Kamli and Mannu

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

RainbowKitty

@RainbowKitty

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: aparnauma
Mannu is upset sad confused with regard to his identity angry with his mother for keeping this as a secret he doesn't really know as to whose child he is Jagya's child or the man who died in front of his eyes.
His world turned upside down and people expect him to behave sensibly

Wonder how many people will be capable of entertaining rational thoughts in their head when so many things are eating up their minds

It is not just depression - He is anxious confused angry and frustrated too.

So many things are eating up his head when he is clearly not in his senses how can his behaviour be judged on that?

who is asking him to behave normal but did he has some memory loss ? He is hurt angry he can stop talking to everyone and be upset They hid this truth from me but how the hell he is insulting everyone around ?How he can forget all the love that is showered on him by same people for so long Which so many things are eating up his head He is only doing Ratan jaap but even cannot remember seeing family pictures all the love that Jagya and Ganga showered on him 16 years ? How that is justified ? His world has turned upside down does not mean he declare the people who loved him unconditionally 16 years as bad evil monsters and lie to convince others how much bad his mother is He is not so small who does not have brain to remember all the love which has been given to him by Jagya and Ganga Dadisaa Today he rejected abhi too why? because abhi is evil dr sahab's son ?what did abhi do ? where Mannu's love for abhi has gone ?

What Mannu is doing now its he who is going to suffer the most later How much he is hurt he is hurting others 10 times more and he will carry the burden of it on his heart forever

Edited by Hina- - 10 years ago

Quote

SPuja

@SPuja

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#22

Serials believe in making everything too dramatic and OTT. That is why the truth of Ratan was revealed to Mannu in most dramatic way and then they made his behavior OTT. Initial reaction of disbelief, hurt and anger was OK. Going to Pooja also seemed logical because she revealed the truth as soon as she came to know about it whereas all the elders including Anandi never mentioned those facts.

But after that he is behaving very rudely to everyone at home - and surprisingly became too understanding of Anandi - is it also because of shock of learning about his real father? I expected him to be serious, cold towards his parents, trying to find out more about his father - asking Bimala some questions - not that childish searching photo of Ratan in BH - if his mother and father are so bad that they did not tell him that his biological father is someone else, why would they keep a photo of his real father at their home? He should have questioned Anandi and DS about his father (considering he is angry with his parents). He should have asked Bimla why they (Ratan and Bimla) did not try to come to him, he should have asked Bimla why she does not want Mannu to live with her etc. Very disappointed with this track - as also the way Pushkar is being shown. Come on creatives - in this age when even films are beginning to treat disabled with some respect - why you want to show a retarded man playing with toys? Retarded people learn slowly - milestones are delayed, lack of social interaction skills etc. are there - but they do become adult - they do not behave like five years old at age 25.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

dolly

@tiny15

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: SPuja
Serials believe in making everything too dramatic and OTT. That is why the truth of Ratan was revealed to Mannu in most dramatic way and then they made his behavior OTT. Initial reaction of disbelief, hurt and anger was OK. Going to Pooja also seemed logical because she revealed the truth as soon as she came to know about it whereas all the elders including Anandi never mentioned those facts.
But after that he is behaving very rudely to everyone at home - and surprisingly became too understanding of Anandi - is it also because of shock of learning about his real father? I expected him to be serious, cold towards his parents, trying to find out more about his father - asking Bimala some questions - not that childish searching photo of Ratan in BH - if his mother and father are so bad that they did not tell him that his biological father is someone else, why would they keep a photo of his real father at their home? He should have questioned Anandi and DS about his father (considering he is angry with his parents). He should have asked Bimla why they (Ratan and Bimla) did not try to come to him, he should have asked Bimla why she does not want Mannu to live with her etc. Very disappointed with this track - as also the way Pushkar is being shown. Come on creatives - in this age when even films are beginning to treat disabled with some respect - why you want to show a retarded man playing with toys? Retarded people learn slowly - milestones are delayed, lack of social interaction skills etc. are there - but they do become adult - they do not behave like five years old at age 25.

puja agree wid u completely.

here mannu is selectively behaving rudely?? if hes hurt then why hes only angry at JaGan only??

why din't he think Aji also knew & she also hid the truth?? even if he thinks shes no1 2 interfere then why he blamed ganga 4 Aji's leaving BH in front of Aji??i mean why he shud bother if Aji left BH or not ??

and if this is the logic that Aji did nothing then why hes behaving like this wid abhi who also din't do anything nor knows anything??

and why not J can ask him 2 behave wid abhi??hes rite asking wat abhi ah s done 2 u that mannu talking like that.

if mannu's behavior is consistent then cud'd thot that he can't think rationally in such situtn but thats note case

@pushkar agree wid u.

and tho i don't mind bit drama in serials but why 2 show OTT stuff??its really OTT & melodramatic

