is pratap killed shakti? - Page 2

Uff !!! In one scene of Jodha-Akbar, i understand ekta is going far beyond the original history...now i understood not only Akbar's history rather she ruins Pratap's history also...

Agree with all your comments on Ekta. She creates history🤣

Oh puhleez!😲

It's better to talk less abt Ekta Kapoor's Jodha - Akbar. She can show anything.
Akbar was barbaric and Jodha is d Devi and all such kind off stuff.
No wonder she showed MP questioning Whatever Raja abt Marriage and all... 🤪

I guess there's a voiceover which says it not related to history ( despite of using and destroying all historical facts) so viewers of that show not needed to use brains.

And this is Mp forum , so talk abt MP, u can talk MPs Akbar.
If u start discussing other shows in our forum then I fear these discussions will lead to fights which i really dont want.

It's a request discuss Ekta's JA in dat forum.

Here v all can discuss our Maharana & his Akbar 😊

Ha. Ha. Cool but tasteless joke 😕

Agreed with khyati, pls discuss MP and its history. We don't want discussions about any xyz fictional show so that others who don't even watch MP come up here to debate and instigate. Lets keep it to our show only. And about dat show, der is a forum for that also.. You can discuss ur queries there

Originally posted by: cherryberry293

It's better to talk less abt Ekta Kapoor's Jodha - Akbar. She can show anything.
Akbar was barbaric and Jodha is d Devi and all such kind off stuff.
No wonder she showed MP questioning Whatever Raja abt Marriage and all... 🤪

I guess there's a voiceover which says it not related to history ( despite of using and destroying all historical facts) so viewers of that show not needed to use brains.

And this is Mp forum , so talk abt MP, u can talk MPs Akbar.
If u start discussing other shows in our forum then I fear these discussions will lead to fights which i really dont want.

It's a request discuss Ekta's JA in dat forum.

Here v all can discuss our Maharana & his Akbar 😊

Originally posted by: Skepblun

Oh puhleez!😲

Believe anything but an Ekta Kapoor show! She had mangled Mahabharat also. Do not expect authentic history from her.😆

Lastly, portrayal is moulded by who the creator has chosen to base his story on. There the show is about Akbar and "Jodha" so Ekta can make Maharana Pratap a villain. In fact she made a villain of Akbar also and tries to show as if he was heartless till Jodha came into his life!🤪

I have not found any record of Pratap trying to kill Shakti or getting him killed (yet, from whatever online search I did).

But I would add that history has its share of versions and twists. And if it is someone like Pratap who never surrendered so it is possible that it might have been messed up with. Many historical records have also been lost over the years. You can never have authentic or true version.

Even in current times, politicians play havoc with history and decide what will be published and what not. So an element of doubt always persists. To me, history is a case of jitne mooh utni baatein. Both ordinary people and those with vested interests twist history or have their own versions of it.

@tm: don't take us wrong, we love to share about history but things take bad turn when the show you mentioned is discussed here. Others come up creating issues. So we just suggested that to keep peace here, because our love is only for mp. Ur any query related to mp will definately be solved here, we just want to keep xyz show discussion out from here

Originally posted by: lika63

its nothing like talking abt other show and all dear.

jst posted to know wat is fact.

dey showed disclaimer only to stop fights so i dont believe its true.

so to know abt pratap i asked this.

:)

@TM, don't take me wrong. Yes of course u can ask questions to clear ur doubts but sometimes when v discuss other shows it takes bad turn.
And u know wat buddy... Watch both d shows, if u have any doubt in dat show then most of ur queries/ questions will b answered in MPs episodes 😊

And u can ask ur doubts. Most us here always prefer healthy discussion