k.taddy1234 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Hi Guys... Im regularly come in this forums and read all the post and comments and their is a war still going on Prats vs Toral. Yes im a die hard fan of Anandi aka Avika and Pratyusha but sorry to say that Toral is not look like Anandi. So after Prats replacement and given the two weeks of time to Toral and i stooped BV becoz she is not able to poitrate the character of Anandi but its only my view i not saying that anybody should agree with me. And im not here to tell who is good or bad. I came here for different discussion Some ppl gave different reason to watch BV and accept new Anandi .i.e some said that they doent like Prats as Anandi becoz she is not look good and beautiful and demand to replace her when this is happened they easily accept new Anandi, some said they are loyal viewer of BV and watch is till the end, and some said that only character is matter not actor , if actor is replaced but still character there so it is doesnt matter who played this etc. First two reason acceptable by me but last reason im not agree with this who said that only character matter not actor. It Is really ture that only character imp not Actor. So if i asked you one question if due to some reason DS aka Surekha ji replaced by Ammaji of NIDML (sorry i forger her name) becoz she is good actress, Shiv aka Sid replaced by Harsad Chopra or Vivan (both are good looking and doing grate acting), Bharion aka Anoop replaced by Mohnish Behl and Jagiya aka Shashak is replaced by Kishuk Mahajan (you also can add name acc to your wish list) but if this case happend then we easily accept these actors in the character. Acc to me '' ACTOR IS MIRROR OF CHARACTER'' if actor is not fit in the role or character we never accpet the actor. And it doesnt matter who is great actor if played these character. Take some example form bollywood also nobody forget the iconic villain character Gabbar Sing which is played by Amjad Khan and nobody replace him becoz they are alternative of each other and we know what happend when the remake of Sholay made and Gabbar Singh character playe by none other than Mr Amitabh Bacahan the superstar of the millennium and he was criticized by their fans. Ppl will accept SRK and Ashwariya as Raj and Simran of DDLJ instead of SRK and Kajol, or we can accept Salman Khan or Hritik Roshan as the hockey coach of Chak De India. Every actor is not fit for each and every role. Its the talk about bollywood we can also take example of TV industry the way Shiva character played by Mohit Raina in DKDM there is anybody in industry who can play this character or repalced him. And Bhabho character of DABH is played by Neelu ji anybody can play that character that ways Neelu ji played this. When one character is written it is not everybody only few actors is fit for a particular not everybody. Becoz Actor and Character is like a "BODY AND SOUL" if there is no soul in body then body is nothing. In a same way if Actor is not choose acc to character then character is never connected with the ppl. Im not doing comparison her but im just share my POV of view that character is matter but equally actor is also matter. Im not saying that anybody should agree with me but some where it is true that Actor is the medium of character. If actor is not fit in a particular role then ppl will not connect with the character. And sorry for the such a long post and sorry if i hurt anybody emotions.
Edited by k.taddy123 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

1k

Users

7

Likes

32

Frequent Posters

Blukitten thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Good question...Lets wait till next replacement and then see the forum's reaction ;-)
SunitaSRK thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
great, bang on, totaly agree with you.

Payali09 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
I don't think there is a Pratz verus Toral war happening. They seem very busy with their own business at the moment to be engaging in any warfare. If you are referring to what is happening on the forum then there are a number of disagreements happening for a variety of reasons that cannot be lumped under one banner of Team Pratyusha versus Team Toral. It's simply not the case.

In terms of is it really true that character is more important than actor...this discussion has been ongoing for the last month and there seems to be no definitive answer to your question. Also people tend to become unhappy with whatever answer is given so I personally don't find it a question worth discussing in great detail. I'm not saying don't discuss it, please feel free to discuss whatever you want. I'm just giving my perspective on the futility of discussing it because you won't get a satisfactory answer.

People think one thing is more important, less important or just as important as another thing because of their own perspective. It's not a matter of something being true or not when it comes to the arts, it's about what you experience and why you experience it. Everyone is different and everyone has a different take on things. The characters you listed are iconic but not just because of the actor but because of the dialogue, the costuming, the characterization and the story within which the character existed. I am not minimizing the work of the actor at all but just pointing out that there are many elements that need to come together for a character to be brought to life.
milindrose thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
pratyusha is good actress it doen't matter she is beautiful but she had elegance to pull anandi high n she did that is why we love her n want her back,,,


no one can pull the show so nicely as pratt did so actor does matter a lot
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
@TM Just like you have your own views and stopped watchin the show because of your own reasons others also have their own reasons for to continue watching the show.
If you like Pratyusha and stopped watching because she is not there there are others who apparently like Toral and are watching the show.

There are other people for who character is important they decide to watch no matter who plays the character.They may have problems accepting the new actor playing the character but still decide to watch and it is their decision.

There are others who have been watching the show for the past 5 years for their own reasons and if they decide to watch the show till it ends it is their own business.

If you do not agree with the view that character is more important than the actor that is your point of view.

I don't think there is any right or wrong here.Different people have a different way of looking at things.
.Prometheus. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Why do members continue to flout the rules of the forum - the rules CLEARLY state that topics SHOULD NOT be made where Prats and Toral are being discussed in the same post

TOPIC CLOSED

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".