BV WU- 4th Feb 2013 Secrets Revealed - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

9.9k

Users

24

Likes

185

Frequent Posters

hooked thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: nniks

@hooked anandi is not yet a mother hence she wont understand nor wld be able to console ganga...she just gave whatever example came in her mind...n tht shockinh look was not due to ganga' being a bv but it ws sadness at seeing yet another life being destroyed due to tht practice...


@Nniks. I got that A was trying to connect via her worst pain with Ganga.
I also get that she was sad to see G too was a victim of BV, but my point is - is that so shocking ? Stopping young gairls getting married even today is a priority, but those who were married a couple of years ago, like when she was - or Phooli was, or Sugna was- i mean- wasn't the whole Jaitser's womenfolk married as a kid ? That happens to be a prevalent custom of the area and sadness is accepted but SHOCK ?? Isn't that a bit OTT from Anandi ?

Cheer up Ganga, concentrate on positives and not sit down and start sharing your own sob story...atleast that's what I felt. And I continue to hope that after today's long face - she will put on her cheerful face and say - we'll fix it all and make it good for you 😉⭐️


708922 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: hooked


@Nniks. I got that A was trying to connect via her worst pain with Ganga.
I also get that she was sad to see G too was a victim of BV, but my point is - is that so shocking ? Stopping young gairls getting married even today is a priority, but those who were married a couple of years ago, like when she was - or Phooli was, or Sugna was- i mean- wasn't the whole Jaitser's womenfolk married as a kid ? That happens to be a prevalent custom of the area and sadness is accepted but SHOCK ?? Isn't that a bit OTT from Anandi ?

Cheer up Ganga, concentrate on positives and not sit down and start sharing your own sob story...atleast that's what I felt. And I continue to hope that after today's long face - she will put on her cheerful face and say - we'll fix it all and make it good for you 😉⭐️



I know this is for Nniks, but I have to agree with Nniks on this one...the pain of seeing an individual be a balika vadhu is like revisiting one's past pain. Being a victim of a social disease is something one can't forget and to run into another woman who was also a victim just makes one more upset because as we know Anandi has and will continue to fight against this issue and has basically lowered the rates of bal vivah happening in her area, but it still does not mean that it does not still happen. I don't think she was shocked that she was a balika vadhu, only hurt to see another woman victimized so brutally. It's one thing to know that Ganga was a woman who was beaten up by men, her baby stolen from her, but another to find out that Ganga is a balika vadhu who has faced physical/emotional abuse from childhood and onwards. I think she was just hit by how awful Ganga's situation is/was in comparison to her own personal experience. To have suffered the brutality of Ganga's treatment by her in-laws from childhood is shocking because as you said, while there were some girls that Anandi knows that faced terrible situations, or were happy in their child marriages, this situation is different because no one saved Ganga or made things better for her. She has suffered for this long and has even had a child, with no end to her suffering still. CVs of course have made her different than all the other girls in that aspect for the very purpose of showing someone who is very different from Anandi.

Ganga's sob story may have felt a bit forced, but she is a woman who's lost everything and helpless. So while delivery of those lines may seem odd...I don't think it's unusual bc she is tired of the condolences when all she wants is her child.
hooked thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: yaherd15

Ganga's sob story may have felt a bit forced, but she is a woman who's lost everything and helpless. So while delivery of those lines may seem odd...I don't think it's unusual bc she is tired of the condolences when all she wants is her child.


I was not complaining about Ganga's sob story. But about Anandi's pathetic attempt to reach out to Ganga and connect thru her own mothers loss. G is lying there imaptient, hurting and bruised and missing her kid terribly - you think she wants to listen to anyone talk about their pain ?

You are right when you said - G is done with condolences, all she wants is her kid - so then - how do you expect her to sit n listen to Anandi moaning about her mom ? G will be more glad to know if Ansh will put in an effort to get her baby back to her and have her in-laws punished.


708922 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: hooked


I was not complaining about Ganga's sob story. But about Anandi's pathetic attempt to reach out to Ganga and connect thru her own mothers loss. G is lying there imaptient, hurting and bruised and missing her kid terribly - you think she wants to listen to anyone talk about their pain ?

You are right when you said - G is done with condolences, all she wants is her kid - so then - how do you expect her to sit n listen to Anandi moaning about her mom ? G will be more glad to know if Ansh will put in an effort to get her baby back to her and have her in-laws punished.



