When someone tells you that you've reincarnated, the first reaction should be blatant disbelief/denial. There was a little of that in Amar. What I don't understand is why he ran off! He just found out that he and the woman he loves have been reincarnated. It's possible that someone who loves him so dearly now, could have possibly killed him in his last life. And by running off alone, he just proved that he does believe what SM said.
Isn't THIS the time to patronize Divya (and the others) and say that they're being foolish. Shouldn't he say that they're just Divya and Amar, not Vidya and Sagar? Why is he so quickly believing everything? Have they even showed any pictures, recounted any incidents, to make him believe? Frankly, when he is told something like this, he should either think HE has gone mad or the rest of them are plain crazy.
This is SO not the way it was supposed to happen. I wanted him to remember, not be told.
P.S. Amar has even more serious issues...I think people in the Singh parivaar are born with a little bit of cuckooness in their genes. But poor Amar was switched at birth. There was no one to nurture that cuckooness and let it prevail. So now, he's just a little lost boy inside.