**New AnS talk is on...COMMENTS**

amina877 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Hi Friends!

I hope everyone is doing great!😃

Welcome to our very own...

In AnS talk, we will discuss some of the very interesting topics related to this section every week hopefully!😃

This week's theme is...

* Comments*

Here are some questions to think about...

What kind of commenters do you prefer? Direct, short, to the point OR the one's with long posts describing it to the minute detail?
Why is everyone dying in the section these days? Isn't it better to keep ppl alive by your creations rather than killing them? Then if commenters say they "died" ...is that really good or bad?🤔😉
Do you believe that comments have an effect on your work?Good or Bad?

Is there anything you have learned from others comments so far?

A big thanks to Khair for helping with the questions and post!😃🤗

Do share your views and thoughts with us!😛

Have fun and keep smiling!!😃

Edited by amina877 - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.1k

Users

11

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

HayeSiyaapa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
cool post amina.. im a nwer rite noww
momogrl21 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

haiiii, what an awesome topic 👏

truthfully, without the comments i've recieved-i dont think i'd be making siggys 😊 i do prefer comments that say how my piece of work was...i agree a lot of comments these days have simply been ***FAINT, or *DEAD*, so far, i've actually thought of them as positive to tell the truth 😆 but its absolutely true that we can take this for another meaning 😉😛 But if something turns out bad, i would prefer anyday to have someone tell me its bad. Then i can see what i've done wrong and learn from that. That way, i can not repeat that style or color again to i'll improve from there. In general, comments have always supported me, encouraged me!!! But even then, i still dont know how my creations are truly-because 95% comments I get are those who are regular in my gallery-my friends from IF. I haven't yet gotten any serious "critique" 😊. So i guess I really haven't actuaaly learnt anything but just to keep going. In general, i appreciate the comments I get-it does keep me going. Sometimes I do wish comments were more elaborate 😳 I try to write comments describing the work sometimes-it may not be every detail-but i try-using adjectives. Usually, that explains how good i thik the work is 😳

Nice topic Aminaaa!! 👏😃😳

HayeSiyaapa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: amina877

This week's theme is...

* Comments*

Here are some questions to think about...
What kind of commenters do you prefer? Direct, short, to the point OR the one's with long posts describing it to the minute detail?anything the commenter wahnts to tell me. if someone wantxs to express veiws thru a long paragraph dats fine with me as long as it doesnt repaet over n over... n if its direct n short its easier to readd
Why is everyone dying in the section these days? Isn't it better to keep ppl alive by your creations rather than killing them? Then if commenters say they "died" ...is that really good or bad?🤔😉LMFAOOOOO!!AMINAAA i luv uu🤗.. dis is such a cuteeee questionn.. lolzz its basicallt an exxageration to make it show dat u luv itt.. but usuually wne i see ppl write dat dey never use da sig altho it "killed" them.. lolzzzz😆
Do you believe that comments have an effect on your work?Good or Bad?Ummmmhhh!! welll usually no one ever gives advice on improving work or negative points no matte rhow da sig looks.. everyone is always like good job good job... dat can sometimes go tto a sig makers head as ive seen b4... they get tooo stuck up n put up ridiculously weird rulez just cuz either everyone loves der sigz orbeecuz everyone says der sigz r good.. but comments are also a good thig cuz dey like encourage u to keep on workin on sigz n dat develops into new ideafied sigz
Is there anything you have learned from others comments so far?welll.... to tell you the truth not muchh.. but occasionally i show ma sigz to one of ma friedns who gives good adice.. she isnrt a sig maker but she tells me wat i should work on to make others liek it.. n dat has helped me alott.. usually commenters just say "wow.. good job👏" or "good work" something along those lines i see nothin in dat , that would help someone while makin a sig.. unl4ess if da sigz r truly pwerfect and have no place for improvemtn wich is really uncommon..

I hope none of my answers offended anyonee

Overall comments re just a nice encouragement but i think a lil constructive criticism and advice may help sig makers😊

LUV
PUJA😳

~bella~ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
okkii Amina these r some guud questiionz so imma just save me spot nd awser them in few minutes! 😉
IBserenity thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
Will be bk with my answers...
Lil Ms.Sunshine thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
What kind of commenters do you prefer? Direct, short, to the point OR the one's with long posts describing it to the minute detail?I actually like anyone that comments. Doesn't matter what kind of comment is. w/ detail or direct, or short. Just their kindness of giving my shop a little time of their life makes me happy.😳

