Maya is the killer???? - Page 5

Originally posted by: MistyDawn

2. ) her saying I trusted you and I thought marriage will make everything right, doesn't convince me about that person being Maya.. Jhanvi trusted Maya? ya..ok..mother's trust their daughters but is that something you would say? to me sounded like Jhanvi knew this person and had been confiding in him/her.. about her secrets? her plans? is this Arjun planted by Jhanvi? to get all her property? random incidents here n there makes me want to connect dots.. Arjun has always been an ambitious guy..Jhanvi understood that.. Arjun blurting out in drunk state at his bachelors party.. that he now own the company and everything that Maya has.. Ayaan had asked him then did he really love Maya?.. I dunno... something didn't feel right that day.. Is it possible that Jhanvi used Ashwin and then found a new pawn in Arjun ( that's why she kept apologizing to Ashwin??) but he double crossed her.. killed Ashwin and now is trying to put the blame on her? which is why the trust word and also the line that marriage will set things straight.. in terms of Maya's wealth and all.. ??

4.) I have a different interpretation of your 5th point which is 1.) why Jhanvi called Maya to the godown.. I don't think it was to confront her but to tell her the truth about Arjun..What she didn't realize was that Maya will bring Arjun along and that's why she kept hiding.. why would she call Maya and then hide from her? she can confront Maya infront of Arjun and Saanjh if she wanted to.. think about it.. the whole time she seemed to be scared of Arjun.. 2.) why she chose to confide in Saanjh and not Maya.. maybe coz after realizing that Maya is blind in her love and trust for Arjun, the only choice she was left with at that moment was Saanjh.. neutral atleast in Jhanvi's eyes.. she did try to confide in Maya first..only after Maya got Arjun in the picture, did she turn to Saanjh.

Originally posted by: sweetshruti

So after watching today's episode and putting together everything that we have read and seen from the spoiler segments I think they are moving towards making Maya the culprit...

The reason I say this is that:

1. One of the BTS segments showed Jhanvi finding evidence that Maya has been giving her medicines to hallucinate and that Maya is behind all this but in the show they made it look like it's Arjun who Jhanvi suspects as she saw him talking to that guy. They have not shown us the part where Jhanvi finds evidence against Maya. With Jhanvi going into a coma now it's pretty clear that they will show that scene as a FB at some point. They just shot the scene already for continuity.

2. Jhanvi is definitely referring to Maya or Arjun as the killer so Saanjh is off the hook. They are going out of their way to make Arjun look like the suspicious one so I am pretty sure it's not him. That leaves Maya.

3. Jhanvi's dialogues today to the killer about telling the world the truth about him/her, telling the world who the real pagal is, asking him/her why they are doing this to her, telling that she thought marriage would solve everything etc definitely looks like stuff she would tell Maya rather than Arjun.

4. Whoever Jhanvi suspects IS THE KILLER because he/she leads to Jhanvi's fall today and was coming towards her with a knife. So the theory that a 4^th person is doing all this and trying to frame Maya does not hold true anymore. If there was a 4^th unknown person Jhanvi would have been surprised to see him/her as she suspects either Maya / Arjun.

5. Jhanvi calls Maya to the godown probably to confront her. Also, Jhanvi wants to tell Saanjh the truth. If Arjun is the killer should'nt she tell Maya the truth instead of Saanjh?? Saanjh is Arjun's best friend and loves him so what makes Jhanvi trust Saanjh with the truth instead of her own daughter?? The only reason she would want to tell Saanjh the truth instead of Maya is if she things Saanjh will be able to do something about it.

Keeping all these points in mind I definitely think they are trying to make Maya the killer and I am really disappointed about that. 😕

Because Maya being the killer means:

A) Ashwin, the child abuser was right all along about her being mad

B) Vandana and her 10001 apshaguns and pandits were right all along

C) Arjun, Saanjh and Ayan were wrong in talking about giving a person a chance to start over and live a new life even if their past was tragic because apparently, a person with a tragic past can never improve.

If Maya has to be the killer then I just HOPE that they have a good justification for it...a mental illness, a split personality or anything that is responsible for making her do this and not just because she is "Pagal" or "obsessed". I would hate it if they make us sympathize with Maya and root for her only to tell us that she is actually just a phycho, obsessive killer with no redeeming qualities.

Waiting to see how they take this forward...

Originally posted by: PeraltaGarranty

Completely agreed

They want this big sort of twist in the show and making maya the killer will give them that.

It will be an absolute pulled the rug moment for maya fans because you can guess that 80% of the audience wont support a killer (I sure as hell wont but will keep watching coz im too addicted)

Only red herring is jhanvi I just cant imagine maya the one that jumped in the river to save her mother while she doesnt know how to swim would almost murder her own mom the only person she lived for before arjun came in her life.

Originally posted by: .annihilation.

Pitching in some bits as to why or how Maya could have done this to Jhanvi.

As much as I have understood Maya's character, she loves herself the most. (In the sense that, she always have had to protect her ownself first because there wasn't anyone else to protect her) She does love her mother, there are no two ways about it. However, we shouldn't forget that she also harbours a strong grudge against her because Jhanvi failed as a mother and thus all the ill treatment she meted out to Jhanvi. She's the kind who would not hesitate to put an end to her own lifeline (Jhanvi) if it comes to saving her life (Arjun, as in she cannot afford to lose him at any cost).

So, if the price is something as expensive and yet expendable as Jhanvi, she'd not think too much. In a bid to protect herself, what she loves the most (who at the moment is Arjun), what she cannot afford to lose, to hide her truth, she could very well go to any extent. Even attempting to eliminate her own mother who she does apparently love. That's honestly no surprise to me because I have always thought that Maya is capable of both protecting and harming her loved ones (recall the incident where she didn't hesitate before thrusting those broken glass pieces in Jhanvi's hand)

All that is going by the history of episodes and more specifically today's episode. While Maya being the real killer would be huge a let down in terms of executing a mystery/thriller track but it does tie up back to the Maya Mehrotra we knew which in a way I would call as 'being in character' because Maya Arjun Sharma was someone I was having difficulties in digesting as her 180 degree turn made no sense at all. 😆

As for Arjun, he would still have accepted her even if she killed Ashwin. What I think he'll have trouble accepting is the whole game play. The way she managed to get Arjun's love, how she got married to him, all the secrets and lies, all the deceit, planning and plotting, all the pretence and act.

And as for Jhanvi, I think what broke whatever trust Jhanvi had in her daughter wasn't the fact that she killed her husband. She might have managed to forgive her for that eventually but driving her insane in order to frame her as one of the suspect would have to be something she never expected from Maya.

Originally posted by: .annihilation.

<font size="2">
</font>

<font size="2">I understand your concerns and also see your questions having valid basis. The only reason or theory I could suggest is, from what I have gathered of Maya and Jhanvi's relationship (lets keep their mother-daughter relationship and they love each other factor aside for a moment) as two people entirely capable of both saving each others necks and throwing each other under the bus, if the push comes to it.</font>

<font size="2">Jhanvi from day one has always been suggesting Maya to come clean of her truth, always voicing her doubts and concerns as to what would happen if Arjun comes to know truth and worse if by a third person. Maya's always made sure at all times (whether or not she was associating with Ashwin at that point of time) that Jhanvi remains under her leash, acts as directed or told and conforms to her rules and standards defined by her.</font>

<font size="2">So, basically, either of the two turning an enemy force against the other doesn't quite come as a surprise to me. And case in point, Maya seems to have done the deed. But of course, this is entirely how I personally look at it.</font>