TOI : Reason why BK & Sid left the show:/ - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

89

Views

8.3k

Users

25

Likes

158

Frequent Posters

Sakuu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#71
Ketu Ketu kya kardiya tumne lol
For the first time I'll have to disagree with you dear, I think that BK and Sid had ample reason to leave the show, their characters were stuck where they started, there wasn't anything new added to it, while there was much scope for improvement.
Yes I am hurt that they left so abruptly, but then again they must've been in talks with the PH for weeks at least, they were after all bound by contract. If the CVs don't give them anything to work with they can't improve their character, I see this as any other job, you want to move ahead, learn new things, you don't want to be a machine that everyday you'll come to work, say dammit Rawte, you're wrong Rawte and that's it.
They had a year to add more depth to the characters, but they did the exact opposite, they started with strong characters, then with new writers, directors etc. The depth declined, and we were left with a chief who was always, always proven wrong, the team took direct orders from the second in command. And there were many more things wrong with the characterization.
Not that they weren't always there, but I always thought that it's an Indian crimedrama, so it's bound to have many bloopers, one of those is that Arjun is still a cop, yes he doesn't miss any details, but after a tragedy strikes you, if you're a cop they usually make you take several psychological tests, which he would never pass, since he is an one man army. He doesn't communicate with the team properly. Yet Rathore and Shree always understood him, which for me was the beauty of the show.
MriduB thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: riyaS2S

thanks fro agreeing 😉
i know.. am just sad to see people blaming BK and sid like this...!!!
right.. phle bhi to khud hi karta tha.. then what was the need of showing these characters???
ab chale gye wo taki main lead he solve kar sake.. tab bhi problem hai...!!!
although am a arjun fan.. but seriously am not liking these accusations on BK and sid..!!!
whats their fault anyway? choosing their satisfaction??
have you seen sid's tweet??? he is quite depressed and people are blaming him..!!
exactly... 4 lions should learn from then.. its been 16 years but still its going great..!!


Welcome!
@Bold 1 :
Wohi toh...🤢 Pata ni BK aur Sid ko kyun blame kar rahe hain! Jabki the show is boring nowadays! I don't follow it but pata lag hi jaata hai ki boring cases aate hain! Blame karo PH ya CV's ko, why BK n sid?🤢

@Bold 2 :
Yeah! Rathore ni hoga toh Arjun ka past? Logon ko vaise koi tension ni Rathore ke character ki...they r more worried abt their Arjun's life!

Haww! Sid depressed? Don't worry Siddy boy! Haters gonna hate! We are waiting for u n Behzaad to come back on screen!

Hell yeah! 4lions should really learn from them! Itne changes toh CID mein ni huye jitne 4lions ke show mein aaye din hote rehte hain!


Ketakee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: Sakuu

Ketu Ketu kya kardiya tumne lol

For the first time I'll have to disagree with you dear, I think that BK and Sid had ample reason to leave the show, their characters were stuck where they started, there wasn't anything new added to it, while there was much scope for improvement.
Yes I am hurt that they left so abruptly, but then again they must've been in talks with the PH for weeks at least, they were after all bound by contract. If the CVs don't give them anything to work with they can't improve their character, I see this as any other job, you want to move ahead, learn new things, you don't want to be a machine that everyday you'll come to work, say dammit Rawte, you're wrong Rawte and that's it.
They had a year to add more depth to the characters, but they did the exact opposite, they started with strong characters, then with new writers, directors etc. The depth declined, and we were left with a chief who was always, always proven wrong, the team took direct orders from the second in command. And there were many more things wrong with the characterization.
Not that they weren't always there, but I always thought that it's an Indian crimedrama, so it's bound to have many bloopers, one of those is that Arjun is still a cop, yes he doesn't miss any details, but after a tragedy strikes you, if you're a cop they usually make you take several psychological tests, which he would never pass, since he is an one man army. He doesn't communicate with the team properly. Yet Rathore and Shree always understood him, which for me was the beauty of the show.



I respect ur POV...😃
Feeling very distress about Arjun you know...
Show ke end ki news aa rahi hai...
Story aage nahi badh rahi...
actors show chhod ke jaa rahe hai...
Rank down ho raha hai...
Ketan bhi show chhod raha hai...
Shital Shah to gumshuda ho gayi hai...usaki missing report koi nahi likh raha...
Isase jyada damage aur koi ho hi nahi sakta Arjun ka...🤢


devildiva21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#74
i completely agree with what both the riya and mridu have written...!!
the actors can't be blamed for the condition of the show...!!!
i very well agree with the reasons they gave...!!! who will want to do a character which isn't given enough screen space... and proved wrong always...!!
as for sid... he himself tweeted that he had other issues.. and he had to leave...!! its the situations which made him leave the show.. so blaming him isn't right...!!!
and as far as the popularity is concerned ... both the actors were popular before arjun.. people started watching only coz of them... half of the people here started watching coz of known names...
and now if they are leaving... people are blaming them.. thats so not done...
as far as the supporting cast thing is concerned... any show will be nothing without them... these characters are also important for the show... it isn't right to always make the lead take the whole screen space...!! for once.. supporting characters can also be shown intelligent...
P.S. sorry if anyone is hurt .. above all is my pov... i know many will disagree with me..!!

