First time in history! Thanks MP! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

4.9k

Users

11

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

Amor. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#21
@skep

its really ridiculous, m loosing interest hope it gets over now, nairam khan i guess when jalal becum king was always with him to protect him as far as i noe but here he was sitting in bundi just to capture sakha veer
i mean c'mmon cvz Indian audience is not that fool i noe we all luv our hero maharana pratap but atleast dnt show him like this
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
@Amor

Indeed! Bairam Khan had no work except sit in Bundi to wait for Sakha Veer?

And yesterday it was ridiculous how they showed BK failing to make out Pratap's tactics (like playing dead). And BK overpowered Pratap only when his sword fell, and the latter didn't attack since principled Rajputs don't attack unarmed persons while unprincipled Mughals have no hesitation in attacking unarmed adversary!

BK was merely watching Pratap slay soldiers and when he fought with him, he fought uselessly.

It's really wrong to show Rao Surtan so clownish, his and Mughals' soldiers so stupid and even Bairam Khan lacking in abilities compared to Pratap.

So a hardcore warrior like BK forgot tactics while Pratap, remembered his 30 minute training to ably fight BK!

This is an issue I have with all historicals. They make everyone foolish or incapable just to glorify the lead. I daresay even mythos these days have begun to undermine all others gods to glorify the one god on whom the serial is based. Don't tell me Mughals were useless and only Pratap was great or Parvati knows nothing unless she's channelised or guided by Mahadev or Akbar didn't know basics of connecting with masses till Jodha guided him!

All shows suffer such malaise. But sadly MP's taking it too far. And yesterday, the way Pratap chased Sheikhs with his sword it looked more like he was holding a danda and driving stray animals away than wielding a sword. It's hard to believe this is the same serial that showed proper battle and action scenes earlier but is resorting to gimmickry now.
Sheikhs were mice who ran away?
bitblue thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Skepblun

@Amor

Indeed! Bairam Khan had no work except sit in Bundi to wait for Sakha Veer?

And yesterday it was ridiculous how they showed BK failing to make out Pratap's tactics (like playing dead). And BK overpowered Pratap only when his sword fell, and the latter didn't attack since principled Rajputs don't attack unarmed persons while unprincipled Mughals have no hesitation in attacking unarmed adversary!

BK was merely watching Pratap slay soldiers and when he fought with him, he fought uselessly.

It's really wrong to show Rao Surtan so clownish, his and Mughals' soldiers so stupid and even Bairam Khan lacking in abilities compared to Pratap.

So a hardcore warrior like BK forgot tactics while Pratap, remembered his 30 minute training to ably fight BK!

This is an issue I have with all historicals. They make everyone foolish or incapable just to glorify the lead. I daresay even mythos these days have begun to undermine all others gods to glorify the one god on whom the serial is based. Don't tell me Mughals were useless and only Pratap was great or Parvati knows nothing unless she's channelised or guided by Mahadev or Akbar didn't know basics of connecting with masses till Jodha guided him!

All shows suffer such malaise. But sadly MP's taking it too far. And yesterday, the way Pratap chased Sheikhs with his sword it looked more like he was holding a danda and driving stray animals away than wielding a sword. It's hard to believe this is the same serial that showed proper battle and action scenes earlier but is resorting to gimmickry now.
Sheikhs were mice who ran away?


agree with you regarding training part of pratap in that CV did mistake. during yesterdays episode they did show him not strong enough for physical fight with BK. MP was undefeated from mugals all his life and in huldighat fight it was 3000-4000 of his solder against almost 20,000 of mugals with fully equipped arms still akar was not able to win. so showing him powerful is not wrong.
Edited by bitblue - 11 years ago
somump thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Skepblun

Just when one thought it couldn't get more outlandish, now we have this show showing us that was never heard of - shortest and most accelerated crash course ever! 30 minute crash course in yudh kala! 👏

So Pratap couldn't fight himself. Guru couldn't lend same men to Pratap to help fight there. Pratap couldn't make a yuva sena with his friends like Manu's naari sena.

Pratap got quick training from Raghvendra in jungle on his way to Bundi!

Mazaak! 😛

He faltered every time, Raghvendra gave him instructions and then he suddenly got the warfare tricks in a flash!

Enemies are engineering even their breath according to Pratap. đŸ„± Jab aayega toh hum kuch karenge.

Viewers are so stupid?

Or was MP a genius who got training in 30 minutes flat?

Pandavas and Kauravas entire youth was spent in training. MP learnt everthing earlier in one month. Now in 30 minutes he is perfect to defeat BK as his Guru springs up from nowhere.

Either this show is telling us about unknown nuggets from MP's life (that he learnt to fight fierce enemies in 30 minutes) or it needs to be renamed to Bharat Ki Veer Comedy - Kunwar Pratap. 😆

Oh by the way! There's no one else in entire Rajasthan to solve any issue. Only Pratap is karta-dharta. Krishna and Dudha who used to fight earlier in Bundi have also disappeared or become mute spectators.

People don't even have 30 minute crash courses for studies. Pratap had one for warfare. Thanks for telling this fact. 😆

642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#25
@bitblue

MP was undefeated? He was un-captured. Not undefeated. And this all didn't happen in his teenage at least.

I haven't come across any historical record that claims Akbar-MP rivalry started in their teenage only.

Also fight should be equal. Showing BK foolish or careless was wrong.

This 30 minute training and then Bairam Khan either not fighting or fighting carelessly was wrong and foolish. It's an outlandish attempt to make teenaged Pratap seem all powerful or divinely commissioned warrior.

MP FLED from Battle of Haldighati that too due to Shakti's help.

And when he was young, they lost Chittor to Mughals.

If MP alone was superhero then how did US lose Chittor? Why did he have to go and establish Udaipur?

Grown up MP can be superheroic. Even teenager can be. But don't make cartoons of opponents who were solid warriors themselves.
Amor. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
@skep
i agree on thatas this is the problem of each n every hist n mytho shows

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".