Anyone else who felt bad for Prakriti ? - Page 3

i felt like crying when they were giving such comments to her!!!!!!!!!!!

I was quite appalled at the comments. Kunal and Shreya are normally so nice to the kids! And Pritam, whose comments I normally dont care for, was quite nice.
I agree 100% with all those who have stated that her first performance was quite good. I enjoyed it very much and thot she shud've gotten a sarvottam for it!!
When u r actually ignoring the others' mistakes and just njoying their performances, I dont see why only Prakriti's mistakes should be highlighted like this!!
And it does not help stating now that others were better!
The poor girl was so demoralised; is it any surprise that her next performance was worse?? Even when she was seated, she looked so morose

And does this make the judges feel that people will vote less for her, hell, I almost picked up the fone and voted for her!!! Ppl are just going to go all out and vote for her!!
And that brings the question, was the whole thing scripted?? If yes, then am completely disgusted at the level ppl will stoop to!!!!

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Prakriti would have taken constructive criticism in right manner if it was given in professional manner instead of harshly. She is 12 yrs old and judges are in their 20s and 30s for god's sake. I was disappointed in Kunal and Shreya in their delivery of judgement. Their are supposed to be more mature than that.

It is not only what you say but how u say has greater impact IMHO.

OH yes!! Agree 100% on this ... no doubt Prakriti shud have been criticised especially for her 2nd performance but not like this!

And i still believe her 2nd perf wudnt have been so bad if she had not been given such harsh comments for her 1st perf!!!

And Prakriti does sound like a chote ustaad, the other two A's sound and look old enough to participate in Badhe ustaad. Anwesha looks so old and mature in voice and looks.