Does maya really needs guidance? - Page 3

Originally posted by: janecastle

I have a BIG doubt, so someone please clear it. Why is some people calling Maya a MURDERER? The last time I checked the two murders that happened were never solved. So how did you people conclude that Maya is a murderer? Then again this is the sad reality of our society. Some people think that being mentally ill and murderer are synonymous. One more thing if Maya was a murderer then Ashwin would have been dead long back. The same goes to VM and your favorite Saanjh Mata. If Maya wanted to commit murder she would have killed off VM and Saanjh in the first chance she got.

So do grow up people. Not every mentally ill patient is a murderer and they SHOULD NOT be isolated like some people are suggesting.

And coming to your question, 'Yes, Maya do need guidance and medical care'. Those two things can bring her back to a normal life.

Originally posted by: tanvismile

I think u dint watch the episode when maya attempted to kill vandana and saanjh and suddenly arjun arrived. So vandana and saanjh were lucky. You also dint see that episode ashwin telling jhanvi if the maya doings goes to police then maya will be jailed for 25 years.

Originally posted by: janecastle

Buddy, trying to kill and killing are two different things. Maya was going to hit VM with the car but Arjun's voice brought her back to reality. That's what I said, Maya is mentally ill and needs treatment and proper care. You and some people here do find it amusing to mock mentally ill people and that's is wrong. Also about what Ashwin said, Ashwin was an abuser and anything he ever said and did was to hurt Maya. So him telling that Maya going to jail does not prove that she killed someone.

Originally posted by: tanvismile

Attempt to kill also is crime I hope u know that. Just like attempt to rape is a crime. One should wait for them to conduct the crime and then declare them as criminals. Ashwin had proofs and if ashwin was lier maya and Jhanvi would have sent him to jail but they knew if he is sent to jail their truth will also come out.

Originally posted by: sindu_gurti

Tanvi Maya needs love,to get true love Maya needs to be open about her.,she needs medical treatment,someone who is more powerful than Maya,not someone like arjun.,he didn't get Maya st all...I think if he and Maya attends a marriage counseling they could atleast make out something is wrong with Maya...Maya can't be handled this way for a long time,she will become more and more sick...First I want Maya to find a good friend with whom she can confide her feelings,I know it's difficult but she needs a friend...and arjun should start thinking that why Maya behaves this way,I know it's hard for arjun to do so at this scenario,but Maya really needs help and someone to control and stop Maya and help her get some medical help...

PS:- I am not justifying Maya or arjun...I am giving her a solution

But rancid sorry to disagree Maya cant be manipulative again to get love...if she falls in love then it should be without any expectations.,just love and only love...

Originally posted by: kavsy

This is my friendly advice to all. I deliberately did not comment on this thread as it will go round and round. The same scenarios, the same talks, and the same examples. Beyhadh is unpredictable. It is not only Maya who is on the suspect list. Even Arjun and Jhanvi are there on this list.

P.S I am not saying this to justify Maya's actions but I am saying this because a culprit is not a culprit unless it is proved. Whether it is Maya or Saanjh or Arjun or whomsoever it may be. Yes, Maya tried to kill VM and Saanjh by accident but before doing that she saw Arjun and came to senses. So no damage is done. Attempt to murder is a crime but it cannot be proved when no there is no damage at all.

If you talk about the killing the pundit at Mauritius, the show didn't talk about it. There is no investigation on that whatsoever. So there is no proof that Maya has killed the pundit.

If it was a normal person doing the same like what Maya is doing, that would have been a different story. If a person is mentally ill, one should show compassion and humanity. Those who do not have these, even they have a mental problem. (I know that you might take it personally and throw chappals and rotten eggs and tomatoes at me for saying this but I don't have any intention to hurt anyone here but to make people understand my point before doing that.)

As for the guidance, I would say yes, she needs it very badly. had Jhanvi brought up Maya singlehandedly without getting drowned in her problems & showing blind love towards Ashwin, things would have been different. Maya would have been a better person. Jhanvi loves Maya but she herself is/was mentally weak. She is at the age to mentor her daughter but she is getting mentored by her. So it has not been helpful to her. In these 3 years, I would like to know what had happened between Arya that their boat began to sink. I have said n no of times that no one is a saint in this show or otherwise. So definitely, I can expect some fault from Arjun's side too. I have been finding his character fishy from the time I have seen the bachelor party episode. I even wonder whether he has even tried to find out the cause of her behavior rather than taking a drastic step. I don't want to make any assumptions saying it is only Maya who is at fault.

Note: Though I like Maya, I am not justifying her as both of them are separate things but at the same time it is not been proved that she is a killer.