Lol, this is exactly what I thought when I heard about this track. Was there no-one else the Singhs could have sent to drop off these gifts? Why not send Bhairon? Or even Makhan? He's trustworthy enough.
Plus Sanchi has lost whatever few marbles she may have had to start with. First of all, Jagya is her sister-in-law's ex, and that's somewhat icky as triangles go. Like I would not even want to date my friend's ex, let alone my family member's. It's not immoral or anything, but it's just something most people would be somewhat hesitant to do. And secondly (and this confounds me much more than Jagya being Anandi's ex), Jagya FRAMED Shiv and got him thrown in jail for a night! I am shocked that Sanchi and the rest of the Shekhars would be so friendly with him after that. Any normal family would be at least a little wary of someone who had caused one of its members distress in the past. Or have the CVs conveniently forgotten about the railway ghotala? Not that I blame them if they have... that was another horrible, OTT and OOC track, lol.