Vipul didnt deserve to leave - Page 2

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

Agree - they could have kept all the 14 in the finals.. after they had promised.... Anyways, one by one people will start leaving now, leaving a sense of sadness with all!

yes i really wish they had kept all 14, atleast everyone wud've been heard next week and not just a selected few and then no doubts as to this person was not asked to sing or why is this person being asked to sing etc. ... and to catch up they cud've eliminated the bottom 2 for two weeks ... i dont think it wud've been so bad if vipul and even arvind for that matter had been eliminated in this manner ...

Absolutely agree with u.. vipul sang consistantly well and did not deserve to leave...
i thought priyani was the worst this time.. but i think all the men gave her 9 because they had this huge argument and they didnt want their opinion to be proved wrong..
they all said that priyani sang bad but they all gave her the points jus cuz they thought she has potential where as vipul sang waaaay better than priyani but poor him .. couldnt get through the final one..

at the end jatin also said that he felt really bad that vipul had to leave and he should hav given him 9 points..
it was his guilt that he gave priyani 9 even when she didnt sing well and gave vipul 8 when he sang so well..
i guess every judge would have had this feelin deep down in their gut...

so many ppl left so far but this time i actually cried my heart out cuz that guy didnt deserve to go.. i know this is a game one person will b leavin each n every week but i would have loved if vipul stayed..
but 😭

Vipul did not even deserve to be heard once more...I have no idea what the judges were thinking when they asked him to sing again......

They should have asked Prantik Sur to sing instead. And 10 to Ishmit? What was Aadesh thinking??? It was his song, and even Shaan said where he had gone wrong... 🤢

Whether he was a good enough voice to be in the bemisaal barah or not is a total different question

It was the biggest act of two facedness by the 4 "what do they call thems(I seriously dont remember 😆 )", just b'cos they wanted Priyani in the show, they wanted to make someone a bakra, and that bakra turned out to be Vipul, who by all means sang better than Priyani on that night, and everyone keeps on claiming "oh how you sing that night is all that matters". Whatever happened to that logic

The only judge who was able to give a proper reason and which was beleivable was Alka(and incidently she is getting called names for that 😉 )

It is like a kid tries his level best to acheive something and gets sidelined just b'cos of someone's favortism. All too common a thing to happen in India, just didnt think it would be seen on a reality show in such a open manner, it seems sensibilities on this topic have so become numbed that nobody cares anymore.

I wonder why Aadesh gave Ishmeet 10 marks on that day 😕 Prantik Sur and Prantika deserve to be heard once more not Vipul

its kinda sad...vipul was really talented...i felt bad that the judges raised his hopes so much and then shattered it all in one day...if he was the least deserving singer, i wouldnt care much about the judges decision...however, vipul was actually one of the top scorers throughout the competition ( i agree, sooner or later someone had to leave, but did vipul really deserve to that day?)

Yes it was sad to see Vipul let go. But I guess that is going to happen from now.... lettign someone go.