Ketakee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: MriduB

@riyaS2S :

Agreed with what u posted!

It's sad to see people blaming them... :( Even though BK n Sid are not at all to be blamed! -_- :(

Ur hero is now acting like a hero...he's the only one solving the cases (oh wait, he used to and still does and forever will do that)...now be happy at that! -_- And stop blaming BK n sid! Stop hurting us guys by posting stuff like that!

PS : Yeah! CID has numerous characters, but still they are going great!



Hey thanks...i don't know how i missed this view of thinking...😃
Loved the way Arjun's mind work...😳

BitterBerry thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: riyaS2S


its for us...the fans that the character of sameer and shree had lot of scope and all..
but if u ask anyone who isn't a fan.. they will say only one thing...
why are they in the show? when the chief is to be proved wrong and all the work is to be done by arjun...
and my dear friend.. i have experienced it that is why i am telling you... i made my friend who isn't a fan to watch this show.. and this was the answer given by him...
its true that their characters were superbly written.. but cv's failed to do justice with them.. if we see... they still haven't been clear with shree's past.. nor with sameer;s past... he was a passionate race driver na... then why did he left that,. nothing has been explained.. we got to know little bit of sameer only coz he is linked with arjun and rosh..
again sorry if i hurted anyone..
just my pov...!!


well leave about rathod and shree.
What is the development in Arjun's character they made.
It was a revenge story. And all we get is some painful past that to once in ablue moon.
And what about arjun stealing sth from that protected room, and that from rathod's cabin.
They could even focus on this track too.
But all arjun doing is solving these cases of psycho killers.
He came here for sikki. Where is he.

Above hundred time it has been discussed, there no progress with the whole story. And if they, makers ain't concern for it, why should actors concern for show?

MriduB thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#77
@devildiva :
Wohi toh...It's Arjun and Arjun only...baaki toh..faltu mein hi aaye hain .-_-

Pata ni kya dukh takleef hai logon ko... :( They should stop blaming BK n Sid!


devildiva21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: MriduB

@devildiva :

Wohi toh...It's Arjun and Arjun only...baaki toh..faltu mein hi aaye hain .-_-

Pata ni kya dukh takleef hai logon ko... :( They should stop blaming BK n Sid!



tell me abt it mridu...!!!
i mean ya... arjun is the lead so its bound that all the focus will be on him...
but baki bhi to important hai...
i agree.. BK and sid aren't to be blamed for all this...!!!
DivineDarkness thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#79
@ RiyaS2S agree with what u said...
Bk or Sid have every right to quit the show... i agree they got strong character but that was not developed in any way in last one year... it remained the same way it was during the initial episode... Plus there screen space was ever decreasing... How long do u expect actors to put up with it... esp senior actors like BK???
it was said that every character in the show has equal importance but it was always Arjun... i'm Arjun fan but have to tell this...
Will u guys blame Shaa if he left the show same way???? he is still there coz it is his first show and contract with SP...
every time rumour about Arjun ending came we got interview of Shaa's wishlist of what he want to do next... even he know this show has not much future...
So are you guys telling Arjun run this long and is popular bcoz it had BK & Sid???? then i guess that is appreciation than blaming!!!

rocking_gal thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#80
Am I late...???
looks like party just started!

I agree with most of who supported BK and Sid...
BK,for me was famous from Geet,when I first saw him in Arjun I remb him well,where as shaa was just a newbie!!!
I dont know whether Bk feels that way or not but we being his fans sure feel that way...he has more to him rather being proved wrong,dammit and being sidelined!!!
Not all blaming shaa for it..he did what was expected 4m him,but I guess CV's failed to show what we were expecting for BK...!!!
Sid, I find little strange...little sympathy and little confusion...
he did justice to his role nd so guys i think thats need to be appreciated,he needs to be move up a little on ladder..cant just stand there and try to touch the roof!!
so he might have felt his char wasnt going anywhere.,
if he has quit for personal reasons than I respect his reasons...!!!
Well for the show...since its ARJUN(sorry for caps)...i guess there is no Pun being used..the show is turning into Arjun and some are expecting it to turn into something else soon..ahem ahem...
Looks like some are blinded or else we are blind,both the ways loss is loss for the show...
I wish the actors all the best for future...

Totally agree with many here..to name a few..Riyas2s,devildiva,riya,leki,mridu...(sorry if Spelled it wrong)

Actors are being blamed for no reason,Its their choice which they had to take because of the situation they were pushed into..and helping themselves out of it is being labelled as wrong..for that Claps guys!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".