Nakul shouting @ Simran

The last scene on Asitiva here on Wednesday was Nakul shouting & accusing Simran for breaking his marriage.

What is your opinion about this?

Was he correct at this or should he just keep Sim outof this and deal & talk to Saakshi...

If you were in Nakul's position what would your reaction and thoughts be?

In my opinion, he should certainly not have called her and yelled at her. He should have tried talking to Saakshi and then if he still wasn't satisifed, maybe the three of them could have sat togetehr and talked (IF he wanted Simran involved, it should have been with everyone's consent!). But calling her up and yelling at her would only be a bigger put off for everyone..

He has no business talking to his wife's employer. It is his wife's decision to work there. Just because Simran offerend employment does not mean, she forced her into it.
It is for him and his wife to sort things out.


I cannot think how I would have reacted... hoepfully not this way.

I think it is unprofessional of Nakul to do so. If he claims that he is disgusted with India and all that other nonsense, and that US is better, such a behavior by him would not be appreciated by any employer in the US. He could be sued for slander. So, he needs to make up his mind - does he hate India, does he hate the fact that he doesnt have a woman (his wife BTW) to wait hand and foot on him after he returned home, or does he hate the fact that his wife had her own career and life!

If i were in Nakul's place, (which i could never be, because cannot despise my motherland the way he does) I would have supported my wife as long as she deemed it necessary. It is supposedly a matter of a few months. After a few months, i would have discussed with her what she would rather do and then make a decision accordingly. But i am guessing that it is because he is such a loser that Saakshi is able to break away from him especially since she has the opportunity to fulfil her dream.

which brings me to another point - i thought that sakshi's dream was to work in a rural area, not in a private hospital like Simran's...so how is this a fulfilment of her dream!!!!!!!!! Inconsistencies abound in Astitva!

Originally posted by: krutilynn

I think it is unprofessional of Nakul to do so. If he claims that he is disgusted with India and all that other nonsense, and that US is better, such a behavior by him would not be appreciated by any employer in the US. He could be sued for slander. So, he needs to make up his mind - does he hate India, does he hate the fact that he doesnt have a woman (his wife BTW) to wait hand and foot on him after he returned home, or does he hate the fact that his wife had her own career and life!

If i were in Nakul's place, (which i could never be, because cannot despise my motherland the way he does) I would have supported my wife as long as she deemed it necessary. It is supposedly a matter of a few months. After a few months, i would have discussed with her what she would rather do and then make a decision accordingly. But i am guessing that it is because he is such a loser that Saakshi is able to break away from him especially since she has the opportunity to fulfil her dream.

which brings me to another point - i thought that sakshi's dream was to work in a rural area, not in a private hospital like Simran's...so how is this a fulfilment of her dream!!!!!!!!! Inconsistencies abound in Astitva!

I agree completely.

I don't remember Saakshi saying that she wanted to waork in a rural area? Maybe I missed that episode.. Well, even if she works in Simran's hospital, I guess she has the option of not charging for poorer people (I know some doctors in Apollo do that), but anyways looks like I have been missing a lot here these days:-)

Originally posted by: xyzzee

I agree completely.

I don't remember Saakshi saying that she wanted to waork in a rural area? Maybe I missed that episode.. Well, even if she works in Simran's hospital, I guess she has the option of not charging for poorer people (I know some doctors in Apollo do that), but anyways looks like I have been missing a lot here these days:-)

I dont think that you are missing much...seriously, coz i read Sree's updates, and when i watch the serial, it is just soooooooooo boring. Its kind of like a good book - fun to read but awful to watch. I know that sree updates based on what she watches in india, but she writes is well enough to keep it interesting...the actual visuals on the other hand are uninspiring (well, the storyline has ceased to be inspiring either) but the acting skills are challengeable also. While Nikki is looking better and doing OK in general, she whines too much, and without realizing it has attached herself to the others - so all the talk about 'dont feel sorry for me' seems to be unrealistic when viewed. However, some of the fanciful characterizations get skipped or brief in the written posts, so i prefer those substantially 😊. So, read back a few posts about when Simran remembers Saakshi and you will see that Saakshi had a dream to work in a rural setting. hehehe, dont worry about watching the serial too much! I bet u are busy with work - being end of the year and all...and holidays coming up here in the US, plus diwali, etc.

Originally posted by: krutilynn

I dont think that you are missing much...seriously, coz i read Sree's updates, and when i watch the serial, it is just soooooooooo boring. Its kind of like a good book - fun to read but awful to watch. I know that sree updates based on what she watches in india, but she writes is well enough to keep it interesting...the actual visuals on the other hand are uninspiring (well, the storyline has ceased to be inspiring either) but the acting skills are challengeable also. While Nikki is looking better and doing OK in general, she whines too much, and without realizing it has attached herself to the others - so all the talk about 'dont feel sorry for me' seems to be unrealistic when viewed. However, some of the fanciful characterizations get skipped or brief in the written posts, so i prefer those substantially 😊. So, read back a few posts about when Simran remembers Saakshi and you will see that Saakshi had a dream to work in a rural setting. hehehe, dont worry about watching the serial too much! I bet u are busy with work - being end of the year and all...and holidays coming up here in the US, plus diwali, etc.

Thanks:-) I will read it sometime. Last week was rather light but I expect it to start getting busier next week or so..You are right, sometimes reading the update more than suffices..

HONESTLY IN THIS STUPID SERIAL EVERYONE BLAMES SIMRAN FOR THEIR PROBLMES............ 😡

Originally posted by: mona21

HONESTLY IN THIS STUPID SERIAL EVERYONE BLAMES SIMRAN FOR THEIR PROBLMES............ 😡

..............but don't they do that in alllllll serails !! The main character , usually the hroine of the story is blamed for everything .........if there's a tsunami ....blame her , if there's a robbery ....blame her ,.........someone dies a natural death .......ofcourse blame her !!!!!!!!!!! It happens in Kkusum , Jassi , Reth , piya ka ghar , KSBBT etc etc !!! 😕

As for that Nakul talking like that to an employer ...........as some one in their post said ..........its highly unproffesional coming from some one who talks about valuing proffesionalism !!!😆😆

I disagree with what Nakul said. But Simran was not only an employer for Saakshi. Saakshi adored Simran and she was Sakshi's ideal.

Saakshi did not share an employer-employee relationship with Simran. It was much more than that and Nakul was aware of this, guess that's the reason he called her. He thought that this lady Simran has brain washed his wife and he wanted to take out his frustration. 😕

Simran has also publicized her cell phone in every nook and corner of the world so that people can call her, yell at her and sing endless songs of praises for her. 😃