Why is everyone dying in the section these days? Isn't it better to keep ppl alive by your creations rather than killing them? Then if commenters say they "died" ...is that really good or bad?lmpao! I've came across that..no wait..i don't think. I've been afraid that I don't kill anyone. Lately, they're stuck on fainting. They gain concious and faint again by some other siggy maker.😆 I like to take it as a compliment but sometimes it feels odd cause I don't get if they're fainting cause the siggy turned out good or because its so ugly they fainted!😆I would like it if they told my why their fainting.😛😆
Do you believe that comments have an effect on your work?Good or Bad?They definately do because it shows me that if I'm doing good or bad. If the comments are good and they like my work it shows me that I can continue with this style. If it weren't for comments, I wouldn't know I'm copying someone or not. They would definately tell me and I wouldn't take it in a bad way. Then bad (critisicm) shows me that I need to get better. So, yes it does effect on my work.
Is there anything you have learned from others comments so far?Umm, I'm sure I have..but I just haven't thought of them yet!😛

Lil Ms.Sunshine thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: babiilovexox3



Do you believe that comments have an effect on your work?Good or Bad?Ummmmhhh!! welll usually no one ever gives advice on improving work or negative points no matte rhow da sig looks.. everyone is always like good job good job... dat can sometimes go tto a sig makers head as ive seen b4... they get tooo stuck up n put up ridiculously weird rulez just cuz either everyone loves der sigz orbeecuz everyone says der sigz r good.. but comments are also a good thig cuz dey like encourage u to keep on workin on sigz n dat develops into new ideafied sigz



you cracked me up w/ that one Puja!🤣🤣

wait--do potatoes crack? ANUU!! help!!😳
-Masakali- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

What kind of commenters do you prefer? Direct, short, to the point OR the one's with long posts describing it to the minute detail?
i prefer any kind of comments....i like the direct ones because they get to the point😳

Why is everyone dying in the section these days? Isn't it better to keep ppl alive by your creations rather than killing them? Then if commenters say they "died" ...is that really good or bad?🤔😉
i think it is supposed to be meant in a good way because i hardly doubt that there are members who faint upon a bad siggy or a good siggy at that. its just a hyperbole to demonstrate how much you like the siggy...and contrary to prior comments....even if some sigs make you faint...does not mean you have to use it. for examples i have seen some really good aishwarya siggy that have made me "faint" but does not mean that i am going to use it since i don't like her, but i like how they used the pics in the signature
Do you believe that comments have an effect on your work?Good or Bad?
i am encouraged by the comment usually...some times i wish (and am kind of frustrated ) because i want critiques, but then at the same time...i think i would be shocked and feel weird and even resentful if some one did criticize my siggy....which i recognize is being hypocritical😆
Is there anything you have learned from others comments so far?
it might not show in my siggy per say but i do learn tons of things from the comments that i recieve

thanks for yet another thoughtful topic to discuss😳


contingency thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

What kind of commenters do you prefer? Direct, short, to the point OR the one's with long posts describing it to the minute detail?
i usually like all comments esp the long ones that have a lot of funny things on them 😆😳

Why is everyone dying in the section these days? Isn't it better to keep ppl alive by your creations rather than killing them? Then if commenters say they "died" ...is that really good or bad?🤔😉
i think its more of a compliment than anything bcoz when i say "faint" or "dead" i dont do it to say its bad i say it to show how i like it w/o my usual "aaah...and ooooh"😆
Do you believe that comments have an effect on your work?Good or Bad?
i am mostly encouraged because maybe most of the people who comment are my friends they usually have some nice things to say about my siggy
Is there anything you have learned from others comments so far?
i think i learn tons because it tells me which style people like the most and which one i am more comfortable with

thx for an awesome discussion as always very intriguing😳

Related Topics

Avatar and Signatures Shop thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima · 5 years ago

======== ========

Expand ▼
Avatar and Signatures Shop thumbnail

Posted by: Quantum-Dot · 9 months ago

🎨 SimPixel Palette 🎨 ~ New Update 3 Pg 7 (24-6)

W E L C O M E to W H A T I M A K E? • Signatures ~ Book Cover ~ Banners ~ Tags ~ Gifs ~ VMs \\ Both non animated and animated stuffs// C O P Y R...

Expand ▼
Avatar and Signatures Shop thumbnail

Posted by: PriyaArshiSarun · 1 years ago

Hello! Welcome to my shop on A/S forum. I'm Priya Arshi Sarun you can call me Priya or pri. I'm Arshi as well as Wangxian (The Untamed) Lover. I...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".