... Jalal was just 9 years old. 😆 The timeline shown here is 1556-57. So, 5-6 years of married life.


true but in MP they will show him getting married as pratap will get married to ajab.😆
Moumimon thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: poulomi12

By now Rukaiya and Jalal are married, but she is not shown here. 😕 They got married in 1551... Jalal was just 9 years old. 😆 The timeline shown here is 1556-57. So, 5-6 years of married life.

i was so badly wanted ruku's track for jallu baby..but again creatives broke my heart😆😆.. they are only interested in phool and marwari ego😆😆
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
[QUOTE=shivam030291

i would like to answer all your doubts one by one:

1. yes, udai singh did marry her and war was fought between mewar and marwar. Mewar won in that. However, the circumstances shown are wrong. Veer Bai's father himself approached Udai Singh for her hand and not because they were found in tent together. 6000 soldiers from marwar and 8000 soldiers from mewar took place in war.

2.About the dates, you are right. Timeline is wrong in the show.

3. mewar and marwar never came together to fight akbar. In fact , they fought many wars between them. Sometimes marwar won and sometimes mewar. Haji khan was main provocative man behind these wars. For his selfishness, he instigated both kings against each other.

4. Yes, Marwar was won by Akbar in 1561, Rao Maldeo died in 1562 , then tensions between the kingdoms cooled down somewhat , and pratap was married to phool in 1563, almost 5 years after his marriage to ajabde.

5. In 1568, Chittor was left ungaurded at the hands of just 9000 soldiers under Jagmal. This was mainly due to Udai Singh's cowardness and bad planning. The royal family escaped thrugh a tunnel . Udai singh later died in 1572, so no question of Jauhar. In fact, Jaivanta Bai died 10 days after death of pratap

6. Samanth are rulers controlling and operating small portion of the kingdoms of powerful kings. Practically, no more than minister.
Thanks a lot
One more question who is haji khan? King or subedhar of another king.
Why he will make mewar and marwar fight? What is the enemity or reason because of veer bai?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".