Cowboys Don't Cry! Why not?

AnjanaYYZ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
There is a novel that's almost a staple of western school system. It's called "Cowboys Don't Cry"... I read it a lifetime back. Its a coming of edge story of a boy. Nothing else stuck with me though till today but, the title and class discussions we had about it. Am reminded of it every time I hear the phrase - "Boys don't cry". Why? Kyun? Cowboys...boys should cry.

Cry is about release of pain. Its a good thing not a bad thing. So, long as we don't just sit and cry for weeks/mnths and nothing else (then that's depression). Otherwise its a totally valid outlet for releasing pain. Better than drinking or burying one's feelings in denial or anger. Anger is the unhealthiest of emotions - it destroys capacity to reason - to find solution - it makes us obsess. As does Hate which is stronger version of anger. Anger turns to hate and Hate turns to invisible shackles that keep us rooted to the past. Crying if it releases the pain and allows one to move forward without anger is much more hollistic and healthy.

Alas societal norms and false believes have us cling to - Cowboys don't Cry and say Boys don't Cry. Its weak and boys oh they must be strong. That is, however, WRONG.

Tears are not signs of weakness. We can own our tears and our fears. It doesn't make us strong or weak. Its just outlet of pain. What with do with the pain is what defines us. Crying does not. Do we let the pain make us bitter or better?

I used to buy all this crap and never show hurt. Then one day I reasoned why not? I hurt - I hurt. So what! If person hurting me knows then so what? They should know impact of their conduct... why do I the hurt one have to make live easier for my hurtor? Moreover, being hurt gives me edge personally! Moral might. Strength not weakness. Now I know not everyone finds strength in pain like me... but, maybe if they did then they would know the true value of tears and learn to embrace them and their fears of tears.

Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.3k

Users

4

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

SiriuslySujal thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I agree. Tears are not a sign of weakness, nor is showing emotion in general. It is healthy to let one's sadness out... keeping it in can actually cause serious physical damage (hypertension etc). Crying also allows one's pain to leave one's body and, as you say, makes us better rather than bitter. If society were more amenable towards people being open about their emotions, I think life would be easier for a lot of people. But instead we are often told off for crying as children, or told by our peers to "just get over" things that upset us. I think I personally have slowly retreated into myself as a result of feeling misunderstood in that fashion by a lot of my friends. And seeing people bashing Anandi in the current fashion... well, it reminds me a lot of times when I've felt that way in my life. So I really feel for her, and I hope her family or Shiv are able to reach out to her so that she can have a confidant. I'm actually really sad Ashi didn't stay longer... there's nothing quite like a good female friend in one's age group. Perhaps Phooli can drop by for consolation. I guess Bhago is coming, though, which should help make up for Sumitra's absence in part.
My own personal problem with tears in particular is that while I don't have a problem with them in general, I don't feel comfortable shedding them in front of my family members because I don't want to worry or upset them. I think Anandi is similar... she doesn't often cry in front of others. It is only now that her crying is really evident to everyone. Otherwise she has mostly cried behind closed doors. So I reckon it is good that her pain is finally becoming more visible. I reckon there's only so long that you can hide inner hurts from those closest to you. So, as I said above, I think Anandi really needs a shoulder to cry on at the moment... hence the particularly strong pang she feels at Sumitra's absence. She will be overjoyed to see Bhago, I'm sure!
tinoo thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
For me, I would distinguish whether the person who hurt me did it unintentionally ... or whether he had a clear idea that he was hurting me (either through malicious intent or through selfishness).
I believe that jagya did not actively go look for a girlfriend to maliciously slight anandi ... however, he did know fully well what he was doing ... for a really long time ... and consequently, my hurt was the fallout of his selfishness.
If a person has done something unintentionally ... then yes, I have no issues crying in front of them and showing them the hurt...
But if someone has done something either intentionally or knowingly, then i would never give anyone the satisfaction of knowing that what they had done had even one ounce of effect on me.
From that vantage point, given that jagya knew fully well what he was doing and proceeded to do it anyway precludes me from giving him any satisfaction of seeing me cry in front of him.
AnjanaYYZ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Its irrelevant to me what the intention of person hurting me is. That's their problem not mine. I hurt and if I feel like crying then I cry. Because its about grappling with my pain in a healthy way. Once the pain is shed through tears then I determine what is healthiest course for me...revenge? or walking away? or what? I can't control other person, I control ME! My actions and reactions.