Quote

BeautyBabe

@BeautyBabe

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: maria13
Yes abhi was proud of having a brother now he should be ashamed of he has Mannu as his brother and i wont blame him if he thinks so

abhi should reject Mannu as his brother This apna paraya drama Mannu started Abhi should give it back to Mannu O it will be so sweet Mannu hurt Abhi calling him Ratan Singh's son only not his brother 😈Let this Ratan junior taste his own medicine

Edited by kikyo - 10 years ago

Quote

BeautyBabe

@BeautyBabe

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#25

Mannu is not in his senses what has happened him lost his brain ? O no he has brain in his skull but right now he is using to make imaginary crap stories on Jagya and Ganga Poor boy he is so shocked but have all time to think negative 🤪

Mannu is no where confused where he is confused ? if he would be confused he would be thinking on Jagya's love for him Ganga's love for him be confused how such loving parents can cheat me He is not at all confused who is my father Jagya or that man who died in front of me He has made up his mind Ratan was my dad and Jagya is some evil monster so is my mother who did wrong to my poor father and he hates them for it

and one day Mannu will suffer very badly when he will be slapped by truth Jagya and Ganga will forgive him but the fact he will never be forgive himself and will carry this burden on his heart That is the best punishment for him and he totally deserves it

Quote

anshurg5

@anshurg5

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#26

Have not seen BH part but can conclude by above posts that he behaved badly with Abhi. Perhaps he can not consider Abhi as his brother now but only as the son of the person who kept him away from his own father.

----------

As for bad behaviour I remember one incidence of the recent past when Abhi threw the ice cream brought by J and served by Shivam very badly. Shivam was neither bullying nor taunting Abhi instead of it he served lovingly ice cream for himself and Abhi in big bowls as he knew that Abhi too loves ice cream . Still Abhi shouted and threw all the ice cream though he himself wanted to eat ice cream on that day. .

There was only one reason that made Abhi angry that ice cream was brought because Shivam asked it not him. Neither J knew that Abhi too asked for ice cream , nor he refused him nor Shivam asked ice cream for himself only still Abhi was angry and unjust towards Shivam due to his imaginary insecurities.

His anger was understood and he was sympathized by many forum members but when Mannu who is going through the biggest crisis of his life and is behaving badly due to after shock of sudden changes in his life then why instead of getting sympathy and understanding he is called a cheapo ?

Even The Earth takes time to stabilize itself after a major earthquake and there are usually after shocks then why Mannu can not be allowed time to stabilize himself? There will be after shocks in BH also due to his behavior.

Edited by anshurg5 - 10 years ago

Quote

mahi12

@mahi12

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

#27

I think Jagya Ganga Dadisaa Abhi should leave Mannu on his own No need to be concerned for him Let him suffer getting kicks of life He will come back on track Why wasting emotions and time on him Mannu is not worth it

Quote

Vidya

@Shinya

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#28

yes, of course, mannu deserves kicks of life. First his mother kept him in the dark. Then she suddenly took him to a funeral and told him to do the last rites of the dead man. When he asked why, she said he was your father.

After giving him such a shock of his life, what he deserves now are kicks of life. Why? because his goddess mother hid the truth from him out of fear that he will go back to his father after knowing the truth. She knew Ratan would win his heart with his love. And this is precisely what she feared and it happened that way.

Edited by Shinya - 10 years ago

Quote

Stephi

@Stephi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#29

Every parent has some secret. Anandi didnt tell to Amol that his biological parents are in desperate search of him. . She hid that fact from everyone . When his parents suddenly showed up in KB we can also say Amol was given such a shock of his life. Especially when Anandi said just like that these are your parents, you have to go with them. So? Was Amol rude to her, did he tell her you knew it but never told me, you're bad, you're a liar, I will never forgive you. Did he make up stories to prove how hurt he is ? And scared because he has to go with people he never met before even though they never gave up on him like Ratan did . Mannu can be angry and hurt but it doesnt mean he should be so rude, lying and disrespectful. And why his younger brother deserves such a treatment from him. What Abhi had done wrong to him ?

Edited by Stephi - 10 years ago

Quote

aparnauma

@GoodDoc_2105

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#30

Did Anandi know that his parents were searching for him when they brought him from orphanage?

What was the time span between Anandi knowing that the parents came in search of him and them landing at her home? Not even one day.

Orphanage verified the details about the parents and landed at her place just a few hours later.Orphanage people accepted that they goofed up on Amol and did not verify the facts before giving him for adoption.Biological parents and Adopted parents neither of them were at fault.

She told Amol immediately that his parents are here to claim him without any delay.

If I remember right Anandi was criticised for acting in haste.

But now it turned out that Amol is comfortable with having two sets of parents and divides his time between them.

Edited by aparnauma - 10 years ago