I agree that nothing much can be said, but I think that's why Anandi said that I know that losing a child is something I have not experienced, but I do know how it feels to lose someone so important to you. Losing a mother is as painful of an experience as is losing one's child. It's that mother-child relationship she was using as an example to make a connect. Like nniks said, it's not the exact same thing, that's something Anandi realizes, but Anandi is trying her best to connect by providing comfort through sympathy. I find that very realistic and human gesture to do when someone is in pain and freaking out in panic, the instinctive thing to do is try to calm that person and show them that you understand and care and are on their side. Don't think it's wrong for Anandi to do that, just think Anandi is trying to show to Ganga that she understands Ganga's pain because she can see Ganga doesn't trust anyone and is freaking out at Jagya since he was no help to her like all the other men in her life. We see that when G is telling off Jagya about not being there for her and Anandi understands the whole concept of mistrusting men because she too started mistrusting them after Jagya's betrayal which is why she was so mistrustful of Shiv's help in the beginning. I think she was bringing some much needed softness to the scene, to Ganga by being a woman providing emotional support to another woman in pain.

Well I don't think Anandi can start by telling her that we will get you justice, she needs to make a connect with Ganga, to get Ganga to trust them first so that she believes that they want to help her. Yes Ganga doesn't want to hear anything, but it is therapy for the soul when people share their sorrows, knowing they are not alone in their pain, having someone who understands the pain of separation. Again it's not the same exact thing, but Anandi knows that, but that still doesn't make her pain less and Ganga knows that as by the way she reacted to Anandi's confession.

I don't know...I mean I guess it just didn't really bother me to see that happen because it was just so human for me to watch Anandi do that...😕 But I guess to each his/her own...right? It's not like you have to agree with me or anything, I just didn't really see it that way so I just posted to have a discussion. That's all. =)
sai1234 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Rkalpana

Thanks for update. Cvs taking the story in a casual manner. Why start talk of khushkhabari immediately after marriage? And the IVF track is ridiculous. Jagdish has just MBBS qualification, perhaps Lal Singh also is MBBS. There is no gynecologist shown and IVF is specialised field and perhaps requires special lab set ups... If they want to give social message, they should not show that a person of Basant's age is trying to become dad again just to give his son a companion.



I agree that Jagya and Lal Singh might not be qualified but men can have children at any age so its not that unrealistic.
yzyz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: yaherd15


I agree that nothing much can be said, but I think that's why Anandi said that I know that losing a child is something I have not experienced, but I do know how it feels to lose someone so important to you. Losing a mother is as painful of an experience as is losing one's child. It's that mother-child relationship she was using as an example to make a connect. Like nniks said, it's not the exact same thing, that's something Anandi realizes, but Anandi is trying her best to connect by providing comfort through sympathy. I find that very realistic and human gesture to do when someone is in pain and freaking out in panic, the instinctive thing to do is try to calm that person and show them that you understand and care and are on their side. Don't think it's wrong for Anandi to do that, just think Anandi is trying to show to Ganga that she understands Ganga's pain because she can see Ganga doesn't trust anyone and is freaking out at Jagya since he was no help to her like all the other men in her life. We see that when G is telling off Jagya about not being there for her and Anandi understands the whole concept of mistrusting men because she too started mistrusting them after Jagya's betrayal which is why she was so mistrustful of Shiv's help in the beginning. I think she was bringing some much needed softness to the scene, to Ganga by being a woman providing emotional support to another woman in pain.

Well I don't think Anandi can start by telling her that we will get you justice, she needs to make a connect with Ganga, to get Ganga to trust them first so that she believes that they want to help her. Yes Ganga doesn't want to hear anything, but it is therapy for the soul when people share their sorrows, knowing they are not alone in their pain, having someone who understands the pain of separation. Again it's not the same exact thing, but Anandi knows that, but that still doesn't make her pain less and Ganga knows that as by the way she reacted to Anandi's confession.

I don't know...I mean I guess it just didn't really bother me to see that happen because it was just so human for me to watch Anandi do that...😕 But I guess to each his/her own...right? It's not like you have to agree with me or anything, I just didn't really see it that way so I just posted to have a discussion. That's all. =)


That's the whole truth wrote from yaherd15.👏
Anandi was not boring, but calm, giving a lot more confidence for distressed Ganga, while she herself faced with her own problems. But what Ganga says is much more than preventing 'child marriage' and returning the little girl to school. These are different cases of discrimination caused by poverty.
They are all accomplices and victims, and this is the great series.

