Phirta rahoon..... Both versions

SAnode

@SAnode

Inactive

9

Posted: 17 years ago

#1

My opinion on Harshit's 'phirta rahoon'

Harshit sang it in sur,good. But i think he missed the passion. The soul of this song is it's passion. It has got both 'dard' and 'junoon' beautifully expressed in it's low and high notes. Honestly i think Toshi was better. He got the passion right.

Reply

Quote

soul76

@soul76

Sparkler

34

Posted: 17 years ago

#2

Can anyone tell me the song which Harshit sang today Phirta rahun darbadar who has sung it originally and what movie is it from?

Reply

Quote

nitzana

@nitzana

Inactive

3

Posted: 17 years ago

#3

I feel the same, SAnode.

Harshit seemed like singing the song only for the sake of competition. Without any feelings. He wasn't enjoying singing it.

Remember... when Toshi sung it... he went in to the song... feeling each and every word... and giving others the feelings...

if the singer is unable to make u feel the song... he's just a singer... not VOICE OF INDIA

Reply

Quote

Ali

@alij79

Inactive

0

Posted: 17 years ago

#4

I agree with you 100%, the soul of this song was completely missing when harshit sang, there was absolutely no feeling, really didnt feel like hearing, and the same when Toshi sang it touched the heart and you felt like hearing it again and again, it was just sooo much soulful...really great

Reply

Quote

Arun

@arun_8687

Inactive

18

Posted: 17 years ago

#5

Originally posted by: blind horizon
Can anyone tell me the song which Harshit sang today Phirta rahun darbadar who has sung it originally and what movie is it from?

Song is by K.K. & Shreya, from the movie 'The Killer'!

Reply

Quote

Abhijit Kulkarni

@kabhi_21

Inactive

29

Posted: 17 years ago

#6

I agree harshit's version did not have soul placed in it completely.... he actually went a little faster to catch the dard, though he had passion.... but he was perfect with surs, lower or higher notes....

u will have to provide link to toshi song to give opinion on who was better as i dont remember his performance.... i remember he had passion, but i know its not his one of best performances so i m not sure 😊

Reply

Quote

Parveen Sibal

@sibal52

Navigator

14

Posted: 17 years ago

#7

Harshits inbuilt udasi shows up negatively in his singing.

Reply

Quote

waseem

@jenious.vip

Inactive

0

Posted: 17 years ago

#8

but i think toshi is sing very nice

Reply

Quote

springs

@springs

Dazzler

21

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

#9

Originally posted by: kabhi_21
I agree harshit's version did not have soul placed in it completely.... he actually went a little faster to catch the dard, though he had passion.... but he was perfect with surs, lower or higher notes....

u will have to provide link to toshi song to give opinion on who was better as i dont remember his performance.... i remember he had passion, but i know its not his one of best performances so i m not sure 😊

Here you go Abhi

http://rapidshare.com/files/53225136/toshi8_tere_pyar_mein.m p3.html

Reply

Quote

springs

@springs

Dazzler

21

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

I just listened to both versions, and I liked Harshit's version better especially at the end of the song 😃

Reply