Also one assumes in this scenario that the pain is about Jugia. Its not. Its death of their rishta. The failure of it. Not an accusation. And last I saw Anandi was not shedding buckets infront of Jugia in court in anycase. Her eyes were questioning... mourning the loss of Jogia not Jugat... her mind wondering about the weakness of the dor that bound them an young age.



tinoo thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: AnjanaYYZ

Its irrelevant to me what the intention of person hurting me is.


This is where our fundamental paradigms and world views themselves are different ...so I bow out of the argument right now because i see that we will never come to a meeting point about the specific issue when our paradigms itself are different. 😆😆
AnjanaYYZ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: tinoo

This is where our fundamental paradigms and world views themselves are different ...so I bow out of the argument right now because i see that we will never come to a meeting point about the specific issue when our paradigms itself are different. 😆😆


Yup - That's why I don't post on your numerous kyun kyun kyun posts of late... I see the world very differently from you. Negativity begets Negativity. Its better to counter with positive...and let go of the things that hurt us in the healthiest way then carry grudges. For me even forgiveness should be about one's own welfare not about the person one is forgiving. Not to say am always forgiving, but not forgiving pratically hurts me more...because then I am carrying the pain from someone else's misconduct. The lesson lies in not forgetting but yet forgiving.

Coming from such perspective, I don't perceive Anandi's conduct as negative. If she was plotting to keep Jugia or manipulating him or berating him or trying to beat him down with her accomplishments...all of those things would be negative actions. Her actions are not. She is simply releasing her hurt, trying to find a positive outlet for the pain and then move beyond without bitterness.
Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
To be true , I was against Anandi mourning for a dead relationship from update,
But I agree the way they showed it with flash backs and her inner self conversation. I could relate to it after episode. I saw episode again to read her eyes the way they were questioning Jagya.
I have seen more of the entire BV with skipping it in few dead lows. But during their childhood phase I was regular BV viewer.
What Anadi shared with Jagya was not one but was layers of various relationships. Like in our childhood we share special bond with our sibling because of cherished beautiful memories with them. She shared a same bond with Jagya, they grew up together, they did lot of thing together first time. He was his best friend, his childhood buddy and overall her first love.For her it was all she had from the time she could understand anything about love or marriage.
Even for Jagya it was not easy to let go that bond even he was hesitant. Loss of that beautiful bond of 10-12 years of love, mutual understanding, admiration, definately leave a scar on her heart and vaccum in her life. Letting go all your memories, all your life you had till noe with a sign on paper. How much its easy said, its not that easy to let it go.
Sometime tears are one way to let it go, let all your pain out from your heart through your eyes. Than only you can leave all past behind and move forward.
Edited by kuls11 - 13 years ago
AnjanaYYZ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Kuls - beautifully put. Congrats on Sanchi ka divorce track and Mohan ki mukhi from death!
Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: AnjanaYYZ

Kuls - beautifully put. Congrats on Sanchi ka divorce track and Mohan ki mukhi from death!

Yes finally divorce track it should have been marriage annulment track though..and Mohan is pheonix who always rise from his own ashes😆HE is one and only reason I watch NBT till now😆
AnjanaYYZ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: kuls11

Yes finally divorce track it should have been marriage annulment track though..and Mohan is pheonix who always rise from his own ashes😆HE is one and only reason I watch NBT till now😆


I know ...I wondered same - what have Sanchiya and Indu been upto that they require divorce😉😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".