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
Neha- thanks for the written update


Very unimpressive episode.Very dissatisfying experience.

Only scene which was sweet was Shiv's satsifaction at the thought of his wife closing the gaps evevn if it was in her sleep.But I guess that tells how much she trusts him instinctively.

I don't know what was the intention behind letting CM and probably Sanchi also know about the non consummation of marriage.Are the CVs intent on letting the whole family know that the couple has not consummated their marriage?And make a drama out of it?🤢🤢😡

Dadisa is going over board with her laad pyar just because she wants to lavish all her affection on her prodigal grandson she does not need to rush to the hospital and interrupt his work.He is not a small child.He is doctor who is used to staying up in the night and missing meals.

The scene the supposedly epic meet between two balkia vadhus - fell flat.

If they intended that Ganga and Anandi to connect in that scene their intention really did not show.
I don't know whether Ganga and Anandi connected with each other but I definitely could not connect with the part of the story there were trying to tell.

Why did Anandi have to talk about her pain on loss of her mother to a woman who was pining for her child?Agreed she was trying to tell the woman that her child suffering and asa mother the pain she feels is valid and is trying to justify Ganga' s uncooperative behaviour.

But more than trying to justify her behaviour it would have been nice if she tried to connect with her pain and started of saying how terrible she felt when she saw how her friend Phooli was separated from her child that would have been more apt given the situation.

I think the scene was written badly with bad dialogues which failed to find connect with viewers.

As for the bloopers - I know Singh Parivar owns the hospital and Mr and Mrs Shivraj Shekhar are on the administrative board of the hospital but it still DOES NOT GIVE ANY OF THEM THE RIGHT TO BARGE IN WHEN A DOCTOR IS BUSY WITH HIS PATIENT.😡😡
THE PLACE THEY BARGED INTO IS SACRED AND IT BELONGS ONLY TO THE DOCTOR AND HIS PATIENT.
Edited by aparnauma - 12 years ago
divine_ram thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28
@aparnauma Righty said about today's episode. The only saving grave was the first scene on how shiv felt happy seeing his wife hand on his chest and the beautiful voice over dialogues by him. His voice is very soothing to the ear. Why cannot they develop more scenes in ansh bedroom with subtle romance like day to day activities. Cv should exploit the chemistry both actors have instead of stupid family interference drama they might in ansh life. I really hope CM talks to anandi or behaves sensibly with anandi. I am getting irritated by DS nowadays with her over love for jagya. The dialogue by er saying "jagya might not have slept well in years so don't wake him up" plz old lady ur jaggubhai was seeping peacefully with his wife gauri till few months ago and got her pregnant too. 😡
All the Singh and ansh family barging into patient room without any permission was a big blooper.
BV did blunders related to medical profession and collector office work, so ths is nothing in front of it.
Plz send saanchi to hostel, she is very irritating with her appearance too.
Rkalpana thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: sai1234



I agree that Jagya and Lal Singh might not be qualified but men can have children at any age so its not that unrealistic.

Perhaps u misunderstood me. I wanted to say that what kind of social message CVs want to convey by this track? Men can have children at any age but is it advisable to have children in old age. Gahna is much younger but if Basant's first child survived, he (Basant) would have been a grand dad now.
nolla thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Rkalpana

Perhaps u misunderstood me. I wanted to say that what kind of social message CVs want to convey by this track? Men can have children at any age but is it advisable to have children in old age. Gahna is much younger but if Basant's first child survived, he (Basant) would have been a grand dad now.


In europe & usa, women approching 70 had kids!!! So i think its not the age that matters, its only the will, determination, hope & faith that matters!!!! The last one who had hers was 65yrs old.😊 So whatever we pple think, it depends on the couple that is concerned & the grace of the one who has more than 1000 names (GOD). Oh!! sorry, also with the help of Jagya of course😉 "Joking, i mean specialistes".

Btw, if we look at it on the practical way, the guy is really a fertility specialiste!!! When anandi mentioned DS's wish, he wont off like bomb, saying he is not ready for a kid. But we all know it was b'coz love was budding with gauri. But someone said it in this FT, that he got gauri twice pregnant!!!😆 So he knows all the formulars of how to do it... We shld give him credit & our encouragement? Especialy now that anandi is taking over his mission of saving ganga and her kid. Poor thing, he can't even redeem himself in peace!!😔 Anyway, now he has plenty of time to concentrate on ferterlising gena & basant...
This way Sumi ll get kushi kabri (good news)soon😆
Edited by nolla - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".