it was wrong - Page 2

Originally posted by: devonc89

maybe everyone forgot abt the song bcos of the excitement abt the finals...

it is for THAT reason (ie. that its the grand final) that there should be NO room for mistakes

I am biased in my opinion, becos thru-out I had always loved the East-contestants (even thou am a Centralite), becos they have worked well as a "unit" n not a one-person show as Central have had to demonstrate, but hats off to them, after all they are our punjabi shaan, n rightly so! ..gooooooo Neeti n Preeti! 👏😳

of all teams, West soooooooo did not deserve to win, but as they say LUCK was the winning factor ..n they've had it from the start of this week's episodes *sighs*

on a side note (I've finally broken my peace, so may as well go all out! 😆😳) ..whilst North captains became captains for a reason, they should have relied on their strength now, which has clearly been the Arora sisters (even if they were 3rd place ..in this final countdown, they performed exceptionally under the pressure, unlike the captains n the twins) .grrrrr!

I agree with u saara... actually I forgot to complete my sentence, which I just did 😊 .. and earlier in the post, I did mention this... I was supporting central and east too... Neeti is one man army... I am not from central.. Infact I m from south and my team is not even there... But atleast in these 2 months I thought central was the strongest... and always wished that the best team should win...
and today, it was very evident, how neeti covered up the margin... I guess she deserves some appreciation...

hmmm can anything be done now? i guess not as the show is already shoot

Neeti definately deserved to win. i want her to come to next season and win everything 😛

also it CANNOT be bcz of final's excitement as an episode before there were objetions on very little things (e.g. Neeti's awara hooooonnnnnn hmmmmooo was objected by West)

some times even the very talented expereinced annu kapoor and research team did this small mistakes.

i dont remeber, in last weeks episode's loose control when annu start asking aishwarya and jackie and north click the buzzer an sung the devdas song chalak ,chalka and they got points. after that annu kapoor said that is right and even if they sang gardish song he will give points.
these songs were wrong when antakshari have a very rigid rules how come this is right.

the right song was from the film albela - where aish,jackie starring in two songs
1. Haiyya hoo kya masti kya jaado - featured by aish,jackie, govnda and namrata
2. Dil hamra hua hai kisika pyar shayad hai naam usika - featured by jackie and aish itself

in the finals the research team shouldnt make mistakes but they are making waay too many mistakes which are landing in positive for the west team.

yes. i completely agree with u. only 2 words mistake is valid but they didnt sang so many lines. this is not done.

oh God.....there's one more topic on this...and i have posted my views in that n i dont want to type again n again still........the 2 lines are considerd as dialogue just b'coz it is exactly in the starting it is not a part of song it is just a song starter...see each n everything cannot be sung.....n i dont think itz a part of mukhda....

Hi!!
Marr daala was not a mistake. As the lines "kiski hai aahat.. " etc is not called mukhda. Its prelude. Pls correct me if I am wrong.
In such case humpe yeh kisne is beginning of mukhda.
Just like salaame ishq which central sang. The prelude there is "ishq walon se na pucho ke unki raat ka aalam ......" But mukhda is salaame ishq meri jaan...
They can object and sing prelude like ratika did for "aao huzur.." and sang the loooong prelude.

But the jackie-ash song in celeb special was a definte mistake.
I guess they allowed it bcos they were celbs.

Originally posted by: mini4frienz

Hi!!
Marr daala was not a mistake. As the lines "kiski hai aahat.. " etc is not called mukhda. Its prelude. Pls correct me if I am wrong.
In such case humpe yeh kisne is beginning of mukhda.
Just like salaame ishq which central sang. The prelude there is "ishq walon se na pucho ke unki raat ka aalam ......" But mukhda is salaame ishq meri jaan...
They can object and sing prelude like ratika did for "aao huzur.." and sang the loooong prelude.

But the jackie-ash song in celeb special was a definte mistake.
I guess they allowed it bcos they were celbs.

You are right Salaame ishq song starts from where you are saying it starts. And "this is the part of the song" that's why its there. It is not a dialogue but a Sher which are usually the part of a Mujraa. Central did not sing the song it was east who sang the song and north got -30 because the clues were given by Swati from the north team.

Neeti from Central team sang the song from "Umrao Jaan" and she sang the whole thing I mean she sang the Shaairi part as well as the song. I am sure if she hadn't sung the Sher in the beginning of the song she would have gotten -30 for that. That's how much under scrutiny she has been. If you remember west even objected on the humming of Awaara song and Neeti got minus points for that. I am not a Neeti fan and I am not from Central either but I do command the courage of that girl she has taken central to the finals all by herself despite all the humiliation she got from Juhi many times and from Vijayta Pandit. And today itself if Soumyaa had gotten -30 for singing the song wrong then it would have been Central who would be leading today.👏

hahahahahahaha this is very funny when ppl are arguing on something they sudn't be talkin' about 🤢